Brian Royal Poll

[McQueen 17,864]

Brian Royal has copped a fair amount of stick over the course of the season and the general consensus seems to be that he's unwanted.

Some have gone as far to say that Choco is the crux of the midfield problem and has basically poisoned every line he's worked with.

Personally, I'm of the belief that we just don't have the cattle. Coupled with all of the off-field issues this year and a whole new regime (except individual in question) it was always going to be a challenging year for anyone tasked with making sense from the senseless at the MFC.

Regardless, let's see how Choco fares in this poll.

Edited August 14, 2012 by McQueen

[rpfc 28,079]

If anyone just looked at their ceiling and shook their head - I'm with you.

[IRW 1,383]

His contract is up...he's goorrnn.

The real question should be whether other assistants will walk of their own volition

Edited August 14, 2012 by IRW

[rpfc 28,079]

His contract is up...he's goorrnn.

The real question should be whether other assistants will walk of their own volition

The rest of them just got here...

[McQueen 17,864]

If anyone just looked at their ceiling and shook their head - I'm with you.

I knew I would get that reaction.

Gotta get me some of this poll action.....

Now vote or go and whinge elsewhere.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

All the talk of getting chapman for his culture building abilities gets me thinking we should go hard for Cameron Ling as a Midfield coach. This bloke knows what it's like to be in a crap team and then turn it around into a monster of a team. Many say he is interested in coaching so I say get him.

[IRW 1,383]

The rest of them just got here

....

...exactly my point,do they want to stay?

[McQueen 17,864]

All the talk of getting chapman for his culture building abilities gets me thinking we should go hard for Cameron Ling as a Midfield coach. This bloke knows what it's like to be in a crap team and then turn it around into a monster of a team. Many say he is interested in coaching so I say get him.

He's got some real appeal, Lingy. I'd bet he's on the radar of many clubs although he does seem quite at home with the media.

Would definitley have a better vocabulary than Royal too.

[fredblackham 19]

Brian royal has a record of ruining any line he has coached. Unfortunately he has had a go at most lines and therefore has stunted the growth of the majority of our team. It's not personal the facts stand for themselves, the back line was stunted last year the midfield this year.

[rpfc 28,079]

I knew I would get that reaction.

Gotta get me some of this poll action.....

Now vote or go and whinge elsewhere.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

He's got some real appeal, Lingy. I'd bet he's on the radar of many clubs although he does seem quite at home with the media.

Would definitley have a better vocabulary than Royal too.

You'd imagine if he did want to coach Melbourne may suit him as we are starting from scratch and whoever does turn this midfield around will look like a dead set legend in the coaching fraternity.

[beelzebub 23,250]

Brian royal has a record of ruining any line he has coached. Unfortunately he has had a go at most lines and therefore has stunted the growth of the majority of our team. It's not personal the facts stand for themselves, the back line was stunted last year the midfield this year.

I ve often wondered whetherh it was purely coincidental or actually circumstantial. He does seem to be there currently simply becuase he is contracted. I suppose we'll knwo soon enough once the circus hits town.

[McQueen 17,864]

No better place than on a forum.

[Want a Flag 46]

I want him moved on and replaced with someone recently out of the game. I think midfield set ups and structures have moved on a lot since Royal was playing. Sometimes our lack of accountability and apparent poor set up beggars belief. None more than the first game of the season where Brisbane must have handballed out the back of the stoppages to one or sometimes 2 free players and set up attacks so often it was enough to make you vomit. The Richmond game a couple of weeks later was no better.

I know we don't have the cattle either but the set up just looks pedestrian and very easily countered or exploited by the opposition.

[DEELIRIOUS 156]

Wasn't liked at Richmond....OUSTED!

Wasn't liked at St Kilda.....OUSTED!

[rjay 24,679]

All the talk of getting chapman for his culture building abilities gets me thinking we should go hard for Cameron Ling as a Midfield coach. This bloke knows what it's like to be in a crap team and then turn it around into a monster of a team. Many say he is interested in coaching so I say get him.

There is already a thread on this...

[McQueen 17,864]

There is already a thread on this...

You are always going to have multiple threads containing similar content.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

There is already a thread on this...

Just explaining who I would want to replace Brian Royal as our midfield coach as Royal is the subject of the thread so I think it's relevant. Have you given everyone who has started a thousand Mark Neeld threads a reminder there is already an original thread?

[rjay 24,679]

Just explaining who I would want to replace Brian Royal as our midfield coach as Royal is the subject of the thread so I think it's relevant. Have you given everyone who has started a thousand Mark Neeld threads a reminder there is already an original thread?

No, I think you are on the money with Ling. He would be great but on the Ling thread a few others said that his business commitments may be a problem and that is the reason he is doing special comments this year and nothing more. Ling has the inside knowledge of all the mids of the last decade because he has had to stop them, he would bring enormous knowledge of how they go about the craft. Not to mention how respected his is in the football world.

If he is a no go then maybe a Simon Black or Lenny Hayes who are both approaching retirement would be good options.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

No, I think you are on the money with Ling. He would be great but on the Ling thread a few others said that his business commitments may be a problem and that is the reason he is doing special comments this year and nothing more. Ling has the inside knowledge of all the mids of the last decade because he has had to stop them, he would bring enormous knowledge of how they go about the craft. Not to mention how respected his is in the football world.

If he is a no go then maybe a Simon Black or Lenny Hayes who are both approaching retirement would be good options.

Agree we need a fresh face who is just out of the game. There is no point teaching an old coach new tactics when a young coach already knows them.

Edited August 14, 2012 by cowboy_from_hell

[Demon Forever 219]

Fallure follows this bloke. I have said it for years

[Moonshadow 17,577]

Fallure follows this bloke. I have said it for years

On a side note, many would say the same about Cameron Schwab.

[jurrahcane 70]

Underperforming midfield, smashed in the clearances. Time for another change, so a Republic for me .... no Royals at MFC

Edited August 14, 2012 by jurrahcane

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

The midfield has failed. Heads must roll.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,495]

Make him forward line coach next year