Tom Scully in September ...

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

Thank god there's a teacher here to edit what fix did you make on your post for the edit genius

Tom, this is the effect you are having on Demon supporters.

Did you think of the damage you are inflicting, Tom? Did you?

[RalphiusMaximus 6,103]

Thank god there's a teacher here to edit what fix did you make on your post for the edit genius

If you must know, there was a minor formatting error with some bold type. The tag was in the slightly wrong place.

If you object to having your work improved, all you need to do is write in an intelligible manner to begin with.

[wmth 69]

Caught up with my mate at the footy last night. He's very good family friends with a GWS development coach (I've been trying to get any inide info all year). My mate's house sitting for him in Melbourne, and he's asked a few times for me but he's given nothing. However, last night my mate said that Scully is gone and the deal is done. He also mentioned the Brogan / Power stuff a while ago.

He also said that Dean Bailey, now working with the Calder Cannons as a "special" finals coach apparently, said that while Tom is a really nice, good kid he is gone..

I suspect that when they pay you a salary of over a million a year they can choose when to announce it. It seems the wait is PR. Wait and see I guess, but I think we all know what's coming.

Just passing it on.

[dees64 104]

I would presume that if he re-signs, the club already knows who the coach will be, and therefore so does Tom. I couldn't imagine them letting it roll on past next week.

I just cant believe that a player would commit to a club pending a coach! If this was the case we would have not resigned anyone!

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

I think the loss of Scully on field can be covered by a fit Gysberts, and although I haven't seen young Viney play, from all reports he will be a brilliant acquisition. So should we lose him from an on field perspective I don't think we'll suffer that much.

He is only one player, and if losing one player is going to [censored] our premiership window chances we were no chance to begin with.

Just wish they'd bloody hurry up with the decision because I'm sick of this website being my homepage lately!

[Guest Thomo]

Thank god there's a teacher here to edit what fix did you make on your post for the edit genius

It's not an English essay, but at least make it readable. Try and have a bit of pride in what you write.

[Sir Why You Little 37,307]

Caught up with my mate at the footy last night. He's very good family friends with a GWS development coach (I've been trying to get any inide info all year). My mate's house sitting for him in Melbourne, and he's asked a few times for me but he's given nothing. However, last night my mate said that Scully is gone and the deal is done. He also mentioned the Brogan / Power stuff a while ago.

He also said that Dean Bailey, now working with the Calder Cannons as a "special" finals coach apparently, said that while Tom is a really nice, good kid he is gone..

I suspect that when they pay you a salary of over a million a year they can choose when to announce it. It seems the wait is PR. Wait and see I guess, but I think we all know what's coming.

Just passing it on.

Why wouldn't the MFC just announce it then? Why should we wait for a GWS presser...stuff that.

I still wait and see.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I think the loss of Scully on field can be covered by a fit Gysberts, and although I haven't seen young Viney play, from all reports he will be a brilliant acquisition. So should we lose him from an on field perspective I don't think we'll suffer that much.

Bail is already better than Scully, so not a great loss but it would be nice if he stayed.

[Ouch! 2,269]

Why wouldn't the MFC just announce it then? Why should we wait for a GWS presser...stuff that.

I still wait and see.

I agree,.. if your mate is friends with a GWS dev coach, then without the name of that coach these comments are next to worthless sorry.

MFC has NOTHING to gain from this. If something has been decided on Scully either way, MFC would announce it ASAP.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

It's either an official statement or it's hearsay.

Every time someone claims to be good friends with a GWS official etc all I hear is Scully's best friend's brother in law's brother's dog's attorney etc etc.

If it's out there Joe Smith from Demonland isn't going to be breaking the news. No offense.

[beelzebub 23,390]

Box ticking

Clock ticking

Scully’s gone , rumour’s sticking

Much thinking

Many sticking

Fat with Tom’s notoff-nicking

Melbourne’s blinking

Sydney’s winking

Demons’ hopeful but heart’s sinking

Red and Blue jumper should be fitting

But money’s easy picking

Clock ticking

Clock ticking

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

LOL!

And with that beautiful poem comes the conclusion of the stalker like obsession with this thread.

The balls in your court Tom. Stop being such a [censored] tease and let us know already!

[Tatu 416]

I think the loss of Scully on field can be covered by a fit Gysberts, and although I haven't seen young Viney play, from all reports he will be a brilliant acquisition. So should we lose him from an on field perspective I don't think we'll suffer that much.

He is only one player, and if losing one player is going to [censored] our premiership window chances we were no chance to begin with.Just wish they'd bloody hurry up with the decision because I'm sick of this website being my homepage lately!

I agree with this.....really like the profile pic woohoo ....

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

I agree with this.....really like the profile pic woohoo ....

That self imposed Tom Scully thread ban lasted all of 5 minutes lol, like a moth to a pretty blue light I am back!

And the profile pic isn't me it was from the Internet. Although I agree, what a hottie hey?

Hurry the [censored] up Tom! Clocks a ticking.

[Ron Burgundy 8,587]

Caught up with my mate at the footy last night. He's very good family friends with a GWS development coach (I've been trying to get any inide info all year). My mate's house sitting for him in Melbourne, and he's asked a few times for me but he's given nothing. However, last night my mate said that Scully is gone and the deal is done. He also mentioned the Brogan / Power stuff a while ago.

He also said that Dean Bailey, now working with the Calder Cannons as a "special" finals coach apparently, said that while Tom is a really nice, good kid he is gone..

I suspect that when they pay you a salary of over a million a year they can choose when to announce it. It seems the wait is PR. Wait and see I guess, but I think we all know what's coming.

Just passing it on.

I agree. I've heard it too, albeit through different sources. And I'm not going to disclose from whom, because the cheerleader stuff on this thread is mindless and pathetic.

It is hearsay. I don't need that pointed out to me from someone who can't actually articulate, when pressed, what hearsay actually is and why it is generally inadmissible in a court of law.

I suspect the announcement will be made on Monday. If not Monday, then Tuesday. It seems we absolutely wasted this pick. And, as a passionate Demons' supporter, I'm really annoyed about this.

On the upside - it will make the glory even better when we eventually taste it.

[7-UP 107]

How can anyone mention Luke Power stuff a while ago when he announce his retirement two weeks ago because Michael Voss told him to.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

I think people just like to gloat about having sources so it appears that they are in the know, and in some kind of circle of knowledge. It's just big noting yourself. If the information was credible and from THE source and not second hand, then surely the intimate relationship between source and messanger would ensure confidentiality.

Until I see Scully in a filthy GWS shirt I couldn't give a [censored] which distant nobody has heard stuff about Scully

[wmth 69]

How can anyone mention Luke Power stuff a while ago when he announce his retirement two weeks ago because Michael Voss told him to.

Our conversation was over several beers in the Percy Beams bar. He mentioned Power, not sure how long ago he pre-empted this. Who knows, the deal could've been in place since October

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

How can anyone mention Luke Power stuff a while ago when he announce his retirement two weeks ago because Michael Voss told him to.

Because he is old and an impending retirement is easier to read than an early defection.

In any case Power retiring isn't as sensitive as the Scully issue.

[Ron Burgundy 8,587]

It's either an official statement or it's hearsay.

Every time someone claims to be good friends with a GWS official etc all I hear is Scully's best friend's brother in law's brother's dog's attorney etc etc.

If it's out there Joe Smith from Demonland isn't going to be breaking the news. No offense.

This is the very type of argument that the Christian Right in Kansas (who flatly refuse to teach evolutionary theory in schools) put to Christopher Hitchens in response to his rational arguments as to the existence of God - ie, you can't prove it, so I won't believe it.

The point is that the 'official statement' has not yet been made. Everyone knows and accepts that. However, that doesn't mean that the underlying facts don't exist - it merely means that they have not been 'announced' yet. And it is clear to me that, absent an 'official' announcement, some people steadfastly refuse to believe what most people know to be fact. Head in the sand stuff.

I'm interested to know how these people will react if, as many expect, Scully announces next week that he will be wearing the grey and orange in 2012.

[wmth 69]

It's either an official statement or it's hearsay.

Every time someone claims to be good friends with a GWS official etc all I hear is Scully's best friend's brother in law's brother's dog's attorney etc etc.

If it's out there Joe Smith from Demonland isn't going to be breaking the news. No offense.

Yep, certainly heresay. But thought I'd pass it on. However, I am sure amongst the thousands of posts, one demonlander will have had it right and will claim it.

[jnrmac 20,276]

It seems we absolutely wasted this pick. And, as a passionate Demons' supporter, I'm really annoyed about this.

Yeah, we really wasted it by getting the best player in the draft.

Good grief. What a goose.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

They will react the way any Scully fan would react I'd imagine- outraged. But that doesn't mean they have egg on their faces. It means they were open to all possibilities until official confirmation was available.

Unless you have spoken to Scully or someone with first hand information (not detached) you wont know for sure. You are simply putting 2 and 2 together. All signs point to him leaving, but I don't have my head in the sand because I am waiting for official confirmation.

[beelzebub 23,390]

What a strange and maverick idea... putting 2 and 2 together. What will they think of next

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

What a strange and maverick idea... putting 2 and 2 together. What will they think of next

the point is it doesn't always equal 4..