Ashley Sampi doing preseason with Demons

[Guest unstable punt]

Sampi has arrived, is sharing digs with the Flash and started training yesterday - DEES LOOK AT SAMPI

"Sampi, discarded by the Eagles, has been given no guarantees of a berth on the Demons' list.

However if he sheds weight and can hold up to the rigours of a personalised program, Sampi is sure to spark interest from not only the Demons.

Richmond and Carlton will get a crack before Melbourne if the talented forward slips through to the pre-season draft."

we might pick him up late in national draft because toygs or cheats might get him before us in pre-season

[Nicho 1]

if he was to come and get his body right, he would be a good player.... Hard to keep him and Davey both quiet in a firing team....

[deanox 8,623]

Bite me Deanox. I didnt say it was relevant. I thought we wanted a younger list so we bid farewell to TJ say hello to draft picks. Not a hello to someone like Sampi

i don't want to bite you, i might catch something. we farewelled TJ for pick 14 in the national draft. that pick will get us one of the best youngsters in the land, hopefully a KPP. ashley sampi is young (i think someone mentioned he is 23?), and has skills and potential. maybe he is not as classy as TJ, but he is about 5 years younger and plays a role which is much needed in our side. we havnt guaranteed we are going to pick him up yet, and wont get him unless he shows something. also we wont be wasting the pick we got for TJ on him, we will either be getting him in the PSD, where we have picks or we could get him late round in the national draft if we think he is worth it.

whatever thought processes you went through to draw a line between the TJ trade and drafting sampi, i'm not sure. the only connection i can see is that we said we had an under 23 policy and this fits that policy perfectly.

you're reasoning is unbelievable and completely illogical.

[Jaded No More 57,946]

i don't want to bite you, i might catch something.

When uni work is getting you down, come to Demonland, pull up a chair, and enjoy the [censored] fights.

:D

[Rogue 585]

I thought we wanted a younger list so we bid farewell to TJ say hello to draft picks. Not a hello to someone like Sampi

Sampi is five years younger than TJ, and pick 14 will be used on a young player.

[Chook 14,502]

Bite me Deanox.

. . . cheats . . .

When uni work is getting you down, come to Demonland, pull up a chair, and enjoy the [censored] fights.

Yeah, isn't it fantastic to see the love that AFL engenders between its followers.

[Jaded No More 57,946]

Yeah, isn't it fantastic to see the love that AFL engenders between its followers.

Oh come on, you can definitely feel the sexual tension in the air

*runs to take cover*

[Rolling Stone 107]

Oh come on, you can definitely feel the sexual tension in the air

*runs to take cover*

Just reading about him in the Herald Sun today conjures up memories of the Byronator over the past 12 months. Overweight, unfit, finished the session with a knee injury. He has a lot of work to do in the next month because we can't afford to waste pick 3 in the PSD on someone who's not up to scratch.

[Bagdana 58]

Just reading about him in the Herald Sun today conjures up memories of the Byronator over the past 12 months. Overweight, unfit, finished the session with a knee injury. He has a lot of work to do in the next month because we can't afford to waste pick 3 in the PSD on someone who's not up to scratch.

Nahh,

He's running the Tan in sub 12 min and leaping small buildings in a single bound.

The Dee's have just told him to keep it on the low down for another couple of weeks!

[brey9186 102]

the harder sampi goes early, the more likely it is he'll hurt himself

id rather him lagging behind the group for the first little bit, because even though it mightnt seem like much, any fitness work is going to be good for him

[dazzledavey36 48,772]

can sum1 post a pic of sampi on the heard sun.. i haven't got the chance to see it yet and i wont have the chance to go down to town today again.

that would be cool

[71 Molloy 266]

Just reading about him in the Herald Sun today conjures up memories of the Byronator over the past 12 months. Overweight, unfit, finished the session with a knee injury. He has a lot of work to do in the next month because we can't afford to waste pick 3 in the PSD on someone who's not up to scratch.

I don't think we have to use the PSD pick, depending on how things pan out we could take late him in the coming draft.

[drdrake 3,038]

If he can show over the next 2 weeks the commitment that is required we should use either pick 51 or 64 to get him, that will mean we have gotten two past first round draft picks for really nothing and both at the right ages Sampi at 23 and Meesen at 21. We get 3 good kids with pick 4, 14, 21 and Sampi with another kid late. If we wait until the pre-season Draft we will be trumpt by Richmond or Carlton. If we do we draft as mentioned we will have 25 players on our list that will be at the end of this year 23 years old or under and that isn't taking into account the 4-5 rookies that we will get.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

I think it's 4 rookies isn't it?

Hayes, Neaves and Huges delisted, and Bode promoted, with Ooze and Neita on the veterans list... that means 4 newies...

Having said that they could re-rookie one or two of those guys. Maybe Neaves.

[dazzledavey36 48,772]

why? Neaves is crap..

we just got Meesen and we dont need another ruckman

[Little Goffy 12,577]

If he can show over the next 2 weeks the commitment that is required we should use either pick 51 or 64 to get him, that will mean we have gotten two past first round draft picks for really nothing and both at the right ages Sampi at 23 and Meesen at 21. We get 3 good kids with pick 4, 14, 21 and Sampi with another kid late. If we wait until the pre-season Draft we will be trumpt by Richmond or Carlton. If we do we draft as mentioned we will have 25 players on our list that will be at the end of this year 23 years old or under and that isn't taking into account the 4-5 rookies that we will get.

That sounds very, very good all up. Obviously it's still a big question mark on Sampi but if he looks like the real thing, hoo haa it's fun times at Melbourne FC Junior Squad!

Ahhh... there's that sneaking feeling that things could go very right for Melbourne pretty soon.

MEMBERSHIPS, GEEEEEEETTTAAA YA MEMBERSHIPS! Buy now before you look like a bandwagoner, make sure you get in before the premierships. MEMBERSHIPS!

[Redleg 37,612]

we just got Meesen and we dont need another ruckman

Yes we do. White is nearing the end. Jamar is not top level. Meesen is untried. Johnson is not a natural ruckman. We will draft another ruckman whether in the main draft or as a rookie.

[drdrake 3,038]

I think it's 4 rookies isn't it?

Hayes, Neaves and Huges delisted, and Bode promoted, with Ooze and Neita on the veterans list... that means 4 newies...

Having said that they could re-rookie one or two of those guys. Maybe Neaves.

You could be right, but I think we have 6 spots left on our list and I'm unsure if we can have another rookie if we only select 5 players for our senior list.

[Rogue 585]

we just got Meesen and we dont need another ruckman

Sure we do.

Neither Meesen, PJ, or Jamar have cemented themselves as a second ruck, let alone as capable of taking the first ruck mantle from White, who is nearing the end of his AFL career.

I'd be rookie-ing at least one young ruck.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Yes we do. White is nearing the end. Jamar is not top level. Meesen is untried. Johnson is not a natural ruckman. We will draft another ruckman whether in the main draft or as a rookie.

Agree. Exactly right.

[tess 19]

Sure we do.

Neither Meesen, PJ, or Jamar have cemented themselves as a second ruck, let alone as capable of taking the first ruck mantle from White, who is nearing the end of his AFL career.

I'd be rookie-ing at least one young ruck.

You pretty much just copied what Redleg wrote.

[Rogue 585]

You pretty much just copied what Redleg wrote.

We do seem to share the same view, but I certainly didn't copy what Redleg posted. Perhaps I didn't see his reply, as if I had, I imagine I would quote Redleg's response and follow on from that, or not post at all.

I'm 'on the record' with a few similar-sounding replies on this topic - in example, this post one month ago, which is quite similar to the views Redleg and I have expressed in this thread:

This topic has been done to death recently. Anyhow...

White doesn't have too much longer left. Neither PJ, Jamar, or Meesen has even cemented a #2 ruck spot, let alone show they're capable of taking over as first ruck. If anything, we don't have enough rucks. I'd certainly be rookie listing a young ruckman.

Perhaps Redleg pretty much just copied what I wrote then?

Yes we do. White is nearing the end. Jamar is not top level. Meesen is untried. Johnson is not a natural ruckman. We will draft another ruckman whether in the main draft or as a rookie.

NB: I'm certainly not impying that Redleg copied what I posted a month ago, just making the point that it's not rare to find similar opinions expressed by more than one author..!