My read of the situation is that after they cracked the [censored] the club felt it might be better to give them some space.

Jay Clark is a Pies shill trying to drive down the price the Pies will pay if Trac wants a trade there.

16 hours ago, At the break of Gawn said:

Anyone hear the [censored] Jay Clark was talking about earlier about how Melbourne only just recently broke bread with Petracca's parents? It sounded super vague and he was backtracking a bit.

At least it's happened now I guess.

1 hour ago, Clintosaurus said:

Jay Clark is a Pies shill trying to drive down the price the Pies will pay if Trac wants a trade there.

They can have him cheap, just get him and Oliver off the books. If those 2 net us picks 9 and 10 I'll be happy enough. Both have played a solid part in our demise.

On 09/04/2025 at 15:49, Roost it far said:

Basically he saw Oliver talking to Geelong players after the game and then realised, without a doubt, that Oliver still wants to live in a farm.

Are you sure he said 'in' and not 'on'

I think we need to get comfortable with the thought that Kos, Trac, Oliver and even JVR might be gone at years end. Could also see Sestan, Laurie, Howes, McVee and Petty chasing trades. Some given little game time, others regretting contract extensions and sold false hope. We need some senior players with kicking skills and leadership from other clubs. Plus 2-3 high draft picks

3 minutes ago, SPC said:

I think we need to get comfortable with the thought that Kos, Trac, Oliver and even JVR might be gone at years end. Could also see Sestan, Laurie, Howes, McVee and Petty chasing trades. Some given little game time, others regretting contract extensions and sold false hope. We need some senior players with kicking skills and leadership from other clubs. Plus 2-3 high draft picks

Gawn to the Cats too? They need a ruck

6 minutes ago, SPC said:

I think we need to get comfortable with the thought that Kos, Trac, Oliver and even JVR might be gone at years end. Could also see Sestan, Laurie, Howes, McVee and Petty chasing trades. Some given little game time, others regretting contract extensions and sold false hope. We need some senior players with kicking skills and leadership from other clubs. Plus 2-3 high draft picks

Not even sure @Demonland is this pessimistic. MFCSSSSSS level here.

Just now, Clintosaurus said:

Not even sure @Demonland is this pessimistic. MFCSSSSSS level here.

Our 2025 second round pick has requested a trade

20 minutes ago, SPC said:

I think we need to get comfortable with the thought that Kos, Trac, Oliver and even JVR might be gone at years end. Could also see Sestan, Laurie, Howes, McVee and Petty chasing trades. Some given little game time, others regretting contract extensions and sold false hope. We need some senior players with kicking skills and leadership from other clubs. Plus 2-3 high draft picks

We could package up Sesto, Bill and Howes for someone's fourth round pick.

These things are small potatoes for me now. I'm thinking long term.

We need to become a good club first and foremost.

#1. Get a training base. It's held us back for 30 years and we cannot attract talent based on 'good team culture' anymore. It's a massive hindrance and it needs to be sorted before we can truly become a club that has sustained success.

#2. Anyone who doesn't want to be here can go. Accept unders if/when required and get on with it. I don't want to see a pea heart effort like the first 2 quarters ever again.

#3. Rebuild as best we can before Tas come into the comp.

Has anyone looked at the damage petracca had from heeney in the Colgate ad? He has not been the same since he put his knee into the ribs for his speccy

Edited Sunday at 09:571 day by Age

1 hour ago, SPC said:

I think we need to get comfortable with the thought that Kos, Trac, Oliver and even JVR might be gone at years end. Could also see Sestan, Laurie, Howes, McVee and Petty chasing trades. Some given little game time, others regretting contract extensions and sold false hope. We need some senior players with kicking skills and leadership from other clubs. Plus 2-3 high draft picks

That is ridiculous.

To me its either Clarry or Trac that need to go, not both. I have seen enough of Clarry and I'm pretty adamant he has fallen out-of-love with Footy. He has lost the ruthless edge which carried us to the flag. It doesn't have to be off by much but id look to move him on. Maybe Saints would be desperate enough to off us 2 picks this year and next.

I'm indifferent bout Trac, but we cannot offload both. Trac will at least give us some solid performances and set standards with the youth. He'll also play to his mid 30's i reckon.

We have to keep Koz to contract and only release him if the offer from Freo is over-the-top good. Has to be a top 5 pick or a F1 and this years first.

Edited Sunday at 10:161 day by GS_1905

20 hours ago, At the break of Gawn said:

Anyone hear the [censored] Jay Clark was talking about earlier about how Melbourne only just recently broke bread with Petracca's parents? It sounded super vague and he was backtracking a bit.

I realise I’m in the minority here but Trac is a grown adult, why are the club talking to his parents? At times it feels like these blokes are treated like giant primary school kids

12 minutes ago, GS_1905 said:

Maybe Saints would be desperate enough to off us 2 picks this year and next.

not even the saints are that stupid

a late first rounder and paying some of his salary is the best we can hope for

I'm not talking about this every week. Wouldn't waste my energy

24 minutes ago, deegirl said:

I realise I’m in the minority here but Trac is a grown adult, why are the club talking to his parents? At times it feels like these blokes are treated like giant primary school kids

Or, family is an important element and factor.

Mine is.

6 minutes ago, Nietaphart said:

Or, family is an important element and factor.

Mine is.

Mine are too but I don’t have them involved in discussions with my employer

Just now, deegirl said:

Mine are too but I don’t have them involved in discussions with my employer

True that, but my employer never had my health on a knife edge either. If they did balls that up my family would be asking questions (at least)

With highly compromised drafts no much point in trading players out unless you get comparable players in.

55 minutes ago, Nietaphart said:

True that, but my employer never had my health on a knife edge either. If they did balls that up my family would be asking questions (at least)

And that would be for the lawyers to sort.
Not ya mum and dad.
Especially if you're a 29yr old man.

3 hours ago, SPC said:

I think we need to get comfortable with the thought that Kos, Trac, Oliver and even JVR might be gone at years end. Could also see Sestan, Laurie, Howes, McVee and Petty chasing trades. Some given little game time, others regretting contract extensions and sold false hope. We need some senior players with kicking skills and leadership from other clubs. Plus 2-3 high draft picks

You taking the p-i-s-s right?

Edited Sunday at 12:121 day by Jibroni

6 hours ago, Fork 'em said:

Just saw that.

I dunno why the club needs to be breaking bread with Petraccas parents anyway.
He's 29yr old man FFS.
If a 29yr old was injured at work do you think the company is breaking bread with the employees parents?
Short answer is .... No.

The fact that the other fools at the table were showing their mock outrage just shows how immature footballers in general are.
Petracca even more so it seems after last years carry on.

Maybe the reason this meeting has only recently occurred is because neither party has felt it’s been necessary.

I think you’re getting a bit overworked about something that, for all we know, was just a dinner.

2 hours ago, Age said:

Has anyone looked at the damage petracca had from heeney in the Colgate ad? He has not been the same since he put his knee into the ribs for his speccy

There is a huge difference between how Heeney uses his knee to get lift for the mark, that’s the way it should be done versus the way Moore used his knee deliberately, in my mind, as a weapon to inflict damage to the opposition player in front of him and in doing so actually limited the lift he could get to spoil the ball.

8 minutes ago, Fork 'em said:

And that would be for the lawyers to sort.
Not ya mum and dad.
Especially if you're a 29yr old man.

I think an organisation of any type would be sensitive to health of an employee and the stress it places on a family. Add to this the role of an Italian family and the way they work as a family. It was a workplace incident.

We need to move past this idea that footy is a ‘man’s’ game and everyone should toughen the F up. If Trac was my family, I’d ask a few questions and lose trust in the club and its medical staff.

im sure the club has invited the family into the rooms and facilities and encouraged them to play a role over the years. You can’t have it both ways…