At this rate Judd will be lining up for west coast in round 1 next year and we will still be going in this thread about when it’s going to be announced

My vote.

I want him McVee to stay.

He has shown the ability to lockdown small forwards as well as rebound and have skill and composure. I think we should offer him a 4 year deal. Also see him play more of a half back role to get into the game more.

If the West Coast Weasals or Fockers offer him to cone back to WA and more $ $ and/or 5 years plus, then so be it.

1 hour ago, spirit of norm smith said:

My vote.

I want him McVee to stay.

He has shown the ability to lockdown small forwards as well as rebound and have skill and composure. I think we should offer him a 4 year deal. Also see him play more of a half back role to get into the game more.

If the West Coast Weasals or Fockers offer him to cone back to WA and more $ $ and/or 5 years plus, then so be it.

My vote - not fussed either way

Why is the offer only 2 years? Is that all he wants to sign on for? If he wants longer I can see why he might have his nose out of joint when we seem happy to hand out big and long contracts for fun when it comes to certain players.

1 minute ago, Colm said:

Why is the offer only 2 years? Is that all he wants to sign on for? If he wants longer I can see why he might have his nose out of joint when we seem happy to hand out big and long contracts for fun when it comes to certain players.

Pretty sure we offered 4 initially but he only wanted 2?

14 minutes ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

Pretty sure we offered 4 initially but he only wanted 2?

He might only want short term if he’s not convinced our MFC future, living in Melbourne or indeed his role in the team. Again offer four years. If he only wants to sign up for two years, that’s okay.

2 hours ago, mmwd6 said:

Heard from a very good source yesterday that he hasn’t signed anything yet and is still undecided. Could’ve just been keeping his cards close but I would’ve expected an announcement by now.

God help us all if Dannyz mail is wrong. What a bizarre set of circumstances

2 minutes ago, BigBadBustling said:

God help us all if Dannyz mail is wrong. What a bizarre set of circumstances

At this stage the only thing that would make this thread worth the trouble is the creation of a new perfume brand featuring scents inspired here.

Sideline hugs body mist; for when it's time to hit the showers

Grosse oeuf; eau de visage

L'attendree Juddot; a signature scent inspired by Beckett

22 minutes ago, BigBadBustling said:

God help us all if Dannyz mail is wrong. What a bizarre set of circumstances

Id still trust his over mine. Mine would absolutely know what’s going on but wouldn’t necessarily always tell the complete truth.

1 hour ago, spirit of norm smith said:

He might only want short term if he’s not convinced our MFC future, living in Melbourne or indeed his role in the team. Again offer four years. If he only wants to sign up for two years, that’s okay.

Could be a number of reasons its 2 without hearing from him .. family reasons, heath reasons of others, gf reasons, tax reasons, post footy career reasons, mfc reasons, too many to mention all guessing won't help

4 hours ago, Little Goffy said:

At this stage the only thing that would make this thread worth the trouble is the creation of a new perfume brand featuring scents inspired here.

Sideline hugs body mist; for when it's time to hit the showers

Grosse oeuf; eau de visage

L'attendree Juddot; a signature scent inspired by Beckett

Deserves more 👏 👏👏

😆😆😆😆😆

Can the Dees be aggressive and creative with there trading. Take a leaf out of Hawthorns book.

Make it an absolute Priority to target Jobe Shanahan.

McVee to West Coast for Jobe Shanahan… Throw In a nice pick exchange to get it done.

Mcvee in 2024 was a star in the making with poise and disposal accuracy under pressure. 2024 shows what he can do.

I get a real feeling their are some very fractured relationships between players in the club.

1400 posts about a Back Pocket

We all need to get a life 😂

18 hours ago, Dee Vision said:

Can the Dees be aggressive and creative with there trading. Take a leaf out of Hawthorns book.

Make it an absolute Priority to target Jobe Shanahan.

McVee to West Coast for Jobe Shanahan… Throw In a nice pick exchange to get it done.

Who

18 hours ago, Dee Vision said:

Can the Dees be aggressive and creative with there trading. Take a leaf out of Hawthorns book.

Make it an absolute Priority to target Jobe Shanahan.

McVee to West Coast for Jobe Shanahan… Throw In a nice pick exchange to get it done.

WC aren't trading their only key forward prospects for a back pocket. Especially after losing Allen

1 hour ago, Norm Smith's Curse said:

Mcvee in 2024 was a star in the making with poise and disposal accuracy under pressure. 2024 shows what he can do.

I get a real feeling their are some very fractured relationships between players in the club.

Exactly

1 hour ago, Billy said:

1400 posts about a Back Pocket

We all need to get a life 😂

I love a good posts count post! Thanks, Billy!

3 hours ago, Timothy Reddan-A'Blew said:

I love a good posts count post! Thanks, Billy!

+1

On 20/09/2025 at 12:38, BigBadBustling said:

God help us all if Dannyz mail is wrong. What a bizarre set of circumstances

As far as I know Dannyz hasn’t been given the MASSIVE Egg on the Face warning. I think it’s only fair that he’s also issued this warning. Perhaps he and I can share a clutch of emu or ostrich eggs? I’d offer up my bantams’ eggs but we’d need a minimum of 30 of those bad boys to make just one emu egg. My girls aren’t machines. 😁

On 19/09/2025 at 07:50, adonski said:

its the J U double D

Mac V to the Double E

4 minutes ago, DubDee said:

Mac V to the Double E

...says his bro, Dub D to the Double E 😉

has he signed yet??

12 minutes ago, Kent said:

has he signed yet??

Depend who you ask