On 15/08/2024 at 10:55, adonski said:

Trac must be worth 4 first rounders then …

  On 15/08/2024 at 11:00, Demonland said:

Trac must be worth 4 first rounders then …

I’d say the entire first round 

If Melbourne is too much of a shambles how come it nearly beat his side with half of its side out injured?

  On 15/08/2024 at 11:59, Norm Smith's Curse said:

If Melbourne is too much of a shambles how come it nearly beat his side with half of its side out injured?

That is the funny part. God I hope port lose to the crows this week and drop out of the 4. Would be wonderful

 

For two first rounders, he can stay right away from our club. Thank you for never coming. 

Thank you dazzledavey36. That is a massive relief. 

2 first rounders? Aaaahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

 

Breathe 

 

Aaaahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahaha

I don't know why people are so surprised. Do we not know how negotiating works? Of course Port are going to ask for something as unrealistic as this. Its how you start trade talks.

He's a contracted player whose likely to get a second all Australian and finish in Ports top 4 BnF.

Of course they're going to ask for overs as a starting bid.

If we do end up his preferred destination, which by the way I still think could be the case. Of course he'd have reservations with all our media attention but that will likely pass when things become clearer at the end of the season with our review etc. If he wants to get to Melbourne and genuinely wants to leave Port then we can certainly negotiate to make it a more favourable deal.

I think we look to split the pick 6/7 (with GC for example) and use a later first rounder for Houston so we still hold a top 10 selection.

I wouldn't be turning our backs on this just because Port are doing what they should by starting with the highest (unrealistic price).

Edited August 15, 2024Aug 15 by Young Blood

  On 15/08/2024 at 13:09, Young Blood said:

I don't know why people are so surprised. Do we not know how negotiating works? Of course Port are going to ask for something as unrealistic as this. Its how you start trade talks.

He's a contracted player whose likely to get a second all Australian and finish in Ports top 4 BnF.

Of course they're going to ask for overs as a starting bid.

If we do end up his preferred destination, which by the way I still think could be the case. Of course he'd have reservations with all our media attention but that will likely pass when things become clearer at the end of the season with our review etc. If he wants to get to Melbourne and genuinely wants to leave Port then we can certainly negotiate to make it a more favourable deal.

I think we look to split the pick 6/7 (with GC for example) and use a later first rounder for Houston so we still hold a top 10 selection.

I wouldn't be turning our backs on this just because Port are doing what they should by starting with the highest (unrealistic price).

If the club turned their backs on things as quickly as Demonland did, we'd not have made it out of the 19th century.

  On 15/08/2024 at 13:09, Young Blood said:

I don't know why people are so surprised. Do we not know how negotiating works? Of course Port are going to ask for something as unrealistic as this. Its how you start trade talks.

He's a contracted player whose likely to get a second all Australian and finish in Ports top 4 BnF.

Of course they're going to ask for overs as a starting bid.

If we do end up his preferred destination, which by the way I still think could be the case. Of course he'd have reservations with all our media attention but that will likely pass when things become clearer at the end of the season with our review etc. If he wants to get to Melbourne and genuinely wants to leave Port then we can certainly negotiate to make it a more favourable deal.

I think we look to split the pick 6/7 (with GC for example) and use a later first rounder for Houston so we still hold a top 10 selection.

I wouldn't be turning our backs on this just because Port are doing what they should by starting with the highest (unrealistic price).

This is a very realistic take and one of the better posts on here. 

Two first rounders for Houston. Thats ridiculous!!! He’s very good but not an elite midfielder.  Butters = two 1st rounders.  Houston = one 1st rounder. I’m glad he’s not coming onboard.  There’s real talent in this draft.  I would rather draft young guns like Langford, Lindsay or Lalor with first round pick.  

  On 15/08/2024 at 12:34, Jaded No More said:

For two first rounders, he can stay right away from our club. Thank you for never coming. 

Exactly. Maybe worth two 2nd rounds but at Port’s price no way

I thought this was dead in the water with ANB going home and all the Tracc talk

Houston I don't have a problem with that.

Keep Pick 5 or 6 and let Jason Taylor go to work.

  On 15/08/2024 at 11:59, Norm Smith's Curse said:

If Melbourne is too much of a shambles how come it nearly beat his side with half of its side out injured?

Bingo.

If you done rate the dees, hard to rate port. Ditto for giants.

My read on this is that Houston is on a relatively low wage contract and Port's demand for two first rounders reflects this. He is clearly a very good player and would add to our side, but we would have to bump his salary and fork out in picks.

I think we were probably reluctant to release Petty for a similar reason last season.

Sometimes the best trades are the ones you don’t make.

We are building again with young players. Another elite youngster with pick 6/7 will be invaluable. Premierships are built via the draft. 2019.

 

It's probably a blessing in disguise he's a quality player but not worth 2 first rounders and our backline isn't the problem it's our midfield and forward line that are a problem recruit players there. I like the sound of Membrey in our forward line quality player but I don't know how old he is? Hopefully we can get Port's first round pick which will be in the teens for Neal-Bullen add pick 6 and we could go up the order with those 2 picks. Go with the kids.

He'd be worth ANB and a late first.

They ask for 2

Offer AnB and a pick swap.

Ultimately land on ANB and pick 17 and it would be a fair swap.

Nor sure how we get pick 17 though...

Dan may have played his last game for Port… big hit on Rankine and knocked him out. Would be 4 weeks minimum one would think, could be more. Given he won’t be available early next year let’s offer a 3rd rounder….

  On 17/08/2024 at 11:34, DistrACTION Jackson said:

Dan may have played his last game for Port… big hit on Rankine and knocked him out. Would be 4 weeks minimum one would think, could be more. Given he won’t be available early next year let’s offer a 3rd rounder….

He’s just practicing for next year’s Kings Birthday game

  On 17/08/2024 at 11:34, DistrACTION Jackson said:

Dan may have played his last game for Port… big hit on Rankine and knocked him out. Would be 4 weeks minimum one would think, could be more. Given he won’t be available early next year let’s offer a 3rd rounder….