1 minute ago, Stevienic23 said:

Can we get our forwards on the Jesse Hogan gym program? He is a unit

The Genetics program?
He was a beast at 17years old.

11 minutes ago, layzie said:

One team's season ends while another starts. Better team won 

In the end it could have gone either way.

We lost against a top-four team because of some crucial errors, not because any of the umpires cheated.

That's tough to take but hardly a reason for some of the venom being aimed at the players.

15 minutes ago, YesitwasaWin4theAges said:

Some author will write a best seller on how to destroy a Premiership window based on the Melbourne Football Club.

94% of teams don't win the flag every year. In any year there's roughly 4 teams with a good shot at winning it, with form, fitness, health, game plan, luck all factors. Winning a flag is definitionally a successful traversal of a premiership window.

I wouldn't put the house on that book being a best seller.

Edited July 27, 2024Jul 27 by gs77

3 minutes ago, Superunknown said:

Just lol

The dynasty that got away

lol 

dynasty

[censored] season 2024 is the gift that keeps on giving.

Season on the line going into the last quarter and they dish that up. GWS kicked more goals (4) than we had touches after 5 minutes. Pathetic really. 

With 8 minutes left, Green kicked it OOF about 60 from our goal. We wasted about a minute switching the ball and then lost it out of bounds in the same spot, but on the other side of the ground. The [censored] was that?

And with 3 minutes left, we let them chip it around with ease. About a minute or minute and a half burnt. That extra time would have been handy at the end.

I dunno, I’m proud of the effort, but it is frustrating to see us bottling another season.

It didn’t even take a page for someone to say Laurie isn’t AFL standard , but I thought he showed a bit. 
 

 

That last centre bounce was an absolute balls up.  

Max could have smacked it forward or at least just try to get it down. 

Instead Greene just waltzed it out

7 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Back on the coaching with this one. Hogan is the premier full forward in the game and we have the premier fullback playing on Jake Riccardi until they made the move late in the last quarter.

Horrid coaching

Agree. McDonald unable to defend last 6 - 8 weeks, Lever showed the same and May has regressed this year, overweight IMO. 

HQ got new favourites so we get the ****ty end of the stick

Petracca's absence was felt hard tonight. We really lack any sort of dynamism through the midfield and it shows.

 

3 minutes ago, Vineytime said:

There’s been more than 1 bad game, last 6 weeks he has been unable to defend, yeah he’s had a few kicks. Not the answer moving forward and time to go past him IMO. 

Ok.

2 minutes ago, DubDee said:

Can May ever regain any agility or is he done?

If the former he should sit out the season and get right. having a guy that can’t bend over at all is killing us

 May hasn't been able to collect a ground ball ... Ever.

Who was the genius who decided to put may on Riccardi? Cost us the game

3 minutes ago, dees189227 said:

  

Max could have smacked it forward or at least just try to get it down. 

 

Well he smacked the previous one forward .... To a lone GWS player.

Edited July 27, 2024Jul 27 by Fork 'em

20 minutes ago, JJR said:

Billings and Laurie not up to AFL standard.

They're not alone there though.

I'm really frustrated with Fritsch, he is a class player but his defensive efforts are deplorable. Late in the game "chasing" an opponent across half back his heart rate wouldn't have gone above 80bpm.

16k is club killing stuff

19 minutes ago, Lexinator said:

Umpires genuinely cost us the game, no ifs or buts about it.

I have not been as furious with the umpiring in I honestly don't know how long. 

I was apoplectic

Simply appalling. I'm still seething.

The blatant inconsistency is just mind numbing.

15 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Mids got absolutely smashed all night.

You'd think by the last quarter we would have at least try to really go defensive on their mids to stop their stoppage dominance, but no we didn't.

Oliver giving Green space in that last centre contests sums it all up.

I’d think that if we had a 6x AA ruck playing against a ruckman with 1 arm; Oliver should have been trying to make space so we could win a game defining clearance.

Gutsy effort to come back in the last 10 mins

Another wasted season 

Should have been 6 goals up at quarter time. 

Should never have conceded four goals in 5 minutes to start the last. 

Billings and Bowey atrocious, Gawn not fit, not sure May’s fit, and TMac had an all time stinker.

Some dodgy 50/50 umpiring against us (it was obviously a push to May and Green sucked them in by dropping his knees) but we are far too inefficient and it keeps killing us.

I love Maxy but his center bounce tapwork was horrible all night. 

bitterly cold, bitterly disappointing

22 minutes ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

Beat the Lions last year off the top of my head

You had lions on the top of your head?? 

Through circumstances beyond anyone's control we just have too many key players out or underdone, and it's going to have an impact. Gutsy performance all the same against one of the best sides in the comp.

4 minutes ago, dees189227 said:

That last centre bounce was an absolute balls up.  

Max could have smacked it forward or at least just try to get it down. 

Instead Greene just waltzed it out

It was woeful.

Clarry was behind Greene on the defensive side (inexplicably) and maxy hit into open space on the offensive side allowing Greene to run onto the ball unimpeded.

Oliver last quarter: 3 touches and 1 tackle.

Will we ever see the best of him again?