We get to choose clash jumper

[Suzanna 72]

.......

If we say that there are 16 clash jumpers (Two for Brisbane but none for Collingwood), that is 8 out of 16 that are not white based.

The statement that the AFL mandates that club jumpers must be white (or grey) based is a myth. It simply is not true. We CAN have red as the main colour, we just have to have the balls to demand it.

A couple of years ago our clash jumper was red - so unless the rules have changed, we could go that way again.

I prefer the demon jumper, but I really like the demon with the M logo the best - they should have used that one.

[demon_king 13]

Gee guys way to shoot me down, I did say when it came to Melbourne. There was an article in the age early this year saying the AFL said no to any red version of a clash jumper we submitted. I am on your side here, whatever crap the AFL have come up with as a reasoning I don't know.

Anyhoo...........voting closed at 5.00pm tonight has anyone heard what poor excuse of a Melbourne guernsey we will be wearing?

[Kiss of Death 755]

Well, jimmy said that the voting was 50 50 tonight, and we had a crowd vote... The cheers were equally loud.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Well, jimmy said that the voting was 50 50 tonight, and we had a crowd vote... The cheers were equally loud.

And...?

[Kiss of Death 755]

Jimmy simply said "we'll take that on board" and while i left not too much longer after that, no announcement was made.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Jimmy simply said "we'll take that on board" and while i left not too much longer after that, no announcement was made.

Interesting.

Thanks.

[Yencks 8]

out of interest

did they actually have a real copy of the jumpers?

and which one looks better in real life if that is the case?

anything else of interest from the function?

[beelzebub 23,379]

Hmm..call me cynical...sceptical...even late for dinner but the mathematical probablility that after thousands of votes that the result is line ball pushes credibility into the realm of credulity !!

This has I suspect been an exercise only...to gauge reactions and trends. a 50/50 result easily creates an out for either another design or none to be forthcoming.

I think people...we've been had !!

[Kiss of Death 755]

I didn't see any actual guernseys, i'm guessing they would have brought out one should a clear choice have been made.

If they did make a decision later, i'm happy to be corrected!

[ucanchoose 1,816]

Well, jimmy said that the voting was 50 50 tonight, and we had a crowd vote... The cheers were equally loud.

To me and my wife standing up the back. A was clearly louder. It will be A no doubt about it.

[Kiss of Death 755]

While the cheers sounded the same, the chatter about the Demon logo lasted longer than the chatter about the MFC logo.

The Demon is back!

[45HG 1,539]

Too bad the Demon looks like a Fairy

[deanox 9,931]

i think the problem with the red jumper is that the a couple of the teams we 'clash' with have red. essendon, sydney fremantle and apparently st kilda. (carlton we clash with but dont have red). by increasing the red we could make the clash worse. HOWEVER, imo by adding white, we clash worse with st kilda and sydney.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

i think the problem with the red jumper is that the a couple of the teams we 'clash' with have red. essendon, sydney fremantle and apparently st kilda. (carlton we clash with but dont have red). by increasing the red we could make the clash worse. HOWEVER, imo by adding white, we clash worse with st kilda and sydney.

Melbourne's normal jumper doesn't clash with Sydney, so there isn't a problem there.

Essendon's clash jumper will clash more with Melbourne than their normal one does.

[TonyMelb 7]

To me and my wife standing up the back. A was clearly louder. It will be A no doubt about it.

TA was clearly favoured by a bit of a margin although not double.

Reasonable possibility that a couple of other alternatives may hev got highter vote:

© The former clash jumper - red with the demon logo - OK for all except Essendon

(D) None of the above

The 2008 clash jumper - used against Saints to ensure clashed ( perhaps thats the purpose??)

would have come last! the alternatives they offered in the members survey for that one were teal and white as the 3rd colour and everyone ticked silver or white as least awful.

Asking us to choose between 2 insipid alternatives is not quite getting to choose what sort of clash jumpers the members will be happy with!

BTW all the predominantly white clash strips for all the clubs are insipid and unattractive!

[H_T 3,048]

Melbourne's normal jumper doesn't clash with Sydney, so there isn't a problem there.

Essendon's clash jumper will clash more with Melbourne than their normal one does.

To be quite frank, there was no apparent clash in the 2000 Grand Final. Nothing was said. And it went International. It's a cop out. Keep it as it is.

Its all BullSh!t.

[titan_uranus 25,020]

Hmm..call me cynical...sceptical...even late for dinner but the mathematical probablility that after thousands of votes that the result is line ball pushes credibility into the realm of credulity !!

This has I suspect been an exercise only...to gauge reactions and trends. a 50/50 result easily creates an out for either another design or none to be forthcoming.

I think people...we've been had !!

I hope you're right bub: maybe this was an exercise to see how many people care about the jumper and whether the demon is worth bringing back. Let's hope it ends up being red...

[Rogue 585]

I'd like to see this one (although the MFC insignia wouldn't get a run there - sponsor placement).

I think this one is also better than Option B:

This is from caddypgt over at Demonology.

[H_T 3,048]

I like that one from caddypgt at Demonology. Rogue is it a white back? Or Red Back?

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Playing around with the blue emblem on a red jumper idea.

[Pates 9,660]

Playing around with the blue emblem on a red jumper idea.

We've been made to have white as our "clash" colour.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

We've been made to have white as our "clash" colour.

I realise that.

I was just playing with the idea.

[beelzebub 23,379]

The AFL doesnt say we have to have white...we have to have "light "...apparently they just neglect to enhance enliightenment on that concept <_<

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

The AFL doesnt say we have to have white...we have to have "light "...apparently they just neglect to enhance enliightenment on that concept <_<

If you go up a few posts I've put the Essendon clash jumper in for comparison. Now which one is lighter?

[beelzebub 23,379]

I didnt say what the AFL said made any sense !!