A very good listen

9 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

A very good listen

Out of all the passionate nonsense these guys were dribbling on this podcast, I nearly crashed my car when they all agreed Buckley was the ideal Goodwin replacement. How many coaches have won premierships coaching their second team this century?

I get some supporters find this stuff cathartic, but 95% of the conversation either contradicted something said earlier in the pod, or just made no rational sense whatsoever.

18 minutes ago, Davos said:

Out of all the passionate nonsense these guys were dribbling on this podcast, I nearly crashed my car when they all agreed Buckley was the ideal Goodwin replacement. How many coaches have won premierships coaching their second team this century?

I get some supporters find this stuff cathartic, but 95% of the conversation either contradicted something said earlier in the pod, or just made no rational sense whatsoever.

I agreed with about 90% of what they said

1 hour ago, Sir Why You Little said:

A very good listen

30 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

I agreed with about 90% of what they said

I've always found (at least 90% of the time) when people say it's a good listen what they really mean is these guys agree with my thinking...

3 minutes ago, rjay said:

I've always found (at least 90% of the time) when people say it's a good listen what they really mean is these guys agree with my thinking...

Exactly right. But there were one or 2 things i disagreed with

Edited July 11Jul 11 by Sir Why You Little

1 hour ago, Davos said:

Out of all the passionate nonsense these guys were dribbling on this podcast, I nearly crashed my car when they all agreed Buckley was the ideal Goodwin replacement. How many coaches have won premierships coaching their second team this century?

I get some supporters find this stuff cathartic, but 95% of the conversation either contradicted something said earlier in the pod, or just made no rational sense whatsoever.

Just saved me a listen because this is exactly how I thought it would go.

They have @Demonland covered in terms of MFCSS 90% of the time too.

The DeeBrief.. lols.

You know you're scraping the barrel when you're taking these guys guys.

I had low expectations but i didn't think it was too bad.

the guy in the baseball cap not bad. the other 2, I wouldn't pay too much attention to.

They discuss the same issues we do here. Some of their prescriptions though. Why anyone thinks Nathan Buckley is the answer is beyond me. Took a premiership pies list and drove it into the ground. Plus he's been sitting on a couch for 3 years.

I’m a subscriber to the DeeBrief but their content can be very reactionary

And sometimes it’s just hard to get through because they won’t stay on topic for more than a minute before someone else jumps in

Regardless they’re just Dees fans going through it at the moment like we all are - and FWIW I agree with the overall sentiment on the need for change

But if your answer is Nathan Buckley then it’s a good thing you’re not at the club making these decisions 🤣

2 hours ago, Davos said:

Out of all the passionate nonsense these guys were dribbling on this podcast, I nearly crashed my car when they all agreed Buckley was the ideal Goodwin replacement. How many coaches have won premierships coaching their second team this century?

I get some supporters find this stuff cathartic, but 95% of the conversation either contradicted something said earlier in the pod, or just made no rational sense whatsoever.

Yep as weird as it seems a rookie coach is the way to go, you would think experience would be helpful but it seems to work against coaches the longer they are in the system

6 minutes ago, demoncat said:

I’m a subscriber to the DeeBrief but their content can be very reactionary

And sometimes it’s just hard to get through because they won’t stay on topic for more than a minute before someone else jumps in

Regardless they’re just Dees fans going through it at the moment like we all are - and FWIW I agree with the overall sentiment on the need for change

But if your answer is Nathan Buckley then it’s a good thing you’re not at the club making these decisions 🤣

Yeah, to be clear the last thing I want to do is start a Deebrief pile on. I listen to them probably once a week on average, but take them for what they are - nuffie fans with little to no idea about the inner workings of the club or what's going right or wrong on field (like all of us posting on here).

Depends how you like your hyperbole I guess.

Surprised they scored an interview with Greenie considering the way they rage about everything.

37 minutes ago, BDA said:

I had low expectations but i didn't think it was too bad.

the guy in the baseball cap not bad. the other 2, I wouldn't pay too much attention to.

They discuss the same issues we do here. Some of their prescriptions though. Why anyone thinks Nathan Buckley is the answer is beyond me. Took a premiership pies list and drove it into the ground. Plus he's been sitting on a couch for 3 years.

Sounds like an ideal candidate for the saints

If toxicity is your thing you should watch some of the EFL fan channels

Deebrief very tame in comparison

17 minutes ago, Rab D Nesbitt said:

Depends how you like your hyperbole I guess.

Surprised they scored an interview with Greenie considering the way they rage about everything.

That touches on the most interesting thing about this edition for me. Adrian, who runs the pod, normally "toes the party line" which no doubt assists with access to Club officers and employees.

They have reached an anti-Simon view and he was happy for that to be aired.....

50 minutes ago, demoncat said:

I’m a subscriber to the DeeBrief but their content can be very reactionary

And sometimes it’s just hard to get through because they won’t stay on topic for more than a minute before someone else jumps in

Regardless they’re just Dees fans going through it at the moment like we all are - and FWIW I agree with the overall sentiment on the need for change

But if your answer is Nathan Buckley then it’s a good thing you’re not at the club making these decisions 🤣

Yes the Buckley talk was certainly overdone…

The DeeBrief Bros are not worth anyone’s time.

The episodes with Ryan from the Demon Army are the better ones. He's very measured, articulate and non-reactionary, while still being passionate.

Edited July 11Jul 11 by John Demonic

2 hours ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Yes the Buckley talk was certainly overdone…

I felt they were taking the [censored] a little bit on the Nathan Buckley topic. Maybe just desperation to have someone other than Simon.

I am also desperate 😅😭

Edited July 11Jul 11 by ElDiablo14

22 minutes ago, ElDiablo14 said:

I felt they were taking the [censored] a little bit on the Nathan Buckley topic. Maybe just desperation to have someone other than Simon.

I am also desperate 😅😭

Big Changes are needed, there’s no doubt. Last Year’s Review was a sham, so the problems, whatever they are, have got worse. I am just interested to hear guys talking, who are 30 years younger than me, I don’t want them to go through the pain that i went through Decade after Decade.

This Current Situation could well be the Fork in the Road

‘26 cannot be a Rinse and Repeat

6 hours ago, BDA said:

I had low expectations but i didn't think it was too bad.

the guy in the baseball cap not bad. the other 2, I wouldn't pay too much attention to.

They discuss the same issues we do here. Some of their prescriptions though. Why anyone thinks Nathan Buckley is the answer is beyond me. Took a premiership pies list and drove it into the ground. Plus he's been sitting on a couch for 3 years.

Agree, Buckley is not the answer.

Edited July 11Jul 11 by YesitwasaWin4theAges

Some horrific superiority complexes here.

Some very passionate dees fans doing what they love. Provide content (invaluable for overseas fans like myself) for basically $0. Pile on is unnecessary.

If any of the guys are reading - keep being authentic. I love your work as much as I love Andy, George and Binman. Don't have to agree to appreciate 👏 👏 👏

Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seemed as though The DeeBrief guys were having a crack at Goody for not playing Nathan Jones in the GF. Didn't NJ leave the Perth hub during the '21 grand final week to be with his wife who was about to give birth to twins?

Also, while I agree that change is desperately needed, can we please never consider Nathan Buckley as the coach of the Melbourne Football Club ever again?

I'd hire Nathan Buckley just to [censored] Eddie McGuire off.