READING IN THE DARK

[Demonland 71,649]

READING IN THE DARK by Whispering Jack

I recently took what was supposed to be a ten-day break from work and went up north to laze in the sun and read a book or two. My holiday co-incided with the gloom and doom of the collapse of the world’s economic markets and, at the same time, the news about my football team wasn’t all that flash either. No major sponsor, no visible progress with the MCC talks, the potential collapse of the Casey Fields deal, no gains in the trade week and acrimony over the future of Nathan Carroll. It seemed as if Melbourne was as much on the nose as any of the thousands of stocks that were plummeting on the All Ordinaries index.

Gloom and doom.

Thankfully, I enjoy reading books and this time I was well stocked. I had two football books and a fine piece of pulp fiction that goes under the heading of "crime thriller". I couldn't entirely escape the footy with that one because the author's name is Connolly (but not Chris - Michael). The reading was good and the contents of the books were in a sense inspiring and helped counter that gloom and doom in the news headlines both business and sporting.

The first of the footy books was Nathan Buckley's All I Can Be written with Ben Collins. It's an autobiography of sorts, one which is both triumphant in that it chronicles the illustrious career of a champion footballer who became captain of his club and won a Brownlow Medal and somewhat tragic in that it also covers the difficult relationship between Buckley and his father and his unfulfilled desire to be an AFL premiership player.

Just as he did throughout his career, Buckley pulled no punches in writing his book. As the title indicates, he wanted to be all he could be but was denied a premiership and the irony is that had a chosen to complete his original contract to play with North Melbourne, or had he remained with Brisbane, he would in all likelihood, have achieved that objective – and done it more than once.

The Kangaroos won the flag in 1996 and 1999 while Brisbane, which was a footballing basket case in Buckley’s only season with that club (1993) went on to score a hat trick of premierships between 2001 and 2003.

I couldn't help but reflect on this during my reading of the book and, for selfish reasons, would like to see others of more recent history who spurned a lowly club for the glamour and the money suffer the same fate when their own careers come to an end. Trust a book by and about a Collingwood player to bring out the mean and nasty streak in me!

Another side of Nathan Buckley was his transition from a youngster who some regarded as arrogant and a bit of a larrikin (FIGJAM) into the complete footballer and a leader of men as he matured at Collingwood. An uncompromising figure as a footballer, he became the ideal captain. In that respect, I can see a bit of him in Brock McLean and for some reason, I kept thinking as I read the Buckley story how the time is right for him take over the duties of leadership of the Melbourne Football Club.

In saying that I understand fully that McLean blotted his copybook with some errant behaviour in last year's off-season. Perhaps, he came under the influence of the wrong person or perhaps his head got a bit too big, but I have faith in McLean's ability to come back mentally and physically from last year's woes (which included an injury that ended his 2008 season early) and to demonstrate that he has what it takes to take this club's emerging young side into what will hopefully be its next phase of success. His appointment as skipper would welcome in a new chapter in our history and put an end to what has been a disappointing few years for the Melbourne Football Club.

I highly recommend Emma Quayle's The Draft. It's an enjoyable read that gives an insight into many aspects of the AFL's recruiting processes and it's one of the best books I have read on the subject of football, behind Richard Stremski's Kill for Collingwood and a couple of books by Garry Linnell (Football LTD: The Inside Story of the AFL and Playing God: The Rise & Fall of Gary Ablett).

Quayle, who is a respected sports writer for the Age, spent 2007 following the lives of five young draft hopefuls, all of who were ultimately drafted in that year's National Draft - Trent Cotchin (Richmond), Cyril Junior Rioli (Hawthorn), Brad Ebert (West Coast), Ben McEvoy (St Kilda) and Patrick Veszpremi (Sydney). She takes us through their experiences covering every day matters as well as the football side of their lives, culminating in their drafting and settling in at the clubs that chose them.

Each of the players has his own issues. Cotchin is dealing with the pressure of being regarded as close to the number one draft pick who is tagged out of the limelight in the national championships and not only fails to make All Australian but sees one of his taggers gain this honour. He also has to contend with the fact that his girlfriend is spending a great part of the year overseas at an equestrian academy. Rioli was taken away from home (Northern Territory) in his early teens and has to contend with life as a boarder in an exclusive private school in Melbourne. He doesn't interview well with many club recruiting officers. Ebert has to cope with being a member of a prominent South Australian footballing family. McEvoy lives in the bush and has to spend hours travelling to and from his TAC Cup team's training. Veszpremi is struggling with his fitness and needs a shoulder operation.

Their stories come together on draft day when the hopes of a couple of thousand youngsters are on the line and only about sixty will make it through at the first opportunity. A similar number get taken at the pre season and rookie drafts and some have another year to make the grade but the rest emerge with dashed hopes and disappointment.

Quayle weaves another aspect of the draft into the narrative by introducing the story of Hawthorn's recruiters as they follow the fortunes of hundreds of potential draftees in their quest to determine who will be chosen to wear the brown and gold. In doing so, she covers that club's long term planning going back to 2004 when the football department was restructured and Alastair Clarkson appointed as coach. At that time, the Hawks took an unorthodox approach to restructure their team by building up through the draft.

We know that in the end, the youth-led development plan paid off and it did so ahead of time thanks in part to an element of luck that saw them recruit Jarryd Roughead, Buddy Franklin and Jordan Lewis early in the 2004 national draft all the way to Rioli and the controverial selection of Stuart Dew with their final pick in 2007 and (as we now know) culminating in the ultimate success in 2008.

We even get a few insights into some of the potential 2008 draftees. Quayle was there when talented West Australian Tom Swift injured his knee in a warm up match in Perth on the eve of the AIS tour of South Africa. Among the players on that tour who were too young for the 2007 draft were the likes of Nick Naitanui and Daniel Rich. We also learn that bottom ager David Zaharakis, now a captain at Cotchin's TAC Club the Northern Knights, was under the Hawks' microscope but not picked last year. Could Hawthorn take him this year?

The Hawthorn formula is now in vogue and, although the circumstances can't all be repeated (for example, the priority pick now comes before the draft's second round and not the first) it's the pathway that Melbourne appears to be going down in preference to the cheque book acquisition of players through trades and other means currently being employed by Carlton. And it's noteworthy that Hawthorn had only one player in its 2008 premiership side who was recruited through the trades.

From Melbourne's perspective, all five of its 2007 national draftees rated at least one mention in the Quayle book with our top three rating several mentions. Cale Morton gets the most kudos but Jack Grimes' leadership capabilities do not go unnoticed. Early in the book, Quayle follows the AIS squad on its tour of South Africa. This paragraph comes at the end of the tour:

"At the post-match dinner, the boys had a final job to do. Each player had been assigned a quality and had to vote for the team member that best personified it. The award was named after Ben Mitchell, a member of the 2001 intake, who died in a car accident the following year aged only 17. The qualities were things like pride, patience, poise, care, trust, skill and sacrifice; the boys could interpret these things any way they chose to and the winner was Jack Grimes."

Here is a potted summary of the coverage each of the Demon draftees gets in Quayle's book:-

• Cale Morton - AIS tour of Africa, AA and National Carnival B & F. Looked upon has having good pace and quality delivery of the football and ranked by most as next in line behind the big 2 of Kreuzer and Cotchin from the Northern Knights. Fell to 4th because he was never going to be picked by WCE which had had enough of the Mortons after their experience with Mitch Morton. Highly regarded by recruiting people.

• Jack Grimes - AIS tour of Africa, AA and leadership and character written all over him. Some clubs rated him higher than his eventual 14th and the feeling was that his back injury caused him to slide a little in calculations.

• Addam Maric - AIS tour of Africa, AA and considered the best and most reliable kick in the draft. Some concerns that he was limited in the fact that he was a small forward and the challenge would be to ensure that he could develop into a more rounded footballer capable of playing in the midfield (I believe Melbourne's football department worked on this during the year and that the result will be one of the club's few notable successes for 2008).

• Kyle Cheney - mentioned only briefly during discussions by the Hawthorn drafting people as one of the draft possibilities from North Ballarat.

• Tom McNamara - AIS tour of Africa, SA rep in the National Champs and mentioned here and there in despatches (he's the youngest of all the draftees from all of the clubs so I wouldn't prematurely dismiss his future prospects).

On the eve of last year's draft Quayle wrote this article which appeared in the Age - Draft day is like Christmas for 16 AFL clubs. In it, she predicted her top 25 from the draft and Melbourne finished with four of her top 23. The Demons also picked up Stefan Martin in the pre season draft and Aussie Wonaeamirri and Shane Valenti as rookies on top of that.

If we can repeat that sort of effort again this year, we are well on the way to a revival that will come earlier than many might think and that thought leaves us with a lot less gloom and doom than many might otherwise be suggesting.

[Slartibartfast 17,223]

Thanks Jack, great read as usual.

I started off trying to hate Buckley but in the end I had nothing but admiration for him.

Emma's book sounds interesting but she didn't take a risk with who she followed did she? All of those blokes went first round. It would have been interesting to see her follow some of the lesser lights like Cheney and McNamara.

[Demonland 71,649]

Thanks Jack, great read as usual.

I started off trying to hate Buckley but in the end I had nothing but admiration for him.

Emma's book sounds interesting but she didn't take a risk with who she followed did she? All of those blokes went first round. It would have been interesting to see her follow some of the lesser lights like Cheney and McNamara.

You can read parts of Nathan Buckley's Book HERE, HERE and HERE and excerpts from the Emma Quayle book on line here - THE DRAFT

[Freddy Fuschia 741]

Enjoyed the read. Agree that it's time for Brock to take over the leadership. From what I hear he has matured a lot over the past six months and is ready to lead our young side.

[Mono 455]

• Cale Morton - ....................... Fell to 4th because he was never going to be picked by WCE which had had enough of the Mortons after their experience with Mitch Morton.

What experience would that be?

[Diablo 1]

What experience would that be?

From what I've heard, it related to Mitch having a bit of FIGJAM about him, despite not actually being THAT G. I've also heard that Dad was a bit of a serial pest around the club, trying to pump up Mitch's stocks.

[titan_uranus 24,980]

From what I've heard, it related to Mitch having a bit of FIGJAM about him, despite not actually being THAT G. I've also heard that Dad was a bit of a serial pest around the club, trying to pump up Mitch's stocks.

Not to mention the fact that he promised lots but never delivered.

[deanox 9,902]

and that he left the club to come to melbourne, where his brother played. that alone should e enough to not want to pick the kid if there is a good chance he will want to be with family interstate.

[Demon Head 271]

I agree that we should forgive Brock for his behaviour of early 2008. Boys will be boys and he has shown he is remorseful and wants to get on with the job of playing good football. We need him to take a role as leader of our young team and I believe he's now ready.

But if we're prepared to forgive Brock, then why are there so many who aren't prepared to give Tom Hislop a go!

[Sydney Pennski 294]

I agree that we should forgive Brock for his behaviour of early 2008. Boys will be boys and he has shown he is remorseful and wants to get on with the job of playing good football. We need him to take a role as leader of our young team and I believe he's now ready.

But if we're prepared to forgive Brock, then why are there so many who aren't prepared to give Tom Hislop a go!

You can say that again!

I think Hislop would be an aquisition if he could show that he has turned over a new leaf. He was a #20 draft pick a couple of years ago and would be worth looking at in the PSD.

[Whispering_Jack 29,828]

You can say that again!

I think Hislop would be an aquisition if he could show that he has turned over a new leaf. He was a #20 draft pick a couple of years ago and would be worth looking at in the PSD.

I don't know the exact nature of the behaviour that led to Hislop losing favour at Essendon and that makes it difficult to give a definitive answer to whether I would take Hislop. As a general rule however, I think you can't hold someone's behaviour over their heads forever and if they show remorse and it's clear that they are prepared to knuckle down and play football then they should be considered and, if that was the case, I'd consider giving Hislop a go. History tells us that there have been many young sportspeople who have overcome early indiscretions and become solid citizens. It also is a test of the club the player is going to and the ability of its coaches to help turn their careers around. You have to back your own people at some stage of the journey.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

But if we're prepared to forgive Brock, then why are there so many who aren't prepared to give Tom Hislop a go!

I think Hislop's personal issues are far far worse than Brock notwithstanding the fact that Hislop is also injury riddled and has produced nothing to date at Essendon. Hislop and McLean are chalk and cheese.

[alpha33 311]

You can read parts of Nathan Buckley's Book HERE, HERE and HERE and excerpts from the Emma Quayle book on line here - THE DRAFT

Emma Quayle was interviewed by KB on SEN today and was quizzed on her top 10 for this year's draft. She did say that it was subject to some possible refinement as the draft nears but this is what she's thinking ATM. I might have a crack at a transcript if my tape worked out:-

1 Melbourne Jack Watts (I know it's a big surprise to everyone but hey, I'm only the messenger!)

2 West Coast Nick Naitanui

3 Fremantle Daniel Rich

4 Port Adelaide Tyrone Vickery

5 Essendon Chris Yarran

6 Carlton Michael Hurley

7 Brisbane Jack Ziebell

8 Richmond Hamish Hartlett

9 North Melbourne Lewis Johnston

10 Adelaide Phil Davis

[e25 5]

1 Melbourne Jack Watts (I know it's a big surprise to everyone but hey, I'm only the messenger!)

2 West Coast Nick Naitanui

3 Fremantle Daniel Rich

4 Port Adelaide Tyrone Vickery

5 Essendon Chris Yarran

6 Carlton Michael Hurley

7 Brisbane Jack Ziebell

8 Richmond Hamish Hartlett

9 North Melbourne Lewis Johnston

10 Adelaide Phil Davis

Who?

[Whispering_Jack 29,828]

Who?

A 193cm tall key position player from Adelaide who was selected in the SA Under 18s but missed all but one game of the carnival through injury.

[e25 5]

A 193cm tall key position player from Adelaide who was selected in the SA Under 18s but missed all but one game of the carnival through injury.

Fair enough. I just don't remember seeing him in any mock drafts or player summaries.

Not that I'm too surprised.

[H_T 3,043]

Fair enough. I just don't remember seeing him in any mock drafts or player summaries.

Not that I'm too surprised.

Kept under wraps from us....those South Australians really are sneaky, aren't they. Good work by Emma Quayle to weed him out. No Blease in her list, hope he gets to pick 17 then.

[Golgothan 0]

Kept under wraps from us....those South Australians really are sneaky, aren't they. Good work by Emma Quayle to weed him out. No Blease in her list, hope he gets to pick 17 then.

Davis won't go quite that high, but is likely to be a top 25 pick. Plays both forward & back, there's a bit of talk that he's a good chance to go for Hawthorn to fill their CHB needs

I don't think Blease is quite top 10, although he could go there, but i think he'll go somewhere in the first round after that. His pace makes him a good fit for Collingwood at pick 11.

[Blistering 538]

A mate who lives in Adelaide has been pumping Phil Davis' tyres for some time. Says he's a more complete footballer and a more mature person than Johnston and that the Crows won't be too happy if he goes before their second pick comes around.

[SidVicious 130]

A mate who lives in Adelaide has been pumping Phil Davis' tyres for some time. Says he's a more complete footballer and a more mature person than Johnston and that the Crows won't be too happy if he goes before their second pick comes around.

Here's some YouTube vision around of Davis and he's impressive - 2008 NAB AFL DRAFT PROSPECT PHIL DAVIS IN ACTION

[e25 5]

Here's some YouTube vision around of Davis and he's impressive - 2008 NAB AFL DRAFT PROSPECT PHIL DAVIS IN ACTION

kicking skills aren't fantastic especially since he seems to get away & not be under too much pressure.

Seems a smart player though, kicking & tapping it to the right spots & to advantage.

Not sure how he'd fare at the next level though..

(disclaimer: based on not even 2 mins of youtube footage)

[Whispering_Jack 29,828]

Emma Quayle has produced her top 25 list in today's Sunday Age (no link currently provided). As usual - a very interesting read.

Not surprisingly, she thinks we'll take Jack @ 1.

[Hannabal 4]

Emma Quayle has produced her top 25 list in today's Sunday Age (no link currently provided). As usual - a very interesting read.

Not surprisingly, she thinks we'll take Jack @ 1.

Unfortunately it's only her rating of the players, not a mock draft. (and yes I know she mentions the challenge of being at the wooden spoon club)

http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/general/j...6770818997.html

[Demondeb 8]

Unfortunately it's only her rating of the players, not a mock draft. (and yes I know she mentions the challenge of being at the wooden spoon club)

http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/general/j...6770818997.html

Quite an interesting read and she brings us some players near the end that I havent really heard of... she seems to have a good grasp of quality players and it's comforting she rates Jack #1. I seriously think I will go down and knock a few heads together if we dont grab h im with our first pick.

Whilst Naita would be great, I just feel Jack fills our needs more and could well become our marquee player we so badly need.

I shall be sitting at the comp holding my breath next Saturday until that name comes out at 1....

[Blistering 538]

Unfortunately it's only her rating of the players, not a mock draft. (and yes I know she mentions the challenge of being at the wooden spoon club)

http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/general/j...6770818997.html

Her smokey at 25 would be an ideal player to have present for our VFL alignment announcement (whenever that may be)!