12 hours ago, KozzyCan said:

Bit of a waste of time and money from North going with that defence.

Yeah 10 grand wasted outa the soft cap, deserved what he got and I reckon 4 weeks more to the incident, so got of lightly!

At the rate North are forking out money for failed tribunal appeals they’ll have to play a third home game in WA.

1 minute ago, Rab D Nesbitt said:

At the rate North are forking out money for failed tribunal appeals they’ll have to play a third home game in WA.

Glass houses RDN

1 hour ago, picket fence said:

Yeah 10 grand wasted outa the soft cap, deserved what he got and I reckon 4 weeks more to the incident, so got of lightly!

In view of what could have been viewed beforehand, similar contact instances, I totally agree.

The tribunal to North after their appeal, probably

I get this impression that North Melbourne's (and probably ours as well to be fair) QC/lawyer is Lionel Hutz, while Carlton's and Collingwood's is Mr Burns's massive crack team of lawyers.

MRO has sent May sent straight to the Tribunal. Contact rated Careless, High, Severe Impact.

The still photo showing May's shoulder into Evans is the result of May being 11 cm taller than Evans so unfortunately any contact was never going to end well for Evans..

The height difference and both players going for the ball mans the contact was Accidental not Careless so the charge should be dismissed. May has oft offended but he doesn't deserve to go for that.

To have any hope of having the charge thrown out we must NOT use Adrian Anderson.

Edited July 20Jul 20 by Lucifers Hero

3 weeks

It is the way

All part of the AFL concussion liability protection saga

4 hours ago, Diamond_Jim said:

3 weeks

It is the way

All part of the AFL concussion liability protection saga

It’s [censored] [censored]

Every player should be the same height and wear NFL costumes

Darcy Moore and Brayden Maynard not cited by ex Pies premiership MRO.

Nothing to see here.

Dropping the knees into a guys back just fine.

Pushing a guy into the dugout just fine.

11 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Darcy Moore and Brayden Maynard not cited by ex Pies premiership MRO.

Nothing to see here.

Dropping the knees into a guys back just fine.

Pushing a guy into the dugout just fine.

Disappointing but expected. Both deserve suspension for mine.

12 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Darcy Moore and Brayden Maynard not cited by ex Pies premiership MRO.

Nothing to see here.

Dropping the knees into a guys back just fine.

Pushing a guy into the dugout just fine.

Darcy Moore and Brayden Maynard not cited by ex Pies premiership MRO.

Nothing to see here.

Dropping the knees into a guys back just fine.

Pushing a guy into the dugout just fine.

Just proves how corrupt the AFL are!

Edited July 21Jul 21 by jules7

Pretty funny - Patrick Cripps (Carlton skipper) has come out saying;

"As a young guy or a young kid coming in, you're always taught (to) bodyline the ball and when the ball's in dispute, you want to go and win the ball…

Obviously you never want to see a player get injured – obviously Frankie was courageous in what he did, you never want to see a player get injured – but I just reckon it's so tough. I don't understand what we want May to do there…

If that's a Grand Final and he hesitates, and let's say Frankie gets the ball... what do you do? I never want to see people go off in the game with with head knocks but I just think it's a really tough situation."

Even the opposition players are mind boggled about how the game should be played and likely disagree with it to some extent.

How the [censored] did Moore not get sighted.

1 hour ago, ANG13 said:

How the [censored] did Moore not get sighted.

Of course, we all know why.

18 minutes ago, monoccular said:

Of course, we all know why.

True. It’s another blight on the competition. Greg Swan has a lot of work to do.

Will say what’s been super refreshing, Kossie hasn’t done his once yearly late sniper bulb on anyone, which is a common once a year occurrence.

I assume he has done a lot of work to cut out the behavior because it was obvious on how important he is and the results we weren’t getting when he was suspended. (Sadly same result on the ladder, however not due to him).

Good on ya Kossie, great to see. Keep it up.

This will be an easy listen on a Monday night:

https://x.com/1116sen/status/1947178476747837859

David King reckons it's May's responsibility to pull out of the contest when he thinks he'll get there second. Lovely. Imagine all the contests players would pull out of if they had to be sure they'd get there first.

Edited July 21Jul 21 by Chook

How the hell did Moore escape with just a 50m penalty.

He kneed someone in the back deliberately. It's dangerous

58 minutes ago, SadDee said:

Will say what’s been super refreshing, Kossie hasn’t done his once yearly late sniper bulb on anyone, which is a common once a year occurrence.

I assume he has done a lot of work to cut out the behavior because it was obvious on how important he is and the results we weren’t getting when he was suspended. (Sadly same result on the ladder, however not due to him).

Good on ya Kossie, great to see. Keep it up.

Sorry, can't cop this.

Never forget . More than half Picketts infringements were nothing, let alone reportable, some as testified by his opposition. This is not a good boy competition. Kossie does not have to be a good boy, as a continuance of his participation.

The post is just about the height of ignorance and should be ignored.

13 minutes ago, dees189227 said:

How the hell did Moore escape with just a 50m penalty.

He kneed someone in the back deliberately. It's dangerous

IMO it was a cynical move by Moore to provoke an over reaction from Freo players to have the mark annulled and a get Collingwood a free. Good to see Corey Wagner was aware of the danger and got in there to calm his teammates down.

Edited July 21Jul 21 by John Crow Batty

14 minutes ago, John Crow Batty said:

IMO it was a cynical move by Moore to provoke an over reaction from Freo players to have the mark annulled and a get Collingwood a free. Good to see Corey Wagner was aware of the danger and got in there to calm his teammates down.

You use the words cynical attempt to reverse the mark. I think he just loves to use his knees to hurt opponents, and knew that he had nothing to fear from their tame MRO: he could have caused severe internal injuries, again, with impunity.

9 hours ago, Willmoy1947 said:

Sorry, can't cop this.

Never forget . More than half Picketts infringements were nothing, let alone reportable, some as testified by his opposition. This is not a good boy competition. Kossie does not have to be a good boy, as a continuance of his participation.

The post is just about the height of ignorance and should be ignored.

You ok, dear?

I find it funny that you think that he can be a dirty sniper.

When he gets suspended for his bumps, he only impacts his team. If you don’t see that, you’re the height of ignorance.

13 hours ago, Redleg said:

Darcy Moore not cited by ex Pies premiership MRO.

Nothing to see here.

Dropping the knees into a guys back just fine.

Finn Maginnes who suffered a lacerated kidney from a knock might be very interested in that ruling.

Darcy is now a recidivist in injuring players with his knees and yet escapes punishment every time.

Jack Reiwoldt, Garry Lyon and even Nathan Buckley said he should have been suspended.

Edited July 21Jul 21 by Redleg

Just now, Redleg said:

Finn Maginnes who suffered a lacerated kidney from a knock might be very interested in that ruling.

Darcy is now a recidivist in injuring players with his knees and yet escapes punishment every time.

Jack Reiwoldt and even Nathan Buckley said he should have been suspended.

Question (rhetorical)

How often are Collingwood players EVER cited let alone suspended ?