A LITTLE WIN

[Undeeterred 3,124]

It's damning that the Dees lost the disposal count by 70, but also lost the tackle count by 22. Five of the top 6 tacklers on the ground were eagles - Selwood had 12 alone.

Surprisingly, Melbournes top tackler was Jamar with 6. He also convincingly won the hit out count (not sure how many were to advantage, though). He was absolutely rubbish around the ground though - 5 disposals for Jamar, while Cox racked up 24 and 3.2. That kind of trouncing puts a side at a huge disadvantage these days. It's as if the opposition have an extra player on the field in open play.

Jamar has never been able to run with mobile ruckmen like Jolly and Cox and they routinely rip us a new one. At least Spencer and Gawn can run with them.

[Undeeterred 3,124]

He's already had more than a year.

4 wins from 25 games.

Go back and look at Clarkson's, Hardwick's and Ratten's results in their first couple of years.

Sacking the coach now would be utterly ridiculous. Where would that get us??

[stuie 7,374]

Go back and look at Clarkson's, Hardwick's and Ratten's results in their first couple of years.

Sacking the coach now would be utterly ridiculous. Where would that get us??

Tell me what the average losing margin was for those guys in their 2nd year....

Neeld's is 107 points so far.

Edited April 13, 2013 by stuie

[dees189227 12,398]

Is Maxy right to come in soon. Jamr needs help and when maxy did play those games he did ok.

Matt Jones I was impressed with. he is taking his opportunity and Turlich but someone else should be taking that kick out not him.

[LegsLeoncelli 162]

In reality if any coach is ever in charge of a side that is outscored 11

goals to 1 in a quarter he needs to go.

Oh well, after today Neeld and Brad Scott are both looking for new jobs.

[stuie 7,374]

Go back and look at Clarkson's, Hardwick's and Ratten's results in their first couple of years.

Sacking the coach now would be utterly ridiculous. Where would that get us??

Hawks improved from 14th to 11th in Clarksons' second year.

Richmond went from 15th to 12th in Hardwick's second year.

Carlton went from 11th to 7th in Ratten's second year.

What was your point again?

[T-34 409]

Lost count of Melbourne players ball watching while their opponent gut ran to provide an option.

Our players simply don't work hard enough when they aren't directly involved in play.

This is why they can't maintain pressure when they try man on man, they don't understand the concept of running off the ball.

First half was the result of hard work, second half was a return to normal programming.

Please no more Jamar, we need to move on.

[Hardnut 327]

Before MN was appointed senior coach at MFC, can anyone tell me who else was interviewed for the job?

[Adam The God 30,406]

Very worrying second half.

The bottom line is that we have at least 5 (probably more) players running around that are just not up to AFL-standard.

Mark Jamar should have his contract torn up and be shown the door. Fed up with him. Cox is a superstar but the amount of times he was in a paddock forward of the centre was ludicrous.

Players today who earnt their stripes, or went up in my estimations as AFL players were Tapscott, M. Jones, Terlich.

Players who I think we need to stop kidding ourselves over, and realise are probably not AFL-standard anymore (or perhaps never were): Byrnes, Garland, Sellar

Really? My god. Terlich looks lost out there and makes some horrible decisions. He was only playing his second game, but not great signs. Jones got a bit of the ball, but I still cannot wipe that image of him walking, unaccountable on the wing, while Jack Viney desperately chased two Eagles.

Tapscott got a bit of the ball, but what the heck is with his overhead marking? For a bloke that has shoulders the size of tree trunks, it's all about confidence, technique and ability. I really want Tappy to succeed, but he has to offer more. Today was probably his best game in MFC colours and that's saying something.

[Hardnut 327]

No-one wants to sack a coach anytime, let alone early in a season, but MN has to go - the players put in hard today (at least in the first half), so it isn't their fault in that sense (and the ones he chose didn't do very well IMO). The players looked totally lost when it came to decision making, and in particular when it came to deciding the quickest and easiest way to goal - that's a part of coaching - MN and NC to go asap!

[Grimes is Great 183]

How were Pederson & Sellar today and did either of them play in defence?

[Adam The God 30,406]

Today showed we can do it. We can match other better teams in contested footy. So - Neeld can coach and we can play. For 2 quarters anyway.

We also showed that we are mentally weak. When a team gets a run-on against us, we cannot stem the flow.

WE continue to show that our structure/positioning through the middle of the ground is the worst in the AFL. Watson and Heppel last week. Kerr, Priddis, Gaff etc... this week were playing 3 verses 1 on multiple occasions.

Pedersen, Sellar - what can I say? They remind of Richmond's back line about 5 years ago. Give Davis, Fitzy a go.

Jamar. How far has this bloke fallen?

N Jones, M Jones, Terlich (kicking excepted) were good toady

Trengove, Sylvia, Tapscott, got in and had a go.

Bail and Evans showed some grunt and run.

I agree, but who would you lay the blame with here? Has to be Neeld and Royal or merely Neeld. In other words, Neeld can't coach.

[Adam The God 30,406]

How were Pederson & Sellar today and did either of them play in defence?

I thought Sellar did his job down back, while Pederson tried hard, but was generally ineffectual.

[drdrake 3,187]

I would drop Frawley, play Sellar as key back and bring in Gawn, Sellar is a better option than Frawley.

[frankie_d 1,471]

'Melbourne fans again booed their team at three-quarter time.'

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/eagles-inflict-more-misery-on-lowly-demons-20130413-2hs7l.html

No we didn't. I didn't hear much, but I suspect it was directed at the umpiring, which for the third quarter was heavily in West Coast's favour (the holding the ball against Clark was awful, the holding the man against Garland was worse).

Whoever wrote this garbage can GAGF.

Completely correct. No booing of the team at all

[DEELIRIOUS 156]

Before MN was appointed senior coach at MFC, can anyone tell me who else was interviewed for the job?

Ken Hinckley

Sanderson

[machine11 142]

Hawks improved from 14th to 11th in Clarksons' second year.

Richmond went from 15th to 12th in Hardwick's second year.

Carlton went from 11th to 7th in Ratten's second year.

What was your point again?

They didn't have seven years of bad recruiting. Even in Richmonds case, they had a stock of quality players before Hardwick turned up.

[machine11 142]

Ken Hinckley

Sanderson

Do you seriously think these two could do a better job with this list?

[DeeSpencer 26,079]

Anyone want to kill (sorry can't say that), shoot in the leg (probably not allowed), direct bad energy towards Ashton hams.

What a disgrace of a footballer.

West coast should be ashamed of his leg dropping rubbish. At least when rivers did it to him he let him know about it.

[DEELIRIOUS 156]

Do you seriously think these two could do a better job with this list?

Who had more talent and better prospects in pre season of 2012 and 2013 seasons? Us both times and both clubs have trounced us.

[Gorgoroth 13,016]

Completely correct. No booing of the team at all

Yeah all of it near me was at the maggots in lime.

[DemonOX 8,800]

The sad thing in all this is that if we had another 2-3 mids along with Jones and Viney, we would be good.

Our forward line is good and our back line is good too despite what is going on. You cant expect the backline to be performing when the bloody pill is in there half for 80% of the game.

First half I was actually enjoying watching the boys for the first time in a long time. Second half it was back to normal unfortunately.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

It's sad that we have to hang our hat on Matt Jones and Terilich being good finds, they are average at best.

We tried to match the Weagles and did for two quarters, but once the adrenaline runs out it gets back to a talented side against an untalented side, it's all over, which it was.

We don't have the cattle and once again we have drafted poorly, we have [censored] midfield and did nothing about it, instead we've picked up several players that were deemed to be superfluous by their existing clubs, they have actually weakened our list not improved it. When someone said Neeld hadn't made our list worse, well you are wrong he has.

There should not be that much difference between the top and bottom sides in the competition, but there is and it's scary; history has shown that a change from a poor coach to a good coach can make a big difference. Eade/Roos, Schimmelbusch/Pagan, Walls/Matthews etc.etc. I'm not saying we have a list like theirs but it can't be as bad as it seems now, surely.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

One other thing, I know it's been done to death, but I nearly cried every time Darling kicked a goal, how stupid are we?

[Hardnut 327]

Ken Hinckley

Sanderson

Thanks Deelirious - and your source is?