4 hours ago, Travy14 said:

This is a big game!  Freo are a good team without being outstanding.  very defensive and if its hot and sweaty in Alice it could be very low scoring.

Id say no change at this stage but if it does look like being a slippery ball kind of game, maybe a smaller fwd line is a good idea.  

If its a slippery kind of game we may as well hand the game Freo now. I don't have faith in the Dees executing under these conditions... I hope I'm wrong this time.

We have an Alice Springian or two on here and they’ve said Alice Springs isn’t anywhere near as humid as Darwin. Don’t think it’s ever been a sweat box when we’ve played in Alice. 

9 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:

We have an Alice Springian or two on here and they’ve said Alice Springs isn’t anywhere near as humid as Darwin. Don’t think it’s ever been a sweat box when we’ve played in Alice. 

I assume it wouldn't be during the day, may be at night? Not even sure if it's a day or night game. 

1 hour ago, Boots and all said:

If its a slippery kind of game we may as well hand the game Freo now. I don't have faith in the Dees executing under these conditions... I hope I'm wrong this time.

Cue the annual clarification on what the actual conditions are like in Alice at this time of year. Perhaps a local can step in? 

1 hour ago, Boots and all said:

I assume it wouldn't be during the day, may be at night? Not even sure if it's a day or night game. 

Not sure they even have lights that work at Traeger. 

But in short: the match is played in one of the driest deserts in the world, just shy of the Tropic of Capricorn. I'm also not sure the latitude of Cockburn. 

Edited May 26, 2024May 26 by Skuit

I've flown up for it a few times for the matches- effectively like a clear spring day on the coast here in Vicco. Perhaps 26 during the day and then dropping down to 14 overnight... clear skies on both occasions. So needed a jumper as soon as the sun set.

Edited May 26, 2024May 26 by Engorged Onion

The first quarter against Adelaide circa 2018 stands out as perfect footy conditions and we romped the Crows. Keep Clarry shaded and all is grand. 

1 hour ago, Boots and all said:

I assume it wouldn't be during the day, may be at night? Not even sure if it's a day or night game. 

Every year this question gets asked and every year it's the same answer, won't be hot or humid so won't be slippery, wlil be dry unless it rains. Game is at 1.00 pm . forecast is no rain and 18 - 19 degrees everyone can stop worrying about the conditions.

26 minutes ago, loges said:

Every year this question gets asked and every year it's the same answer, won't be hot or humid so won't be slippery, wlil be dry unless it rains. Game is at 1.00 pm . forecast is no rain and 18 - 19 degrees everyone can stop worrying about the conditions.

Alice is effectively 15 hours (1500km) south of Darwin, probably has a different climate eh? #knowgeography

10 minutes ago, Engorged Onion said:

Alice is effectively 15 hours (1500km) south of Darwin, probably has a different climate eh? #knowgeography

Locals can do it in eight. 

I suggest managing Windsor for a week to refresh him to play KB and then post bye is starting to look right. This would be on the basis of his GPS showing this being required but he seems to not be covering the ground as well as earlier in year. Otherwise assuming Petty is right to go no change but need to see more from Petty and McAdam in next 2 games. 

McAdam could not run in the last quarter. He looked completely spent. I'm not sure he's fit enough, but I also know we need to get games into him. Nevertheless, I would replace him with Tholstrup for the Freo game. We should be getting games into him, too. 

2 minutes ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

McAdam could not run in the last quarter. He looked completely spent. I'm not sure he's fit enough, but I also know we need to get games into him. Nevertheless, I would replace him with Tholstrup for the Freo game. We should be getting games into him, too. 

Suggest McAdam will be retained for the exact reasons you point out. Needs more fitness and game time.

I like the look of McAdam. Not perfect yet but he looks like the sort of player that needs to have confidence put into him to play his best. I would stick with him and hope he repays the faith 

The Kolt has a big future but I'd suspect he'd be more of a certain starter if they look to rest the likes of Chin or one of the other high half forwards

6 hours ago, Dee Zephyr said:

We have an Alice Springian or two on here and they’ve said Alice Springs isn’t anywhere near as humid as Darwin. Don’t think it’s ever been a sweat box when we’ve played in Alice. 

Been there a few times, the climate is similar to Regional SA. Dry (but not humid) but nights can be quite chilled.

1 hour ago, Lil_red_fire_engine said:

I suggest managing Windsor for a week to refresh him to play KB and then post bye is starting to look right. This would be on the basis of his GPS showing this being required but he seems to not be covering the ground as well as earlier in year. Otherwise assuming Petty is right to go no change but need to see more from Petty and McAdam in next 2 games. 

I agree, I think now is a good time to rest Windsor, perhaps bring Kolt in for another taste, or give Woey a full game and make Billings the sub.

We have a long season still, and Windsor's speed will be critical when we get to September. No need to burn him out now.

31 minutes ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

McAdam could not run in the last quarter. He looked completely spent. I'm not sure he's fit enough, but I also know we need to get games into him. Nevertheless, I would replace him with Tholstrup for the Freo game. We should be getting games into him, too. 

I don't mind playing a player who may be lacking in fitness so it can build up their levels etc.

But makes you wonder how many of them you can fit in a team given Petty and McAdam are in the same situation.

Understand getting them match fit to AFL level requires some AFL matches but is there a limit to this?

4 hours ago, loges said:

Every year this question gets asked and every year it's the same answer, won't be hot or humid so won't be slippery, wlil be dry unless it rains. Game is at 1.00 pm . forecast is no rain and 18 - 19 degrees everyone can stop worrying about the conditions.

It astounds me how little people know about Alice Springs! Oh it's in the NT so must be humid. For god sake it is in the middle of a hugh desert. The weather will be similar to yesterday.

AMW must be nearly ready for an opportunity.

Windsor may need a break, disposals and impact are going south

VFL watch - Jefferson 5.3, AMW 33 disposals, Laurie 25 disposals/2 Goals, Billings 25 disposals, Tholstrup 24 disposals, B Brown 3.3

In - Jefferson, Laurie, AMW/Tholstrup

Out - Petty (If injured), Windsor (Managed), Woewodin (Needs a full game at Casey)

Sub - AMW/Tholstrup

 

Bags are packed and heading off to Alice tomorrow.
 

Based on what I’ve learnt from Demonland, my life will be in constant danger from angry locals and I’ll be sweating up a treat as I try to out run them!

1 hour ago, SthSea22 said:

AMW must be nearly ready for an opportunity.

Windsor may need a break, disposals and impact are going south

VFL watch - Jefferson 5.3, AMW 33 disposals, Laurie 25 disposals/2 Goals, Billings 25 disposals, Tholstrup 24 disposals, B Brown 3.3

In - Jefferson, Laurie, AMW/Tholstrup

Out - Petty (If injured), Windsor (Managed), Woewodin (Needs a full game at Casey)

Sub - AMW/Tholstrup

 

Surely not Laurie, he is good at VFL then goes missing at AFL.  AMW or Kolt ahead of him for sure.

30 minutes ago, Young Angus said:

Surely not Laurie, he is good at VFL then goes missing at AFL.  AMW or Kolt ahead of him for sure.

Agree

 

But knowing Goody, he won't bring in fresh meat

Looking at the stats and highlights of the Casey v Sandy game, we should bring in Mitch White...oh wait! 

2 hours ago, old dee said:

It astounds me how little people know about Alice Springs! Oh it's in the NT so must be humid. For god sake it is in the middle of a hugh desert. The weather will be similar to yesterday.

Paging @Gator

Surely Fullarton plays if Petty injured. If not, why did we recruit him? Did he not drop out of the selected squad through illness? If so, must be close. With Freo having two genuine ruckman he can assist Max, particularly with the calf, and spend time forward.Means that JVR can 'stay at home' up front longer. More of a genuine ruck. Open to other suggestions.  For me it's way to early for Jefferson based on one good performance.