My 3 word player analysis V The Shockers

[joeboy 3,166]

Bartram - confident and effective

Bate - a constant presence

Cheney - safe but unobtrusive

Davey - performance to cherish

Dunn - confident and impressive

Frawley - excellent after errors

Jetta - too many clangers

Johnson - impressive despite limitations

Jones - strong and determined

Jurrah - an exciting presence

Martin - had little influence

McDonald - terrific captain's game

McLean - loved the conditions

McNamara - needs more time

Miller - provided some grunt

Moloney - vital at stoppages

Morton - composed and influential

Petterd - a burst player

Rivers - performance of old

Robertson - some reminiscent moves

Sylvia - performance gradually improved

Valenti - late season revival

[Demonland 73,161]

Thankgod you're here!

[herb 1]

Bartram - stuck to task

Bate - great two weeks

Cheney - continues to develop

Davey - Delicious

Dunn - continues renaissance

Frawley - excellent 3 qtrs

Jetta - not for me

Johnson - solid showing

Jones - i love him

Jurrah - GOAL OF YEAR

Martin - a bit lost

McDonald - really good down back

McLean - tough all day

McNamara - a couple of moments

Miller - still a good option

Moloney - the work horse

Morton - half back special

Petterd - good up front

Rivers - defensive general

Robertson - reeling back the years

Sylvia - solid showing

Valenti-Best game yet

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Martin- clearly very injured

Why the hell are they playing him, when he was limping for 90% of the game?

[Pommy Demon 0]

Bartram - determined and trying

Bate - presented all day

Cheney - improving each week

Davey - suburb silky skills

Dunn - held Pavlich well

Frawley - was bloody excellent

Jetta - inconsistant yet tries

Johnson - beat sanderlands today

Jones - solid second efforts

Jurrah - our colt hero

Martin - out of sorts

McDonald - strong tackles, hard

McLean - solid,confident player

McNamara - first career goal

Miller - made good space

Moloney - showing great leadership

Morton - another top game

Petterd - good in bursts

Rivers - solid down back

Robertson - made a difference

Sylvia - well fit body! ;-)

Valenti- read game well

[e25 5]

Bate - come of age?

[titan_uranus 25,045]

Bartram - never stops running

Bate - very good game

Cheney - hard at ball

Davey - completely brilliant performance

Dunn - better than usual

Frawley - improved through game

Jetta - not enough possessions

Johnson - not abysmal, surprisingly

Jones - showed some leadership

Jurrah - is a star

Martin - unfortunately did nothing

McDonald - terrific captain's game

McLean - impressive senior return

McNamara - must keep playing

Miller - better than Newton

Moloney - not our best

Morton - good in defence

Petterd - OK but inconsistent

Rivers - very pleasing game

Robertson - not too bad

Sylvia - underperformed yet again

Valenti - another good game

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Martin- clearly very injured

Why the hell are they playing him, when he was limping for 90% of the game?

Cos there's no-one else...

:D

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Harsh on Petterd. I'd call Jurrah the burst player. Petterd is just growing in confidence week by week.

[Dannyz 2,851]

McDonald - Must play on

[Doggo 32]

Harsh on Petterd. I'd call Jurrah the burst player. Petterd is just growing in confidence week by week.

So would i normally but Jurrah played more of a 4-qtr game today, whereas Petterd seemed to flash in and out of the game quite a bit. Not one of his better performances but not bad by any means.

Scary to think how much better Jurrah can become with a couple of pre-seasons and extra muscle in him. You can just sense he's growing more and more in confidence every week and is trying more things now. Had a couple of little fumbles, but continued to present and be dangerous all day.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Bartram - worked arse off

Bate - Growing in stature

Cheney - coming along nicely

Davey - displaying midfield presence

Dunn - better with experience

Frawley - maturity starting to show

Jetta - just a baby

Johnson - more positive game

Jones - raising his level

Jurrah - showing confidence, composure

Martin - provided tall option

McDonald - great in defence

McLean - had an influence

McNamara - showed attacking flair

Miller - took tarrant away

Moloney - vital at stoppages

Morton - composed and influential

Petterd - attacks contest hard

Rivers - good defensive game

Robertson - all fall down

Sylvia - liked drying conditions

Valenti - thirty hard possessions

[Scully The Tank Engine 0]

Sylvia - underperformed yet again

Yet again? He's been terrific for most of the games he's played this year. He was quite good today without setting the world on fire imo....

He's the 3rd best player at our club after Brad Green and Aaron Davey....

[monoccular 17,575]

Vaenti - career making game

[Dannyz 2,851]

Yet again? He's been terrific for most of the games he's played this year. He was quite good today without setting the world on fire imo....

He's the 3rd best player at our club after Brad Green and Aaron Davey....

Well said.

[Still Waiting 94]

Bartram=Worked V hard

Bate=Very Good, strong

Cheney=Getting better

Davey=BOG ,great game

Dunn=Seviceable effort

Frawley=Very good improver

Jetta=can do better, give more games

Johnson=showed a bit today

Jones=also showed a bit of hardness

Jurrah=Headache for any opposition, very good

Martin=gives honest efforts,just fair

McDonald=Strong captain's game

McLean=strong again,good goal sense as well.

McNamara=some good signs,needs games

Miller=patchy,some good efforts

Moloney=works hard and good

Morton=V good, great potential here

Petterd=good but needs 4 qtr efforts

Rivers=great defensive game

Robertson=a couple of good patches

Sylvia=gives hardness but still can improve, ok

Valenti=prob his best game yet

[45HG 1,559]

McDonald - was bloody brilliant.

Davey - career best game?

Bate - very good game

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

So would i normally but Jurrah played more of a 4-qtr game today, whereas Petterd seemed to flash in and out of the game quite a bit. Not one of his better performances but not bad by any means.

Fair enough.

[deeflog 679]

McDonald - Must play on

your kidding.... right? no chance he will play on, the game has passed him by, a fantastic servant of the played, but his time is up

[dimmy 1,308]

Probably not directly related to 3 word analysis, but :

Umpires Bloody shithouse. Decision against Frawley 90 metre off the ball must rank as the decision of the year. Eddie McDickhead would have taken them to court if it had happened against Collingwood.

Statisticians mean nothing:

Ignores Stef's shepherd of Jurrah's goal.

Ignored Jettas tackle on the man mountain front on ,which lead to a goal

Ignored Jonesy's efforts that set us up with his COMMITTED approach.

Ignored Brad Miller letting Dodd know that is he wants to fight Jurrah he is going to have to get past him. Thats why we need him to look after Jurrah (Doesnt need much looking after'!!) and also to provide the protection from School Footy to big kid footy for that unmentioned new player.

The players all showed their appreciation of these efforts.

Jimmy doesnt need a stat to be effective.

[Dannyz 2,851]

your kidding.... right? no chance he will play on, the game has passed him by, a fantastic servant of the played, but his time is up

The leadership must come from somewhere. It certainly isn't coming from Bruce and Davey isn't quite there yet.

Based on todays performance, I think McDonald has got another year. In fact, I think he's been quite good all year.