POST MATCH DISCUSSION

[bjDee 1,249]

Just so sick of all the turnovers. We hardly ever get to keep possession of the ball for more than a third or half the field before gifting it back to the opposition.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

I desperately need some good news. Please Melbourne do something or sack someone.

you consider someone losing their job as "good news".

Ummmm ooohhhh kkkkkk...backing away slowly now...

[Roger Mellie 3,991]

Cant see us getting anywhere with McKenzie, Dunn and Jones at the centre bounce - and NOT just occasionally. WTF?

Inspired

[Pennant St Dee 13,118]

What I did notice was the Blues chipping it around until they got it to a player in position to kick a goal. When we get the ball we hack it forward, if we are lucky or kick it sideways to the opposition. For every chip I'll see you with a misdirected hack.

Give me cheap possessions over none any day, give me a kick to a team mate over a hack to the opposition. I just can't understand how anyone can defend today's debacle, it looked to me as if Carlton were just going half pace.

I'm not defending it, I am providing a reason for the indifference, why does any person who provides a differing view have to be accepting mediocrity or happy with losing in other supporters eyes

not having a go with the next statement but not sure if or what level you played Robbie but think back to playing with confidence down and you just want to get the ball away so you don't get caught you just hack it as far away as possible. It's sad but you are selfish and would rather not be the one who lets the team down, I've been there and it is only experience that helps you develop the temperament. Although some boys just step in from day 1 with a cool head

Carlton may have looked half paced today but we brought some intensity today and in my eyes showed there is something to work with

[drdrake 3,163]

They tried today, just had no polish and nothing up forward. Bad turn overs thar where just deflating. You just cant turn the footy over off half back. Good effort, we are just not good enough

[Return to Glory 8,412]

There were some real positives today but I've got to say, McKenzie isn't one of them. He is very, very slow.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Why the hell don't we ever handball and link up coming out of defence? Its just kicking, all we do is kick. Run the bloody footy! Neeld what are you doing?!?!

Because every time we handball we pick out the opposition or a team mate that's under more pressure than we are. Our players have no idea how to position themselves and create space. How many times today did we actually trip over our own team mate, or spoil him in a marking contest, we either have all up or no one up. We continually kick the ball in to the forward line to the advantage of the defender not our own forward.

Notice how we always seem to be on the boundary line waiting for the handball and leaving ourselves no where to go, whereas they had men free in the middle waiting for the ball to come out. We really have no idea.

[Mr Steve 3,820]

I know it's hard to believe but we are moving forward. Saw a lot of good signs today. Just to easy to join the Negative team.

[saka888 54]

Well done Dunn.. kept judd to only 13 disposals....

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

Any news on Grimes?

you wanna build a culture? Trengove needs a spell in the VFL either he's not fit or he is out of form, either means he shouldn't be in an AFL team others had to earn a spot in.

McDonald can go with him.

[daisycutter 29,605]

I have never seen a team beaten so comprehensively in marking contests - absolutely rubbish

this is apart from the appalling skills and decision making

a better team would have beat us by more than 100 points

i really don't think i can watch this anymore

[DEELIRIOUS 156]

When we lose next week, this site will be going into overdrive, then we shall see what everyone has to say

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

When we lose next week, this site will be going into overdrive, then we shall see what everyone has to say

We won't. Dawes and Fitzpatrick will come in and lookout, we suddenly have a forward line again.

[Return to Glory 8,412]

Just got home. On a negative note, we still kick to packs or certainly not to advantage. On a positive note, there was a semblance of desperation, Tapscott is a competitor, Kent did ok and love the development of a Michael Evans.

[Moonshadow 17,675]

Some amazingly bad skill errors, particularly in disposal. I like Tom Mc, but his kicking is just awful. Appears as if the preseason was all fitness work and no skill development.

[Demon Jack 6,862]

Our forward structure was a mess today.

Gawn was our key target today and he tried hard but couldnt hit the scoreboard.

Where were our crumbers today? I didn't see Byrnes much and I have no idea why Davey was dropped.

Kent tried hard in his first game and did ok. He looks like a tough footballer.

Howe had no impact and Trengove couldn't impose himself when he was moved to FF.

Hopefully Dawes is fit and firing and will play next week.

The Gold Coast game next week has suddenly become very similar to the GWS one in that it may cost Mark Neeld his job if we lose. We need a win, a big win.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I think I saw Strauss about three times.

[bush demon 2,039]

I don't know what's more disappointing out of Melbourne's fade out after 2006, John Lennon's fadeout after 1968 or Lynda Carroll's item on demon swapcards which totally ignores our glory era of the 50's and 60's.

[Chook 15,012]

I think I saw Strauss about three times.

I've never seen what others see in him.

[whatwhat say what 22,702]

I would be curious to know if Dunn put his hand ip and asked for the job on Judd.

His effort was outstanding.

Our skills are non-existent. Just woeful. We can't hit targets clear and under little pressure.

[Demon Jack 6,862]

I think I saw Strauss about three times.

Same, all in the first quarter.

[71 Molloy 266]

Frustrating, but I'm not totally doom and gloom. Happy with the fact we had a crack after losing Grimes early. Our newer draftees are showing something and some of the older players like Frawley and Garland look like they are retuning to some form.

If, and it's a big if, we can clean up our foot skills we will improve rapidly (as in get ut of bottom 4....). We should have drawn even at half time but for lack of finishing and those agonising defensive turn overs.

Some +ves for me

• Spencil and Gawn could be a good tandem combination.
• Tappy showed some physicality. If he can bring 4 1/4's.......
• Matt jones. Keeper

Some -ves

• Bail. Needs to nail his opportunities. We need score board pressure and he should have kicked 6 in the past fortnight.
• Tom Mc. Get hm out until he fixes his kicking.
• Trengrove. Must be injured.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Frustrating, but I'm not totally doom and gloom. Happy with the fact we had a crack after losing Grimes early. Our newer draftees are showing something and some of the older players like Frawley and Garland look like they are retuning to some form.

If, and it's a big if, we can clean up our foot skills we will improve rapidly (as in get ut of bottom 4....). We should have drawn even at half time but for lack of finishing and those agonising defensive turn overs.

Some +ves for me

• Spencil and Gawn could be a good tandem combination.
• Tappy showed some physicality. If he can bring 4 1/4's.......
• Matt jones. Keeper

Some -ves

• Bail. Needs to nail his opportunities. We need score board pressure and he should have kicked 6 in the past fortnight.
• Tom Mc. Get hm out until he fixes his kicking.
• Trengrove. Must be injured.

it'll come.

[71 Molloy 266]

it'll come.

God I hope so. How much longer do we wait?

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

God I hope so. How much longer do we wait?

Well he has played 25 games.

It'll click.