Lynden Dunn unrestricted free agent

[pitmaster 3,513]

Sensational kick. Impactful defender. His detractors are clueless.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

I'll miss him, if he goes...

[Undeeterred 3,123]

Olisik, I don't agree with you much, but you're definitely on to something here, although pushing it uphill against a tide of people who just don't get it.

[whatwhat say what 22,700]

i rate him, and have always done so.

he was great on debut vs hawks in 06, so i've always had a soft spot for him. remember those heady days when we belted teams by 75 points. team like fricken hawthorn???

13 possessions, 8 marks, 2 goals 2. i thought we had the next schwarz on our hands!

he got crucified by bailey.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Dunn plays his best footy in seasons that his contract is up for renewal. Don't expect him to be re-signed until at least midway through the season.

[Sir Why You Little 36,983]

Hope he stays

[praha 11,236]

If the club loses Frawley and Dunn in the same year, our backline would be similarly as inept and dysfunctional as the midfield was in 2013.

Would be a step backwards.

[Sir Why You Little 36,983]

If the club loses Frawley and Dunn in the same year, our backline would be similarly as inept and dysfunctional as the midfield was in 2013.

Would be a step backwards.

Only if we cannot replace them.

If these guys do not want to sign the club has to move on fast.

Are these the last 2 remaining from 186?

[old dee 23,781]

Only if we cannot replace them.

If these guys do not want to sign the club has to move on fast.

Are these the last 2 remaining from 186?

NO

[Ted Lasso 19,307]

He is playing the best footy of his career so i'd like him to stay, but if he leaves i won't be upset either, much more concerned with what his mate in number 8 does

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

i rate him, and have always done so.

he was great on debut vs hawks in 06, so i've always had a soft spot for him. remember those heady days when we belted teams by 75 points. team like fricken hawthorn???

13 possessions, 8 marks, 2 goals 2. i thought we had the next schwarz on our hands!

he got crucified by bailey.

Ungracious slur at Bailey and it's complete bullish too.

Dunn had his best year of football under Bailey.

As another poster said this is his 10th and his best has been fleeting and his performance over his career below mediocre.

He has had 3 coaches over his tenure and not delivered under any of them notwithstanding he has been tried continually in nearly every position. He has had nearly 120 games of AFL football, loads of chances and not made a position his own. It's even worse when you consider how bereft of talent we have been over the past seven years.

His career has been marked by timidity in the contest and faux acts of toughness (jumper punching) which have ever hopefully supporters sucked in that he's the real deal

As a first round pick he is another in a long line of poor picks. I hope he does start to contribute as a competent footballer going forward. And I won't be getting excited from playing pre season running in straight lines of half back.

Chris (son of) Johnson anyone?

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

If the club loses Frawley and Dunn in the same year, our backline would be similarly as inept and dysfunctional as the midfield was in 2013.

Would be a step backwards.

Frawley yes.

Dunn...you're kidding.

[Nasher 33,607]

Some people seem to equate "I'd prefer Lynden Dunn stayed but wouldn't lose any sleep if he went" to "I hate Lynden Dunn and can't wait for him to leave". Frustrating.

[Hannibal 5,814]

I would be happy if he re-signed.

Semantics, you just gotta love 'em!

I have a feeling he meant what he typed.

[chookrat 4,247]

Dunn is in our first 10 picked every week. He consistently beats his opponent, is an excellent kick and is always available for selection. Further he plays well irrespective of how the overal team is performing.

If we are to become a decent side then players like Dunn need to finish their careers as 150+ game clubmen.

[Satyriconhome 10,729]

He has been on the list for 10 years, olisik.

If he is 'in his prime' it is the near the end of it - that is how long he has taken to become a productive role player.

And it is a HBF - I am sorry to all the HBFs out there but it is the easiest position to play in the world ever.

How many games of AFL did you play in that possie, hiding your light under a bushel?

We nurture players like Dunn, Watts and Spencer for years and as soon as one comes good everyone is happy to see him go. Sigh

O, you have to remember you are dealing with some posters who forget to face the green bit now and again, Roos has Dunn doing the kick outs, so he obviously sees something in him and in the season guide Roos said "hopefully we will see him play his best football" , so that will do me

[nutbean 8,838]

He is certainly playing his best football and hopefully can further improve under better structures and disciplines that Roos is bringing to the team.

But lets not rewrite his career to date with us.

[DeeSpencer 25,477]

How many games of AFL did you play in that possie, hiding your light under a bushel?

O, you have to remember you are dealing with some posters who forget to face the green bit now and again, Roos has Dunn doing the kick outs, so he obviously sees something in him and in the season guide Roos said "hopefully we will see him play his best football" , so that will do me

Don't you think that Roos saying 'hopefully' in a sentence mentioning Dunn almost proves the point that to date he's been horribly inconsistent. So far I'd be shocked if any teams have interest.

I'm hoping Dunn has a really good year. I think he can be top 10 B+F and a reliable best 22 player. Even be a reliable best 22 in a team that isn't hopeless that would be nice. And yes we are short on defenders and versatile ones are pretty important.

[old dee 23,781]

Don't you think that Roos saying 'hopefully' in a sentence mentioning Dunn almost proves the point that to date he's been horribly inconsistent. So far I'd be shocked if any teams have interest.

I'm hoping Dunn has a really good year. I think he can be top 10 B+F and a reliable best 22 player. Even be a reliable best 22 in a team that isn't hopeless that would be nice. And yes we are short on defenders and versatile ones are pretty important.

I think that is the nub of our situation tm.

As Dees supporters we tend to have an inflated opinion of our player list.

We have been in the bottom 3 -4 sides for almost all of the last decade under Three main coaches.

That says to me our list is poor.

We have lots of players on the list who are not AFL standard but as supporters we want to believe that Joe Blogg is after five years on the list just in need of a good coach.

The reality is that Joe is not up to it.

with the exception of 5 -6 players the fact that a player has played regularly for the MFC proves only that he is one of the better ones of a poor lot.

When we get to being a competitive team I will be impressed by players that are regulars.

IMO The test of a player is how many would the top four sides want from the MFC.

The answer for me is probably about five.

Another five might make a bottom half of the ladder side

The rest would find themselves in the WAFL, SANFL or the VFL.

Edited March 11, 2014 by old dee

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,693]

I know I'm repeating what I've written many times before. Dunn is a very good kick for goal, but not a good field kick. People mistake distance for quality. His long kicks travel too high and therefore take too long to land. That works perfectly fine when kicking for goal but not when trying to get the ball into the hands of a teammate. His kicks allow the opposition to get to the drop of the ball and spoil.

The best kicks are those who get distance while keeping the ball low. It travels more quickly and is therefore more effective. It's what Jack Watts can do (as could Jurrah, Nathan Buckley and the player I consider to be the best kick I've ever seen - Darren Jarman).

With respect to Dunn, until last year I didn't think he was worth holding onto. After his performances last year I can see some value in him being on the list but see no reason to lose sleep in the unlikely event another team picks him up as a free agent.

[Hannibal 5,814]

^^^

I'm not sure I agree.

Some of his long switches from one side of the ground to the other have worked well this preseason and are tailor made to Roos' game-plan.

[rpfc 28,262]

How many games of AFL did you play in that possie, hiding your light under a bushel?

I really hate this sentiment. I haven't played AFL so I can't tell you which position is the easiest to play at AFL level?

You can come down of your high horse, you look out of place up there.

I can tell you from the experience, however limited, that HBF is the easiest place to play on the ground in a football match of Aussie Rules.

I don't need your affirmation - I can own my own opinion.

[Deez 298]

He is a good player. played some good footy last year, looks good this year. I would suggest he is certainly a required player.

[Moonshadow 17,675]

O, you have to remember you are dealing with some posters who forget to face the green bit now and again, Roos has Dunn doing the kick outs, so he obviously sees something in him and in the season guide Roos said "hopefully we will see him play his best football" , so that will do me

If the word 'hopefully' will do for you then you are easily pleased Saty.

It's a nothing statement, of course Roos hopes every player will play their best football this season.

[CBDees 3,167]

Don't think that Chip, McDonald and Judy are our only three [tallish] defenders, both Dunn and Georgiou will be important to Roos this year, particularly if we get any injuries to the first three. Also Dunn is capable of going forward and kicking a goal and we certainly need some reserve back-up options up there.