The Josh Toy Thread

[Striker475 696]

Worth a play for one of the compos?

Reportedly seriously homesick.

[Mad_Melbourne 877]

Best mate's brother, he is a ripper bloke too, coming back for the next week or so as well. Didnt get much of a run in gold coast coz they didnt think he was fit enough, is a serious weapon, and would slot right into our backline, freeing tapscott and grimes up to more midfield roles.

[MadAsHell 4,212]

Hell yes, if he's home sick we should target this kid big time! He'll be a star I have no doubt. I made mention in another thread that I reckon we should target Jordan Russell, but I'd be even happier with Josh Toy, can play the same type of role to free up a Grimes, Blease or Bail etc to spend more time in the midfield.

Question mark will be over his ability to shut an opponent down, can he play on the oppositions best smalls?

If we can get a draft pick in the mid 20's for Warnock & our 3rd round pick then maybe Maric and that pick in the mid 20's could get the deal done?

[Chicken Deelicious 0]

Why not a straight swap with GCS? Could imagine they would love a big bodied full back, to support Campbell Brown at CHB!

[deeflog 679]

Why not a straight swap with GCS? Could imagine they would love a big bodied full back, to support Campbell Brown at CHB!

Nathan Bock sends his regards

[Whispering_Jack 30,175]

Why not a straight swap with GCS? Could imagine they would love a big bodied full back, to support Campbell Brown at CHB!

Not a bad suggestion given Matthew Warnock appears headed in that direction.

[Disco Demons 92]

Another club has already enquired about him and told no. I saw it on twitter

[Lutz 76]

Must be true then.

[Roger Mellie 4,032]

Another club has already enquired about him and told no. I saw it on twitter

Yes it was North

[H_T 3,047]

Why not a straight swap with GCS? Could imagine they would love a big bodied full back, to support Campbell Brown at CHB!

Not a bad suggestion given Matthew Warnock appears headed in that direction.

I don't think Josh Toy and Matthew Warnock will ever, ever be a straight swap in a trade. It would have to include picks and it would be heavily weighted to Gold Coast. ie. It would most likley cost a compensation pick and then some.

[H_T 3,047]

Yes it was North

I'd say no to North too if their best was pick 18.

[dee-luded 2,959]

I don't think Josh Toy and Matthew Warnock will ever, ever be a straight swap in a trade. It would have to include picks and it would be heavily weighted to Gold Coast. ie. It would most likely cost a compensation pick and then some.

What about a swap of Morton for Toy?

[mordja 187]

Trade week radio now suggesting Warnock to GCS.

could we potentially get Toy in return, maybe we give up a 3rd rounder as well to even it out?

Edited October 12, 2011 by mordja

[Roger Mellie 4,032]

TAKE IT NOW

Sounds too good to be true

[Guest Thomo]

Trade week radio now suggesting Warnock to GCS.

could we potentially get Toy in return, maybe we give up a 3rd rounder as well to even it out?

Would need to be Warnock and at least one first round pick for Toy, possibly two. Would have been top 3 in last years draft if he was not taken early. Didn't star last year, but is very hightly rated.

[mordja 187]

fair enough, wont happen then.

[Guest Thomo]

fair enough, wont happen then.

I'd do it.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,222]

Warnock for Toy won't happen wasn't Toy a top 5 pick only last year? Or was he one of the GC early 17yo picks? Either way we'd have to offer a lot more than just Warnock and a 2nd-3rd round pick.

[Ouch! 2,263]

I don't know enough about Toy... what role in defence would he play? Looking at his height he isn't overly tall, so is he competing for the 3rd tall? or is he a "quarterback" (Don't like the use of this term) or more a running defender?

If he was rated top 5, and has had a year in the system, I suspect Warnock would be bundled with a compensation pick at least.... and if we are still in the running regarding the 17yr old mini draft that might have to play out first.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,222]

I thought he was seen as more of a midfielder than a defender but I'm only going on memory of reports from 1-2 years ago. Can't remember seeing him play either.

[nutbean 8,838]

Why not a straight swap with GCS? Could imagine they would love a big bodied full back, to support Campbell Brown at CHB!

Umm Campbell Brown does play tall but he is 179 cm - not quite CHB

[GRUN DEE 69]

Can Toy be traded??? Isnt he suppossed to be at GC for another year. Total 2 years before a trade.

If he can be traded;

I would trade a compo pick + Warnock in a heart beat.

[Ouch! 2,263]

Can Toy be traded??? Isnt he suppossed to be at GC for another year. Total 2 years before a trade. If he can be traded; I would trade a compo pick + Warnock in a heart beat.

He can be traded if he agrees to the trade, which if he is contracted but homesick could be a possibility. But yeah you would think that compo, warnock and possibly even 37 (If that was coming from Nth for Maric) would be needed.... doubt he would be cheap, and if he is genuinely wanting to come home ..... surely he would have been linked to Carlton

[Whispering_Jack 30,175]

He played only eigh games in his inaugural year at the Suns.

Was there a reason forn such a low number?

Injury?

[Ouch! 2,263]

He did get injured at one point I remember, but didn't their player list get rotated heavily to get games into all of the list to assess where the list was at. So I reckon there would not have been too many of the 1st year players getting more than 15 -17 games would there?