Ball for Melbourne in the PSD?

[grazman 7,451]

He can nominate for either with contract terms and the firts club willing to mmet the contract and spend the pick get him.

In the PSD that's us, in the ND the club has to be prepared to spend the pick, that wouldn't be us because we would need to to use 18 to trump Collingwood's 30. I doubt he'd go earlier than 18 unless Port was in the market at 16 so Ball needs to look at the clubs with picks 19 to 29 and see whether he'd get thru to 30.

Sydney? I think Ball would be very wary about their intentions. He'd fit right into Paul Roos game plan and I think the Swans might be tempted to use pick 14 on him. Given Essendon's declared interest, they'd see Ball as pretty good value at pick 26 as well.

The Question is does he want to risk having to move North (or West) by going into the PSD, if not the only real options for him are to re-sign with the Saints or change his mind about playing with us.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

He's only 25 (younger than Davey who just got a 4 year deal)!

I know his body is not in great shape, but he may still be around when we're challenging for a flag, and if he brings leadership and experience, why not?

We lost his exact type in McLean, whether by choice or not is unclear, but if we got pick 11 for McLean and can get Ball for nothing as a short to medium term replacement, it'll be a huge win.

25 with OP is about 30 without it.

The issue is that he has said he does not want to play for MFC. He might have to change his position

I would be happy to take him for nothing in the PSD. He mightn't be.

As Old points out he could still go for pick 30 to the Pies or earlier if someone trumps up the money and Ball wants to go.

MFC are still along way from the box seat on this.

[Supreme_Demon 3,899]

MUHAHAHAHA! :D

I knew the Collingwood deal would fail!

Now all the Demons need to do is convince Luke Ball that coming to the Demons is genuinely worthwhile.

Lets hope Dean Bailey and Co arrange a meeting with him.

Explain to Luke that there is a great opportunity here at the Demons if he wishes to take it.

That is the hard part.....

Edited October 9, 2009 by Supreme_Demon

[Ryan Dee 140]

Sydney? I think Ball would be very wary about their intentions. He'd fit right into Paul Roos game plan and I think the Swans might be tempted to use pick 14 on him. Given Essendon's declared interest, they'd see Ball as pretty good value at pick 26 as well.

The Question is does he want to risk having to move North (or West) by going into the PSD, if not the only real options for him are to re-sign with the Saints or change his mind about playing with us.

Was only a rumour about him not wanting to play with us?

Why would he say this? it's just not a smart thing to do and with managers having a big say these days i'm sure he would have been told to keep his mouth shut.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

MUHAHAHAHA! :D

Now all the Demons need to do is convince Luke Ball that coming to the Demons is genuinely worthwhile.

Wrong!

MUHAHAHAHA! :D

[mauriesy 7,357]

Would he get to Collingwood at 30 in the ND with $400K x 3 on his head?

I think it's possible.

I thought those who nominate for the National Draft are not able to set a minimum acceptable contract period or salary, but those who nominate for the PSD may set the terms for their contracts?

[Supreme_Demon 3,899]

Wrong!

MUHAHAHAHA! :D

Such negativity!

Who else is worthwhile taking in the Pre-Season Draft then?

[Disco Demons 92]

and in further good news...the aussie dollar is rising and luke ball looks set to becoming a demon!

[flog 20]

Such negativity!

Who else is worthwhile taking in the Pre-Season Draft then?

I think someone raised j mcdonalds name from brisbane.

[Guest Digga]

Such negativity!

Who else is worthwhile taking in the Pre-Season Draft then?

It's his over analytical personality usually brought on by a lifetime of not being accepted by his fellow peers in school and worklife.

Like someone said here a few days ago, demonland was a much better place when he was away for a few weeks.

Edited October 9, 2009 by Digga

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Apparently we're talking to Luke Ball now http://twitter.com/emmasq

[Carn dees 108]

Can he go into the national?

Like tom hislop and colm begley.

[titan_uranus 25,043]

Andrew Maher just said that 'the team on the bottom of the ladder' is going to make a play for Luke Ball, alongside Collingwood (and possibly other clubs).

[grazman 7,451]

I thought those who nominate for the National Draft are not able to set a minimum acceptable contract period or salary, but those who nominate for the PSD may set the terms for their contracts?

Used to be Maurie, but they changed the rules. It's now both.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

The question is, does he HAVE to nominate for the ND in order to be considered for the PSD?

That is, if we talk to him and he says he wants to come to Melbourne, can he bypass the ND and go straight to the PSD?

[Forest Demon 4,681]

The question is, does he HAVE to nominate for the ND in order to be considered for the PSD?

That is, if we talk to him and he says he wants to come to Melbourne, can he bypass the ND and go straight to the PSD?

He can choose to nominate for either or both drafts...so yes he can just nominate for PSD

Edited October 9, 2009 by forest85

[flog 20]

The question is, does he HAVE to nominate for the ND in order to be considered for the PSD?

That is, if we talk to him and he says he wants to come to Melbourne, can he bypass the ND and go straight to the PSD?

yes, one or the other

[Jaded No More 68,974]

He can choose to nominate for either or both drafts

Thanks.

Fingers crossed. It's about time we scored ourselves some freebies!

[Guest The Old Xaverian]

The question is, does he HAVE to nominate for the ND in order to be considered for the PSD?

It's dependent on when his contract ends. If he doesn't have a binding contract prior to list lodgement, he automatically is delisted & if he nominates, he'll go into both drafts.

[LITTLE STINGA 1]

If we can't land Ball in the PSD then heads should roll. We must have the money to pay him. He will be our no 1 midfielder and he will be able to show the 2 best kids in the draft how it's done or he can stay at St Kilda where he has clearly fallen out with Lyon who doesn't rate him.

A big name player is just what this club needs, he is great at clearances and we are the worst team at that so we definately need him. If we can't land him then I'll have to ask what is the club doing? I'm getting sick and tired of this club not being able to land quality experienced players.

[Choko 493]

25 with OP is about 30 without it.

The issue is that he has said he does not want to play for MFC. He might have to change his position

I would be happy to take him for nothing in the PSD. He mightn't be.

As Old points out he could still go for pick 30 to the Pies or earlier if someone trumps up the money and Ball wants to go.

MFC are still along way from the box seat on this.

When did he say he didn't want to play for the MFC?

[Akum 2,660]

Like the guy as a player, but I'm really not convinced he's right for us. If his aim is to play in a premiership (which it seems to be), then his unwillingness to consider anything other than a side whose "premiership window" is already open may mean that he just doesn't see his body holding out until a 4-6-year "premiership window" period like ours.

Also, he'd be taking 15-22 games (barring injury) away from the younger mids that we badly need to get game time into.

This might not be a problem if he was the type of mid we need, but he's not.

No point now in attracting a "name" just for the sake of it. Much smarter to get a lesser player in the PSD who fills a need.

[WonnaJurah 5]

MFC Announces they are interested in getting Ball in Psd.No powerpoint presentations plz

[Cards13 9,117]

If we can't land Ball in the PSD then heads should roll. We must have the money to pay him. He will be our no 1 midfielder and he will be able to show the 2 best kids in the draft how it's done or he can stay at St Kilda where he has clearly fallen out with Lyon who doesn't rate him.

A big name player is just what this club needs, he is great at clearances and we are the worst team at that so we definately need him. If we can't land him then I'll have to ask what is the club doing? I'm getting sick and tired of this club not being able to land quality experienced players.

If we make a pitch to him and he tells us no.. you going to chop his head off (listening to Wu Tang clan as we speak)?

All we can do, if we are interested is put a proposal to him, it is then up to Ball if he wants to come to the bottom side, with very little experience on it's list. Does he want another situation when he first arrived at St Kilda? Or does he want to play out the next 3-4 years (doubt his body will hold up longer) at a club in the hunt for flags?

I think he will say thanks but no thanks. It might be a couple of years before we can attract so called big name players to our club.

Edited October 9, 2009 by Cards13

[pantaloons 2,019]

MFC Announces they are interested in getting Ball in Psd.No powerpoint presentations plz

Indeed: http://twitter.com/Whitey927

TRADE NEWS: Melbourne confirms serious interest in Luke Ball. The Demons will aim to convince him to come through the pre-season draft