MFC best 22 rnd 1

[BIG JIM 508]

Very hard nut team im going with cause i think neeld wants a strong team

B: Bartram - Frawley - Davis

HB: Grimes - Sellar - Garland

C: Couch - Moloney - Trengove

HF: Howe - Martin - Sylvia

F: Watts - Clark - Davey

Foll: Jamar - Magner - Jones

I/C: Bate - Green - Mckenzie Sub: Blease

Pettard for sylvia round 1

[Grandson of a gun 276]

Likely to be re-visited after NAB 4 when we know the exact stance with injuries and game time. But here is my guesstimate at what it will be round 1 based on current injury/fitness/suspension lists:

FB: Bartram Frawley Sellar

HB: Grimes Rivers Garland

C: Howe Moloney Trengove

HF: Green Watts Petterd

FF: Davey Clarke Blease

R: Jamar Jones Magner

Int: Bate Martin Bail

Sub: Bennell

Emerg: Gysberts Dunn Nicholson

[GawnWithTheWind 604]

With the squad for the last round of NAB released, it has given us a slightly better indication of round 1:

FB: Garland - Frawley - Bartram

HB: Rivers - Sellar - Grimes

C: Jones - Magner - Trengove

HF: Howe - Green - Petterd

FF: Davey - Clark - Watts

R: Jamar - Moloney - Bail

I: Blease - Martin - McKenzie

S: Tynan

E: Tapscott - Bate - Dunn - Bennell - Gysberts

[robbo24 66]

With the squad for the last round of NAB released, it has given us a slightly better indication of round 1:

FB: Garland - Frawley - Bartram

HB: Rivers - Sellar - Grimes

C: Jones - Magner - Trengove

HF: Howe - Green - Petterd

FF: Davey - Clark - DUNN

R: Jamar - Moloney - Bail

I: BATE - Martin - BENNELL

S: MCKENZIE

With the squad chosen I predict this to be the side.

[old dee 22,999]

Why are so many people picking Sellar?

The guy was dumped by Adelaide

Has play a couple of average games

And suddenly he is everyone's CHB.

[daisycutter 28,694]

don't worry od, he'll be a demonland whipping boy before long....have patience

[Trisul 649]

Why are so many people picking Sellar?

The guy was dumped by Adelaide

Has play a couple of average games

And suddenly he is everyone's CHB.

There aren't too many options there Old, who would you prefer?

I would prefer that the defenders are able to work to their talent / niche without being burdened with gorilla minding - where possible.

Edited March 14, 2012 by Trident

[rhaz 342]

Why are so many people picking Sellar?

The guy was dumped by Adelaide

Has play a couple of average games

And suddenly he is everyone's CHB.

He was also taken as a top 10 draft pick then played in every bloody position on the ground by the Crows. Wasted. Lots of players have gotten a change of scenery and become much better. Tarrant at freo?

I'm more confused about Bate. I saw nothing i liked from him in the midfield. Interested to hear how Tynan goes again this weekend, wouldn't mind seeing him thrown in the deep end from round 1. Gives him confidence and would be a bit of a kick up the ass to some of the older guys.

[rjay 24,053]

If Watts is fit he will play round one, a few of the guys like Bate, Dunn, Blease, Davey, Bennell and Couch are pushing for a place this Friday, a fit Magna has booked his. Tynan is in for experience but would be very supprised if he made the round one team. I also think Sellar and Rivers may be playing off for a place as Brisbane with no Brown are not going to stretch our defense, if Brown was playing there may be an argument for both.

[monoccular 16,415]

I notice that many put Jurrah in - the header of the thread is best 22 round 1.

Clearly no way Liam will be ready for that.

Same goes for Morton - is he in full training?

[mrtwister 650]

FB: Bartram Frawley Rivers

HB: Garland Sellar Grimes

C: Green Magner Davey

HF: Howe Martin Trengove

FF: Petterd Clarke Couch

R: Jamar Moloney Jones

Int: Blease McKenzie Dunn

Sub: Tapscott

I would love to use Couch as a crumber in the forward line. To me, this spot would be Sylvia's but what can you do? Otherwise it would be Jetta's or Jurrah's if fit. I don't see anyone else that could be used there without losing out by taking them from their current position in the 22.

I will save my thoughts on Watts for another thread.

[Harrisonrules 273]

Bartram is one player who splits the supporter base down the middle. I'm one who thinks his skills are so far below the required level its a joke. Despite what some of his advocates think he rarely takes the best opposition small. We have to find a replacement real soon otherwise he's one of our c players of which we can have too many. One hundred games and he still hasn't developed the skill set required, it won't happen now. He should be at the top of his game.

[Harrisonrules 273]

I notice that many put Jurrah in - the header of the thread is best 22 round 1.

Clearly no way Liam will be ready for that.

Same goes for Morton - is he in full training?

Playing this week at Casey I am sure I heard

Edited March 14, 2012 by Harrisonrules

[Harrisonrules 273]

He was also taken as a top 10 draft pick then played in every bloody position on the ground by the Crows. Wasted. Lots of players have gotten a change of scenery and become much better. Tarrant at freo?

I'm more confused about Bate. I saw nothing i liked from him in the midfield. Interested to hear how Tynan goes again this weekend, wouldn't mind seeing him thrown in the deep end from round 1. Gives him confidence and would be a bit of a kick up the ass to some of the older guys.

Where Sellar is after round 10 will be interesting

I was hopeful for Bate. Got some great skills but I didn't see great improvement in the mid-field. Ok in the scrappy Bris/suns game. But very modest last week. I had given up on dunn but I felt he was probably more value than Bate last week.

Tynan sounds romantic but hardly any point at this stage. Personally I'd go with Davis before Tynan, despite what Neeld did to him last week.

[Biffen 12,433]

Why are so many people picking Sellar?

The guy was dumped by Adelaide

Has play a couple of average games

And suddenly he is everyone's CHB.

People seem to think the new guys are all great . Rivers , Tappy and Strauss will be pushing up for spots in the back line as well .

[_becks_ 35]

It will be interesting how many games Martin gets. With Clarke up forward, they may make him rake for 5-10 minutes a qtr to provide Jamar with respite...

Surely Bartram will not get many games this year. His disposal is terrible. The pick of the smalls to play back would be Blease, Grimes, Tapscott, Bennel or Strauss. I dont think Jetta has the requisite skills to play down back. I think he may get a go as a forward. Talls

There are quite a few Mids to choose from...Jones, Bail, Moloney, Davey, Nicholson, Trengove, McKenzie, Strauss(?), Gysberts (hoping for a big season!), Morton and Magner. I believe they will elevate Magner and Nicholson to replace the two injured ruckman on the list.

Rucks: Jamar, Clarke, Martin.

The forward line will be interesting. Jurrah will be a big loss to start the season. He can kick a few and play terribly. I think Clark, Howe are automatic starters with Petterd, Green, Watts, Davey, Jetta, Lawrence and Sylvia depending on rotations and form.

Neeld has done some experimenting over the Nab cup, lets hope he can get a good mix come round one!!

Cant wait!

[mrtwister 650]

People seem to think the new guys are all great . Rivers , Tappy and Strauss will be pushing up for spots in the back line as well .

If Sellar can hold his own at CHB then that would/could allow Rivers to free up a bit and come into contests as a spoiler (he is the best punch we have in all of the backs) as he can play on a 'less dangerous' forward. He would go nuts as a loose defender. (IMO)

[Striker475 696]

Just to add onto the SellarDoor debate, I was at the Qld triple header and very much liked what I saw from him. The guy can play in the backline. Very much had the Warnocks about him except didn't scare the living [censored] out of me when he tried to kick the footy. He'll be great against a gorilla - see Cloke, Brown, Roughead - and even better against the more generic tall forwards (Vickery, Lynch). It also releases Frawley off those guys to take the rebounding HB role, where he is far, far more deadly.

If we don't try and muck with him as well as (occasionally) have him pinch-hit as a third option down back in the ruck (behind Rush and Martin) then I think he'll do well.

Edited March 15, 2012 by Striker475

[old dee 22,999]

People seem to think the new guys are all great . Rivers , Tappy and Strauss will be pushing up for spots in the back line as well .

I am not having a go at you biffen

But a lot people on here keep saying " they are only a Nab cup / practise games they don't mean much"

So lets wait till the real action starts

[P-man 13,277]

Just please no more Bate in the midfield. His decision-making verges on embarassing, if you can call hurriedly booting it forward without looking up a decision. Can't understand everyone singing his praises in the new role considering how often he turns it over.

I can only assume people are leaving out Tappy because of the lack of pre-season games. If fit he's one of the first I'd pick. Tough, reliable kick, and leaves nothing out on the paddock. How many can have that said about them?

Plus Bartram is in the leadership group, for some reason, hence he will get plenty of games no matter how good his disposal.

Two key players that need to stand up this year if we're to have any chance of moving up the ladder are Morton and Gysberts. Those are the two I will be watching most closely, and I'd like to see both playing in Rd 1 but I doubt it will happen.

Previously I was pencilling this in as a win, but now I just want to see us go out there and stick it up them.

[Guest Dr Who]

Plus Bartram is in the leadership group, for some reason, hence he will get plenty of games no matter how good his disposal.

I have a feeling we might see Bartram used more up ground this year as a mid-field defensive stopper/tagger, just will depend on a few injuries down back.

[monoccular 16,415]

People seem to think the new guys are all great . Rivers , Tappy and Strauss will be pushing up for spots in the back line as well .

....but not Tappy and Strauß for round 1, which is the title of this thread.

[monoccular 16,415]

.....Two key players that need to stand up this year if we're to have any chance of moving up the ladder are Morton and Gysberts. Those are the two I will be watching most closely, and I'd like to see both playing in Rd 1 but I doubt it will happen.......

Absolutely no way, given their lack of preseason, or at least preseason appearances.

[Hells Gates 505]

One of many who are no certainty for Round 1.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/131236/default.aspx

[tonatopia 278]

So it begins......against Brisbane........

FB: Bartram Garland Rivers

HB: Grimes Frawley Tapscott

C: Green Moloney Trengove

HF: Howe Watts Davey

FF: Petterd Clarke Martin

FOL: Jamar Jones McKenzie

INT: Magner Blease Bate Bennell

Emg: Morton Seller Dunn

and its on.......