Goddard Gone..

[DemonDan... 77]

Apparently, as mentioned on the radio today..

Brendan Goddard has been made an offer 'to good to refuse,' to leave the saints..

Can anyone add to this?

Is this a good move if it was us?

EDIT: here's a link to that radio segment in question.. Thanks Oucher..

http://www.sen.com.au/audioplayer/Audio/Dermott-Brereton-on-Brendon-Goddard/5627

Edited August 20, 2012 by DemonDan...

[Nasher 33,616]

Thank Dog it's some other club feeling the heat with player departures this year.

[w00dy 146]

I haven't seen much of him this year, and have heard he's gone backwards, but if we've got the cash I'd love to have him at the Dees.

[jayceebee31 761]

It is believed that he is heading to Lyonland--Fremantle.

[beelzebub 23,380]

It is believed that he is heading to Lyonland--Fremantle.

without any basis whatsoever to beleive this it would make sense.

i rate Goddard. Would be an ideal pickup....*sigh*

[Deers 202]

GWS and Fremantle tabled $1 million offers to Goddard and they were knocked back.

The captaincy will be given to him as a reward for loyalty and Riewoldt is happy to step aside.

Money isn't the big drawcard here. Whilst a glorious seven-figure sum from the aforementioned clubs would "set him up for life", fact is he plays off 1 on the golf course. That'll look after him post-footy.

[Range Rover 1,935]

GW$ for sure

[DemonDan... 77]

I'd give him $3 - $3.5 over 4 yrs, imagine the benefits the midfield (and the watts' an tommy macs) would get from him..

this is what the War Chest is for!

Edited August 20, 2012 by DemonDan...

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Goddard has lost his edge at 28. Gets lots of the ball but has less impact than he used to. Picking up possessions on his terms and playing easy football. Idont want him but he would fit into the senior player culture at MFC very well though.

[Lucifers Hero 39,941]

We already have a Goddard...his name is Jack Watts!

[Range Rover 1,935]

Goddard has lost his edge at 28. Gets lots of the ball but has less impact than he used to. Picking up possessions on his terms and playing easy football. Idont want him but he would fit into the senior player culture at MFC very well though.

Very much agree. Would prefer Lenny Hayes if he was available, even to get a season or two out of him in his twighlight years.

Give me Lenny Hayes going at half rat power over Goddard anyday.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

Goddard is a no for me. I don't want to pay that much for a floating half back. Key position players are a lot harder to find and therefore are more expensive. I don't think a older version of watts is worth squillions.

[Junior84 1]

GWS and Fremantle tabled $1 million offers to Goddard and they were knocked back.

The captaincy will be given to him as a reward for loyalty and Riewoldt is happy to step aside.

Money isn't the big drawcard here. Whilst a glorious seven-figure sum from the aforementioned clubs would "set him up for life", fact is he plays off 1 on the golf course. That'll look after him post-footy.

I'm a golf pro and I can guarantee a 1 handicapper isn't going to win millions playing on the tour... He should take what he can get in his last years playing footy! Hope it's with the dees...

[John Crow Batty 8,871]

At his age, only a club who reckon they have a premiership window opening would want him for big bucks. Not us. Fremantle would be in the picture.

Edited August 20, 2012 by america de cali

[DemonDan... 77]

Think the saints have been down this year, not Goddard in particular..

Only just turned 27 y.o.. Rhino..

Would take the opponents best mid at the centre bounce.. (where i would play him)

-30 touches 10 marks against the cats best, last round..

I would prefer Dayne Beams or Harley Bennell in a heartbeat, but will Goddard be the best available mid/utility/player this year?? ..still well worthy of a Dees jumper..

[Demon SeaMan 108]

Don't want him, he seriously looks like he's lost his edge. I have watched him this year, and if he doesn't want to be there, why hasn't Watters relegated him. Let's leave this please...., and at that money IMO the war chest would seriously be wasted

[jnrmac 20,104]

Would rather him than CLoke.

[Range Rover 1,935]

At his age, only a club who reckon they have a premiership window opening would want him for big bucks. Not us. Fremantle would be in the picture.

Or a club that have big bucks and can't afford to go through another year getting belted by 100+ points every other week when they're trying to attract supporters to a new market.

[pantaloons 2,019]

At his age, only a club who reckon they have a premiership window opening would want him for big bucks. Not us. Fremantle would be in the picture.

I don't completely disagree with your premise, but it's pretty optimistic for a team that is going to miss the finals (as they have done for 15 of their 18 seasons) like Freo to think they are entering their premiership window.

[John Crow Batty 8,871]

Or a club that have big bucks and can't afford to go through another year getting belted by 100+ points every other week when they're trying to attract supporters to a new market.

Our ineptidude has already been confirmed. Getting him would be rubbing it in. I would prefer Cloke any day over Goddard.

[John Crow Batty 8,871]

I don't completely disagree with your premise, but it's pretty optimistic for a team that is going to miss the finals (as they have done for 15 of their 18 seasons) like Freo to think they are entering their premiership window.

I believe they have a ticket on themselves. And they look pretty good this season with Lyon coaching. Better than for a hell of a long time.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Think the saints have been down this year, not Goddard in particular..

Only just turned 27 y.o.. Rhino..

Would take the opponents best mid at the centre bounce.. (where i would play him)

-30 touches 10 marks against the cats best, last round..

I would prefer Dayne Beams or Harley Bennell in a heartbeat, but will Goddard be the best available mid/utility/player this year?? ..still well worthy of a Dees jumper..

He will be 28 at his new club.

I fear he has lost the intensity in a game. His 30 possessions these days just dont hurt the opposition. He is good enough to accumulate possessions but does not have the hunger he once.

MFC is 5 years off being a serious challenger (if at all), he would not both to get smacked about protect a number of kids. He would be better off at Freo.

Harley Bennell......now you are talking!!!

[rolly 149]

Harley benell last year [censored]

harley benell this year exceptional

the difference? imo its because he moved in with k hunt

say what you will about hunts footy ability he is a proven sporting warrior

while it may be a [censored] sport have a look at the way he would return kicks from full back as a bronco as a moroon and as a kangaroo...100miles an hour directly at the opposition daring them to get in his wsy. the 120kg props dont have the same intensity and will often slow their run before the line

hunt is seriously dedicated to his profession and this is the type we should be looking for through FA

The club is short of senior leaders and need to be taught off field as much as on and for that reason i am hoping the club in question is melbourne.

Buy cloke we get goals for 5 years from 1player

get a goddard, foley or hayes and they will teach the kids ti become teachers and success will breed success

[DemonDan... 77]

Jones, Viney, trenners on the inside,

Goddard, grimes, blease on the outside..

Another dimension and a big difference..

EDIT: and would probably mean we could cut the Cale Morton umbilical cord

Edited August 20, 2012 by DemonDan...

[ChaserJ 5,096]

It is believed that he is heading to Lyonland--Fremantle.

Makes a bit of sense. Bit of money out West and they had money tucked away for Mitch Clark, but didn't get the deal done. Had money tucked away for Travis Cloke, but they're unlikely to get the deal done.

They clearly want a big signing to state their intent and lift them up a cog. Ross knows what BJ can do (still don't know what he sees in Dawson though), and Freo see a window of opportunity while they still have Pavlich and Sandilands somewhere near their peaks.

Reckon you're on to something.