Ben Jacobs

[rpfc 27,646]

I can see your argument rpfc but I'm unsure if you have a reason for the opinion or its just general negativity.

Given ND opens him to the risk of Port picking him up (as they have threatened) the PSD does offer him benefits if his true goal is returning to Vic.

Given he holds the choice, persuasion is possible.

If we don't see a better option out there...

I don't know. We can always have the discussion.

Or he can do a Luke Ball and make it more difficult.

We will see.

[Guest José Mourinho]

Definitely could do without the PSD, but then how much of a chance would we have of getting him then?

I reckon players in his position with potential suitors (as opposed to desperate hope that someone will want them) tend to choose the relative certainty of the PSD.

We have to try to convince him he'd be better going in the PSD so he can get to us, while Port will be doing their best to convince him that GWS or GCS will take him first, so might as well stay with the devil you know.

[mordja 187]

If we don't see a better option out there...

I don't know. We can always have the discussion.

Or he can do a Luke Ball and make it more difficult.

We will see.

Send Mitch round with a blowtorch and a hammer.

[rpfc 27,646]

Send Mitch round with a blowtorch and a hammer.

All for getting him in the PSD - but wouldn't mind seeing what is out there first.

Doubt there is much...

[Pennant St Dee 11,489]

Don't think we will get him in the ND but if our FD want him pretty sure if we got in his ear and guaranteed to him we would take him pick 3 in PSD and he makes it clear he wants home to Victoria then we should be able to snare him

Edited October 26, 2012 by Pennant St Dee

[Brian Wilson 331]

I spoke with his parents yesterday. He's here in Melbourne should MFC want to talk to him, but he hasn't had direct contact (only indirect, through his manager). He's desperate to return home, for family, girlfriend and footy.

[Redleg 38,062]

I spoke with his parents yesterday. He's here in Melbourne should MFC want to talk to him, but he hasn't had direct contact (only indirect, through his manager). He's desperate to return home, for family, girlfriend and footy.

Lets hope we want him.

[Deestroy All 14,262]

Send Mitch round with a blowtorch and a hammer.

And a tattoo gun.

'MFC4LIFE'

[pantaloons 2,019]

Can you nominate your price in the national draft? I didn't think you could. In which case, it's another reason the PSD would be preferable for him.

[Nascent 7,475]

Can you nominate your price in the national draft?

Luke Ball

[pantaloons 2,019]

Luke Ball

No worries. I wondered about Ball. Though did he just nominate the Pies as his team or did he specifically put a price on his head? Money wouldn't have been a deterrent for Melbourne, but him refusing to play for us would.

[Guest José Mourinho]

Ball priced other teams out of contention, considering it was just too much to shell out for a bloke who had suffered chronic OP yet wouldn't even submit himself for a medical.

[Tatu 416]

Hopefully we can get this kid in the psd.... That would put a dint in the disappointment I have, over the losing a number 4 draft pick for pick 88.....

[Nascent 7,475]

No worries. I wondered about Ball. Though did he just nominate the Pies as his team or did he specifically put a price on his head? Money wouldn't have been a deterrent for Melbourne, but him refusing to play for us would.

He did both, while publicly shunning melbourne in the process... my hate for Mr Ball started that day whilst simultaneously stoking my collingwood rage... Perhaps I should let that anger go, It's like that old saying. Fear leads to anger. Anger leads to hate. Hate leads to anger. No, wait. Fear leads to hate, hate leads to the dark side. Hold on, no... First you get the women, then you get the money, then you... Okay, we'll forget that.

[MadAsHell 4,089]

Correct me if im wrong, but in this time of free agency, cant he just sign with whoever he wants. Not sure if there even is a PSD this year?

Only delisted players can. Jacobs would have walked out on his club, not delisted so it's slightly different.

[Neita3000 37]

Hopefully we're doing our due diligence with this kid. He's ours for the taking

[dee-luded 2,958]

I spoke with his parents yesterday. He's here in Melbourne should MFC want to talk to him, but he hasn't had direct contact (only indirect, through his manager). He's desperate to return home, for family, girlfriend and footy.

Hmmn, interesting on all levels.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Lets hope we want him.

Well, do we?

[Daz's Dee's 113]

If he has attitude problems as reported why would we go near him isn't that the reason a few players were traded/delisted?

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

I'd have an attitude problem too if I had to play for Port.

[Brian Wilson 331]

If he has attitude problems as reported why would we go near him isn't that the reason a few players were traded/delisted?

Those reports are incorrect.

In any case, Ben Jacobs was not traded/delisted. Port have been trying to extend his contract from the day they drafted him.

[rpfc 27,646]

If he has attitude problems as reported why would we go near him isn't that the reason a few players were traded/delisted?

Those that left were massive projects that we didn't have time for.

More than happy to bring in blokes with attitude issues IF they can play footy...

[Deestroy All 14,262]

I'd have an attitude problem too if I had to play for Port.

LoL

[old55 21,657]

Will likely nominate for the ND.

[Whispering_Jack 28,094]

Will likely nominate for the ND.

If that's the case then we have no hope of getting him to the club. Who knows where he'll end up in the ND?

We would have to come to an agreement with his management to go into the PSD. That's the test for our our football department if, in fact, he's in their sights.