Injury List: Round 9

[alpha33 277]

The weeks go by slowly for Tom Scully. Every week in which he is injured takes three or four* and I'm wondering whether his season isn't over already.

The official injury list from melbournefc.com.au says three weeks. FWIW here it is:-

Rohan Bail (knee) - 4-6 weeks

Jack Fitzpatrick (ankle) - 7-9 weeks

Colin Garland (ankle) - 6-8 weeks

Jack Grimes (foot) - season

Mark Jamar (knee) - 3-5 weeks

Jared Rivers (ankle) - test

Tom Scully (knee) - 3 weeks

Jake Spencer (knee) - season

See the Round 4 Injury thread

Updated Injury List (Post#28)

Robbie Campbell (achilles) - 5 weeks

Jordie McKenzie (groin) - 4 weeks

Tom Scully (knee) - 6 weeks

That was after Tom's injury was upgraded from 3 to 6 weeks.

[old dee 23,256]

Depressing but it is too early for the single walt.

Perhaps a cruise as I cannot Ski

Edited May 17, 2011 by Rogue
No need to quote massive slabs of text - just enough to indicate what you're replying to is fine

[Rogue 585]

The unavailable (ordered by weeks, rather than alphabet):

Jared Rivers (ankle) - test

Jack Trengove (susp.) - 2 weeks

Lynden Dunn (susp.) - 2 weeks

Tom Scully (knee) - 3 weeks

Mark Jamar (knee) - 3-5 weeks

Rohan Bail (knee) - 4-6 weeks

Colin Garland (ankle) - 6-8 weeks

Jack Fitzpatrick (ankle) - 7-9 weeks

Jack Grimes (foot) - season

Jake Spencer (knee) - season

I'd have ~7 in my best 22.

[Hobbits's 17]

Scully (knee) - 3 weeks

Jamar (knee) - 3-5 weeks

deesBet odds for who will return first to football head2head:

scully $15.00

jamar $1.07

insider trading no doubt.

*disclaimer: deesBet is not Deesbet and doesn't exist.

Edited May 17, 2011 by Grimes to Watts

[jayceebee31 692]

Depressing but it is too early for the single walt.

Perhaps a cruise as I cannot Ski

Do what I'm doing. Going to see Melb v's Essendon. Leave straight after for Auckland arrive back on the 12th to go and see us get belted by the Colliwobbles.

[Eth 4]

No McKenzie. Good.

[jayceebee31 692]

No McKenzie. Good.

Why would he be- played for Casey last Sunday and gained 24 kicks.

[Rogue 585]

No McKenzie. Good.

McKenzie has played footy the past two weeks.

[Guest Rajon Rondo]

Already praying these Bail, Garland, Jamar injuries don't become a year long problem.

We've a great record of turning 4-5 week injuries into a season.

[Eth 4]

McKenzie has played footy the past two weeks.

IIRC he's been on the injury list for the past two weeks as well. Him being off means he's 100% fit which is good.

[Roost It 1,434]

The unavailable (ordered by weeks, rather than alphabet):

Jared Rivers (ankle) - test probably right to go

Jack Trengove (susp.) - 2 weeks - 2 weeks

Lynden Dunn (susp.) - 2 weeks - 2 weeks then season at Casey then dumped from list

Tom Scully (knee) - 3 weeks - 6 - 8 weeks

Mark Jamar (knee) - 3-5 weeks - 5 - 7 weeks

Rohan Bail (knee) - 4-6 weeks - season

Colin Garland (ankle) - 6-8 weeks - season

Jack Fitzpatrick (ankle) - 7-9 weeks - season

Jack Grimes (foot) - season - 3 seasons

Jake Spencer (knee) - season - cut from list

I'd have ~7 in my best 22.

[titan_uranus 23,253]

The unavailable (ordered by weeks, rather than alphabet):

Jared Rivers (ankle) - test

Jack Trengove (susp.) - 2 weeks

Lynden Dunn (susp.) - 2 weeks

Tom Scully (knee) - 3 weeks

Mark Jamar (knee) - 3-5 weeks

Rohan Bail (knee) - 4-6 weeks

Colin Garland (ankle) - 6-8 weeks

Jack Fitzpatrick (ankle) - 7-9 weeks

Jack Grimes (foot) - season

Jake Spencer (knee) - season

I'd have ~7 in my best 22.

Rivers, Trengove, Scully, Jamar, Bail, Garland, Grimes.

It hurts.

Garland out for 6-8 is a huge blow, he's been in good form all year. Same deal with Bail.

[Whispering_Jack 28,128]

It hurts.

Yes. It does but it hurts a lot less when your team is developing and young because the fact that some of those players are missing gives an opportunity to others to get games before their time would otherwise have come.

None of us would have been contemplating two weeks ago the possible debut this week of a Max Gawn or a Michael Evans. In all probability it's too soon for them to be making their debuts. Yet the thought of these young players getting their opportunities and the hope that they can kick start their careers ahead of time is a compelling one

If they can get games, show something and play well they might well offset the disappointment of losing some of the old regulars.

[rhaz 342]

Garlo, Grimes, Rivers and Bail are all no strangers to the injury list. It sucks, some players just have no luck.

[Nasher 33,246]

Yes. It does but it hurts a lot less when your team is developing and young because the fact that some of those players are missing gives an opportunity to others to get games before their time would otherwise have come.

Yes, silver lining and all that, and it's a development year still. But we're pretty much stuffed in terms of winning matches in the short term, which is a shame. It's also disappointing that there are several players on the injury list who we want to be pumping heaps of matches in to for experience, not to mention Trengove.

I'm bracing myself because I think we're going to be put in the hurt locker for a few weeks.

[Rogue 585]

Yes, silver lining and all that, and it's a development year still. But we're pretty much stuffed in terms of winning matches in the short term, which is a shame. It's also disappointing that there are several players on the injury list who we want to be pumping heaps of matches in to for experience, not to mention Trengove.

I'm bracing myself because I think we're going to be put in the hurt locker for a few weeks.

It's also now tough to judge the team, and DB, because we're an already weak team missing 1/3 of their best team (and a bunch of the more important players, too).

[Age 421]

Call me a pessimist but we do seem to have the best record in turning 3-5 week injuries into season ending ones, the odd we even end the career of!

I don't expect to see any of those players back again this year. Even Trengove will probably do something at training during his time off.

This club has killed my expectations in life!

[H_T 2,941]

Bleak. Very bleak.

That said, this Saturday it's a chance to stand for something. Cattle or no cattle. Actions not words. 4 quarters.

[dee-luded 2,958]

The unavailable (ordered by weeks, rather than alphabet):

Jared Rivers (ankle) - test

Jack Trengove (susp.) - 2 weeks

Lynden Dunn (susp.) - 2 weeks

Tom Scully (knee) - 3 weeks

Mark Jamar (knee) - 3-5 weeks

Rohan Bail (knee) - 4-6 weeks

Colin Garland (ankle) - 6-8 weeks

Jack Fitzpatrick (ankle) - 7-9 weeks

Jack Grimes (foot) - season

Jake Spencer (knee) - season

I'd have ~7 in my best 22.

Thats better, thanks Rogue.

[waikikkamukau 62]

Call me a pessimist but we do seem to have the best record in turning 3-5 week injuries into season ending ones, the odd we even end the career of!

I don't expect to see any of those players back again this year. Even Trengove will probably do something at training during his time off.

This club has killed my expectations in life!

Sad for you!

[Doggo 32]

I've been interested to find out how Robbie Campbell played in the Casey reserves smashing of Cranbourne in the practise match at the weekend, and to my surprise there was no mention of him in Brad Gotch's player review? Did he injure himself last week (played a half in the 2's last week), or was he rested? I'd have thought, for a player like Campbell coming off such a long playoff with no preseason at all, a practise match against a local team would've been a great opportunity to play 3-4 quarters of a fairly low intensity match and get a bit of game time and run in the legs (albeit against soft opposition). Especially with our current ruck situation.

Reserves practice match

Casey 22.14 (146) d Cranbourne 1.4 (10)

Troy Davis: Troy can play. He’s building his fitness and showing some really good defensive play. He uses the ball well and showed a bit of dash. He’s going to put some pressure on selection wise.

Cameron Johnston: Cam played really well. He had more than 30 possessions, on top of his 26 last week. So he’s going well and he’ll be pushing for the VFL seniors.

Can anyone shed some light on Robbie's apparent non-inclusion at the weekend?