Round 1 2010 Who is in MFC's best 22?

[titan_uranus 25,043]

FB: Garland Warnock Bennell

HB: Frawley Rivers Bruce

C: Morton Davey Sylvia

HF: Green Bate Petterd

FF: Watts Jurrah Wonaeamirri

R: Jamar Moloney Grimes

Int: Martin Scully Blease McLean McDonald

Emg: Jones Strauss Jetta

Edited September 2, 2009 by titan_uranus

[Dannyz 2,851]

FB: Garland Warnock Bennell

HB: Frawley Rivers Bruce

C: Morton Davey Sylvia

HF: Green Bate Petterd

FF: Watts Jurrah Wonaeamirri

R: Jamar Moloney Grimes

Int: Martin Scully Blease McDonald

Emg: McLean Strauss Jetta

Surely Jones is more worthy of a Round One spot than an unproven Blease.

Edited September 2, 2009 by Dannyz

[titan_uranus 25,043]

Surely Jones is more worthy of a Round One spot than an unproven Blease.

Fair enough. But considering I've got McLean as an emergency, and Jones unlisted, I'll give McLean the nod first.

[B20 0]

B. Grimes Warnock Frawley

HB. Rivers Martin Davey

C. Green Bruce Buckley

HF. Bate Miller Dunn

F. Petterd Jurrah Wonaemirri

R. Jamar McLean Sylvia

IC. Jones Maloney P.Johnson Cheney

[H_T 3,049]

We won't draft Panos, Daw would be a long-term prospect, Blease will be under-done and Trengrove isn't a forward.

Trengove.....is a midfielder who can play up forward or even half-back. Same with Morabito he can also go forward.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Then by all means please, tell me out of that 22 who would you have them in place of?

By all means, your saying they should earn it.... who should be there in their place?

I dont care who they replace. If they are good enough... they play. Enough of the pretence

[stranga 328]

May as well put in my 10 cents worth....

FB: Frawley, Warnock, Bennell

HB: Grimes, Rivers, Green

C: Morton, Davey, Bruce

HF: Watts, Bate, Sylvia

FF: Wonaemirri, Jurrah, Watts

R: Moloney, scully, Jamar

Int: Martin, mclean, Mcdonald, Strauss

Emg: Trengove, Blease, Jones, petterd

Edited September 2, 2009 by stranga

[Demon4Life 603]

I fear Garland won't be ready for senior football by round 1 next year. I hope I'm wrong!

[LITTLE STINGA 1]

R: Moloney, scully, Jamar

Moloney in the ruck and Jamar rover. Surely we would of stopped tanking by then.

[Old Gregg 1]

Strauss, Blease and our #2, #18 picks will start in the VFL.

Scully can play off the bench.

Garland may also begin the year in the VFL.

FB: Rivers Warnock Frawley

HB: Green Martin Grimes

C: Morton Moloney Davey

HF: Watts Bate Sylvia

FF: Jurrah Miller/Newton Wona/Maric

Ruck: Jamar Jones Bruce

Bench (from): Scully McLean McDonald Jetta Petterd Bartram Dunn

Emerg: Bennell Buckley Cheney

Bail Johnson Garland McNamara Blease Strauss McKenzie Spencer Meesen

This is a tough gig.....

Edited September 2, 2009 by Stop: Jurrahtime

[stranga 328]

Moloney in the ruck and Jamar rover. Surely we would of stopped tanking by then.

LOL...oops, you know what i meant

[Al`s DEMONS 0]

Bruce might be on the out next year if his disposal does not improve

[Bruce Almighty 0]

The 22 players that train the hardest in the pre season!

[Bruce Almighty 0]

Bruce might be on the out next year if his disposal does not improve

i would prefer to think that bruce will be in our best next year when his disposal improves

[rpfc 28,775]

Bruce might be on the out next year if his disposal does not improve

I'm sorry, is this 2003?

Bruce has always delivered helicopters, and he is constantly one of our best players. Top 3 in the Bluey I would say.

He will not be 'on the out.'

[volders 22]

@most peoples

i dont think theres room for garland, frawley, warnock and rivers in our backline, way too top heavy,

also jimmy should definately start in the best 22 had a better season than jones/mclean imo.

Yes, I thought the same. He has the height. Maybe Morton to CHF, Jurrah to FF and Watts to HF then.

i see him more as a goodes type player, anyway hopefully watts will be filling this position.

Edited September 2, 2009 by volders

[Tex 68]

B: Cheney Frawley Warnock

HB: Grimes Rivers Green

C: Davey Sylvia Morton

HF: Petterd Watts Bate

F: Wonaeamirri Garland Jurrah

R: Jamar Bruce Moloney

INT: Scully Johnson McLean Maric

EMG: Jones Newton Trengove

Depth: Bennell Dunn Miller Blease Jetta Strauss Buckley Spenser Messen McNamara Martin

Not interested - Bell Bartram McDonald

****ADD 1ST PICK IN PRE-SEASON DRAFT

It is about time we snagged a gun uncontracted player. Preferrably a key tall forward.

[titan_uranus 25,043]

Not interested - Bell Bartram McDonald

Well he's been re-signed for another year, and he's continuing as captain. So he'll be playing when fit.

It is about time we snagged a gun uncontracted player. Preferrably a key tall forward.

Who? And at what cost?

[Rosso 59]

****ADD 1ST PICK IN PRE-SEASON DRAFT

It is about time we snagged a gun uncontracted player. Preferrably a key tall forward.

[volders 22]

Craig Hutchison said on footy show that the Bulldogs board have come out and said that Brian Lake will not be traded, and therefore if he doesn't sign, he will be forced into PSD...... I'm assuming he will re-sign with the Dogs, but IF he does declare for the PSD, then A) Would the Dees take him given we have Garland, Frawley, Rivers and Warnock already? MORE IMPORTANTLY B) Would we be able to trade our #1 PSD pick to other teams ie (Hawthorn) that are desperate for a Key defender of the quality of Brian Lake and what would we be able to command in return... pick #9 in national draft perhaps?

brian lake will almost definitely be AA this year, ofc we would take him in an instant, even geelong with perhaps the only better FB in the game would take him. lake is worth more than pick 9 in national draft... a lot more.

[Bucks-Fan 1]

B: Bennell Garland Warnock

HB: Morton Frawley Bruce

C: Davey Moloney Grimes

HF: Sylvia Bate Jetta

F:Wonaeamirri Watts Jurrah

R: Jamar Jones McLean

INT: Martin Green Cheney Buckley

EMG: Meesen Dunn Rivers McDonald

??- Maric, Pettard,

then there's

Scully, Trengove

[jayceebee31 761]

MY BEST IS:

Best team in 2010 is:

B: CHENEY WARNOCK MARTIN

HB: GARLAND FRAWLEY RIVERS

C: GRIMES McLEAN BRUCE

HF: GREEN WATTS BATE

F: DAVEY JURRAH JAMAR

R: MEESON BARTRAM JONES

I: SYLVIA PETTERD McNAMARA McDONALD

EMERG: BUCKLEY BENNELL WONAEAMIRRI DUNN MALONEY BLEASE STRAUSS.

REQUIRE:

FAST MIDFIELDER ----- SCULLY

RUCK ROVER TYPE ----- TRENGROVE

TALL FORWARD ------ TALIA

VERSATILE TALL------ GRIFFITHS

RUCKMAN------- FITZPATRICK

UTILITY----------BURGOYNE

OFF LIST: ROBERTSON WHELAN WHEATLEY BELL MILLER JOHNSON.

[titan_uranus 25,043]

R: MEESON BARTRAM JONES

EMERG: BUCKLEY BENNELL WONAEAMIRRI DUNN MALONEY BLEASE STRAUSS.

Giving Bartram a start over Moloney is a bit rich. Moloney's coming off a great year, will do well in the B&F. Bartram, on the other hand, is no certainty to even be on our list next year.

[Guest demons are hell]

FB Strauss Warnock MacDanold

HB Grimes Frawley Rivers/Garland

C Morton Jones Bruce

HF Sylvia Watts Bate

FF Maric Jurrah Wonna

R Maloney Davey Jamar

INT Messon Green Bleese Peterd

EMER PJ Bennel Jetta Rivers/Garland Cheney Dunn

This is not including any of our new player we will get in this years draft

[jayceebee31 761]

Giving Bartram a start over Moloney is a bit rich. Moloney's coming off a great year, will do well in the B&F. Bartram, on the other hand, is no certainty to even be on our list next year.

Far comment regarding Bartram- I think Bartram has good upside- do not forget the year before he came off a knee injury. However, accept your point re Maloney,but as my interchange shows- many could take Bartram's place.