The Scott Gumbleton Thread

[Demon SeaMan 108]

Is it a rumor that Jones kicking has improved this yr or I'm not sitting on the sidelines,!! Time to sacrifice and hate to say but he could be the fall guy to get what we need

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Is it a rumor that Jones kicking has improved this yr or I'm not sitting on the sidelines,!! Time to sacrifice and hate to say but he could be the fall guy to get what we need

I dont think our midfield can afford to lose another experienced bigger body, even if jones doesnt tackle as much as he should.... i agree though he isnt untouchable... If you could get a fit Gumbleton it may be justified, this is what i doubt

[Demon Jim 149]

An injury riddled start to his career but showed genuine signs in 2010 that he could become a quality KPF.

If he comes good our forward line suddenly looks seriously potent:

Jurrah Gumbleton Davey

Petterd Watts Sylvia

The Bombers have made enquiries about a couple of our players recently, including Jones. Perhaps it's worth a punt to sacrifice a player

of that type in order to get Gumby to the club.

If he comes good it would dramatically improve the balance and quality of our forward line.

This is one risk I reckon is worth taking.

Thoughts?

Spud

[Bobby McKenzie 2,268]

The boy can play. You want Cloke or a Buddy to plug in straight away but that's never going to happen.

We should take a risk on a guy like this with massive x-factor. He didn't go no.2 in that draft for nothing.

In a year or two, we'd have a Watts/Gumbleton duo absolutely scaring the living suitcase out of every defence in the league.

Meanwhile, Cook can be groomed for CHB.

No way Essendon would let him go after watching those highlights. He would be a real acquisition though if it happened.

[Nasher 33,246]

I do generally think RR is on the right track - we're not going to trade in Buddy or Cloke and we're not going to get anyone worthwhile for Bate, Dunn, Maric or Warnock.

I agree - the premise is right but I'm not that keen on the particular player.

It's nice to see a trade thread that makes a reasonable attempt at a well balanced trade rather than one ridiculously weighted in Melbourne's favour.

[H_T 2,941]

I dont think our midfield can afford to lose another experienced bigger body, even if jones doesnt tackle as much as he should.... i agree though he isnt untouchable... If you could get a fit Gumbleton it may be justified, this is what i doubt

Me too re: a fit Gumbleton - but that's the risk. However, you can't rule anything out without some consideration. But I don't think they'll offer him up for trade. Besides, what do we have in surplus that they would want ? You see, we don't have a quality midfield. What do they need ? A stronger midfield too. Do we have something they'd want ? Only what we want to keep IMO.

What Gumbleton has shown on the footy field is impressive ie. leap, capable marking, kicking for goal.

Here's some of his stats: -

2007 - 5 games

2008 - DNP

2009 - DNP

2010 - 17 games

2011 - YTP (yet to play)

Age: 23

Games: 22

Goals: 22

Height: 197cm

Weight: 94Kg

*footywire-afl stats

[H_T 2,941]

I agree - the premise is right but I'm not that keen on the particular player.

It's nice to see a trade thread that makes a reasonable attempt at a well balanced trade rather than one ridiculously weighted in Melbourne's favour.

Agree. Well done Range Rover in that regard.

[dee-luded 2,958]

An injury riddled start to his career but showed genuine signs in 2010 that he could become a quality KPF.

If he comes good our forward line suddenly looks seriously potent:

Jurrah Gumbleton Davey

Petterd Watts Sylvia

The Bombers have made enquiries about a couple of our players recently, including Jones. Perhaps it's worth a punt to sacrifice a player

of that type in order to get Gumby to the club.

If he comes good it would dramatically improve the balance and quality of our forward line.

This is one risk I reckon is worth taking.

Thoughts?

Cotton Wool & Mercurochrome. all along one line.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Great footage package but his lack of on field time is disturbing

[Range Rover 1,935]

This will really draw some ire but if Gumbleton could prove his fitness, I would even dangle Jurrah out there to snag him.

[H_T 2,941]

This will really draw some ire but if Gumbleton could prove his fitness, I would even dangle Jurrah out there to snag him.

Essendon have the bye in the last round, so with a game to go plus a possible final, how do you suppose Gumbleton prove his fitness ?

I wouldn't dangle Jurrah, but you could twist my arm in Aaron Davey. He'll be 29 around next Queen's Birthday and he would have to have some trade value left. I think ?

There's a risk in everything you do, and there certainly is here in these examples of trades. But it's all about improving one's list and the greater picture. Maybe 'eye on the prize' wins out this trade period. Certainly that's what Josh Mahoney alluded to prior to last Sundays game against Richmond. Clear intentions there.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I wouldnt offer Jurrah. I think he would be great playing beside a fit Gumbleton. You could offer Davey but they may adopt the one Davey is enough policy. I am not sure clubs would be chasing Davey atm

[Range Rover 1,935]

Essendon have the bye in the last round, so with a game to go plus a possible final, how do you suppose Gumbleton prove his fitness ?

I wouldn't dangle Jurrah, but you could twist my arm in Aaron Davey. He'll be 29 around next Queen's Birthday and he would have to have some trade value left. I think ?

There's a risk in everything you do, and there certainly is here in these examples of trades. But it's all about improving one's list and the greater picture. Maybe 'eye on the prize' wins out this trade period. Certainly that's what Josh Mahoney alluded to prior to last Sundays game against Richmond. Clear intentions there.

No doubt it will be touch and go. And not without risk. If he can get through a full AFL game and play in that final, gee he'd be worth looking at.

Looking 2 - 3 years ahead to have a Watts-Gumbleton two-pronged structure to build a forward line around would be really something. I sniff a premiership with that sort of quality.

I love Jurrah and Davey and the former is a particularly feel-good story, but we've got to be about more than that and it may be that a ruthless but calculated risk will need to be made in order for us to compete with the big boys.

Spasmodic, mercurial types are great to watch and ooh-ahh over but in the cut and thrust of September you want structure, discipline and two genuine go-to forwards.

Anyway that's what I reckon. A spine of:

Frawley

Cook

Trengove

Gumbleton

Watts

... has a distinctly premiership feel about it.

Edited August 26, 2011 by Range Rover

[Johnny Karate 559]

The guy is a walking bandaid IMHO not worth the trade punt as Rhino said I would take him in the PSD. If we were to trade for a big man I'd be trying to tempt big Taylor Walker from Adelaide to cross to the red and blue.

[H_T 2,941]

The guy is a walking bandaid IMHO not worth the trade punt as Rhino said I would take him in the PSD. If we were to trade for a big man I'd be trying to tempt big Taylor Walker from Adelaide to cross to the red and blue.

PSD would be a long shot IMO with a cashed up GWS and GC, not to mention Brisbane who by reports (if you believe that sort of thing) will lose Clark.

Come to think of it, I wonder where Mitch Clark is headed.....

[Johnny Karate 559]

PSD would be a long shot IMO with a cashed up GWS and GC, not to mention Brisbane who by reports (if you believe that sort of thing) will lose Clark.

Come to think of it, I wonder where Mitch Clark is headed.....

I don't really think cashed up is a big thing for Gumbleton he isn't really a proven AFL quantity so I wouldn't be surprised if GWS and GC were more 'hungry' for him than we would be.

I personally believe Clark will stay, whatever the outcome though his manager was recently quoted as saying he wouldn't be going to GWS. He could possibly end up at Freo being a WA boy.

P.S. Scrap my 'operation Walker' he's just signed with the Crows!

Edited August 26, 2011 by Jimmi C

[jacey 333]

I don't really think cashed up is a big thing for Gumbleton he isn't really a proven AFL quantity

I'm a real big fan of Butcher and Sam Reid.

Gumbleton was a similiar position to Butcher and Reid a few years ago but with less currency.

It's a risk with his body but that's why he is on the cheap. Do it.

[P-man 13,352]

Pass on Fumbleton thanks.

[Nasher 33,246]

This will really draw some ire but if Gumbleton could prove his fitness, I would even dangle Jurrah out there to snag him.

The idea of trading Jurrah is wrong on so many levels.

[Deeman 1,426]

What exactly are Gumbleton's injury and fitness issues and could the introduction of people like Neil Craig and David Misson help him with these now that they are at the club.

[simma02 53]

Absolutely forget about him. He is a dud and his body is shot. Shocking recruit!

[Redleg 38,506]

Gumbleton would be worth a look but he's not worth much.

Agree. You might try and do a deal for say Bate or Dunn as at least they are on the park, unlike Gumbleton and then hope our medical staff can get him right. He has hardly done anything in his time at the Bombers and they may have had enough. If he then failed with us it wouldn't be a catastrophe.

He turns 24 next year and has played 22 games since 2007 and none this year. Hardly a star.

Edited October 6, 2011 by Redleg

[Lutz 76]

Those who want him have been seduced by the draft pick he was taken with, and that alone.

[Goodvibes 3,596]

Those who want him have been seduced by the draft pick he was taken with, and that alone.

We're not that shallow. How about that Youtube highlight package?

[Demon Disciple 11,209]

If we are interested, then we cannot pay overs, if anything unders should be the go. Plus, not give up quality picks, only someone that is expendable, like a Bate or Dunn (even that could be considered too generous).

Edited October 6, 2011 by Demon Disciple