Can't be worse than Hunter, Shaq, Fullarton etc.

Get him on board.

2 hours ago, Go the Biff said:

Dimma didn't want Mabior Chol. He's gone alright since parting company with Hardwick. Twice.

I thought he was getting ironical cheers from the hawks fans Friday night? 
 

Not sure Dimma is losing much sleep over letting him go? 

4 hours ago, Pulp Fritschon said:

Always liked Rosas but the fact that Dimma doesn’t want him probably says it all. 

 

2 hours ago, Go the Biff said:

Dimma didn't want Mabior Chol. He's gone alright since parting company with Hardwick. Twice.

Dimma would be pretty hard on blokes who don't have a good work ethic

Chol doesn't look like a big worker. Rosas from reports is pretty slack

On 03/09/2024 at 09:19, layzie said:

No idea why they would be shipping him out so soon.

If available I'd definitely be having a look, he's your classic small forward with blistering speed on the outside and very good defensive pressure. Different to Nibbler of course but could go a way to filling that particular void. 

If you all  read the post about 10 back they have an NGA Lombard ready in the next draft in Nov and  3 other half forwards on list inc. Humphries and Ainsworth. 

Do our due diligence but he may fit into side as ANB replacement? 

Recent article from Fox.

I am all for Mally coming to us

He is walk up starter imo and gives Kozzy more time in the Mid

His best has him at a sub 10 touches, 1 goal, 2 tackles per game at best. No thanks.

11 minutes ago, MurDoc516 said:

His best has him at a sub 10 touches, 1 goal, 2 tackles per game at best. No thanks.

Played almost every min forward during his career

Take away the disposals and look at his pressure acts, goal assists

Would be an upgrade to what we currently have

We need X factor and pace go get him

Definitely a yes from me. Has X factor and skill and would be a nice 1-2 punch with Kozzy

We definitely need another agile small forward in addition to Kossie. We should have a crack at this guy.

45 minutes ago, SthSea22 said:

Played almost every min forward during his career

Take away the disposals and look at his pressure acts, goal assists

Would be an upgrade to what we currently have

isn't it his lack of these that has kept him out of gc17's side? that's certainly the impression i have had

averages just over 2 tackles per game, less than half a goal assist per game, and only 1.5 i50s per game in the few afl games he's played

vfl stats from @WheeloRatings indicate in the vfl his averages per game bounce to:

• 18.1 disposals

• 1 goal per game

• 3.7 score involvements

• 3.2 tackles

  • 0.7 tackles i50

wouldn't want to give up much for him - wonder what he's 'worth'

we definitely need a pressure forward, but one who impacts the scoreboard too... but so too does just about every team

18 minutes ago, whatwhat say what said:

isn't it his lack of these that has kept him out of gc17's side? that's certainly the impression i have had

averages just over 2 tackles per game, less than half a goal assist per game, and only 1.5 i50s per game in the few afl games he's played

vfl stats from @WheeloRatings indicate in the vfl his averages per game bounce to:

• 18.1 disposals

• 1 goal per game

• 3.7 score involvements

• 3.2 tackles

  • 0.7 tackles i50

wouldn't want to give up much for him - wonder what he's 'worth'

we definitely need a pressure forward, but one who impacts the scoreboard too... but so too does just about every team

Would cost us peanuts as GC want him gone

They told him he could explore another FC last season also

Did he play under King?

1 hour ago, 2021 said:

Did he play under King?

Yep, just went back and looked, played in 5/7 games.

Edited September 19, 2025Sep 19 by Mouseymoo

2 hours ago, 2021 said:

Did he play under King?

i'd trust King to know if he had the potential/temperament. we clearly need more speed and run.. all for it if King is keen.

GC have to offload players for spots for academy picks.

We have had a poor record with picking up unwanted other club players lately.

Change of luck due?

Perhaps with Kosi headed for more mid time Rosas with lightening speed may be worth a try forward?

He may need a change.

10 minutes ago, manny100 said:

GC have to offload players for spots for academy picks.

We have had a poor record with picking up unwanted other club players lately.

Change of luck due?

Perhaps with Kosi headed for more mid time Rosas with lightening speed may be worth a try forward?

He may need a change.

Rosas could end up giving us a solid Jeff Garlett like career or just end up as another Harry Sharp, Tom Fullarton type who end up being genuine plodders.

Trades are pretty much just a lottery.

Steak knives in a Trac-Flanders deal.

Ricky Mentha Jnr

If we recruit him to play alongside Gawn, Pickett, Langford and Lindsay we'd have guns and Rosas.

He is pretty quick, and I always say there’s no substitute for speed

Moses supposes Rosas has toeses

Started at Darwin Buffaloes same Club as Matty Whelan - there's an open.

Sign him up.

On 24/09/2025 at 10:28, DiscoStu17 said:

He is pretty quick, and I always say there’s no substitute for speed

Moses supposes Rosas has toeses

I really like him, but having watched a lot of Casey games, I would elevate young Ricky Mentha before signing Rosas.