Kane Cornes Ranks the Captains

[Demonland 73,106]

3. Max Gawn (Melbourne)

“Gawn plays a different position to Greene but is able to impact in the same way, his endurance allows him to position himself exactly where the team needs him at any given time.

“Behind the play, a big mark down the line, inside 50 or influencing at the centre bounce. Has a calm, level head and is an excellent media performer.”

[DubDee 26,112]

we have the best leadership we’ve had for decades. 

Max, Viney, Lever, Trac, Gus, May etc. 

And other teams…. Allen, Simpkin. ouch

Surprised Danger is so high and think Sicily should be higher

[Sir Why You Little 37,119]

The Bont went missing last year. There are far better leaders than him

[DubDee 26,112]

it’s a pretty sad list of captains really. 

only 5-6 quality leaders

[Little Goffy 14,635]

11 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

The Bont went missing last year. There are far better leaders than him

Having just watched Petracca's interview this mention of Bontempelli brings to mind a couple of Trac's comments about the need for leaders to let the rest of the team play their role instead of the leader trying to do everything in crucial moments.

Having also just re-watched the 2021 3rd qtr highlights posted here the other day, my mind also goes to that moment of total shellshock in the Bulldogs clearance group. Bontempelli is a tremendous player and was probably their best player on that day, too, but his captaincy fell short when it came to steadying the team and the crucial few players at those clearances who desperately need to have their focus brought back.

I also think Toby Greene is overrated as a leader, mostly because I still think he is a *head just well covered by media love.

So... hmm, aside from that I guess I agree on at least the top three.

[whatwhat say what 22,896]

witts is criminally underrated imo

[Wodjathefirst 2,653]

As much as I loved to despise Toby Greene over the years for all his infamous antics. I have done the big turnaround.  Last season I thought that he did an excellent job as a leader of GWS. Not to mention he is an outstanding player. Geez, I wished they beat Collingwood in the finals. Sooo close 

[Queanbeyan Demon 6,861]

1 hour ago, DubDee said:

we have the best leadership we’ve had for decades. 

Max, Viney, Lever, Trac, Gus, May etc. 

And other teams…. Allen, Simpkin. ouch

Surprised Danger is so high and think Sicily should be higher

I frigg'in love Maysie. His leadership on Greville Street and at award nites leaves all others in his slipstream. I just wish he was occupying the same part of the ground as Brayshaw in a now infamous qualifying final. We would have seen some brilliant leadership that nite had it been so.

Edited February 15 by Queanbeyan Demon
Typo

[Ollie fan 3,468]

41 minutes ago, whatwhat say what said:

witts is criminally underrated imo

Absolutely. And Dangerfield is rated much too high

 

[Queanbeyan Demon 6,861]

44 minutes ago, whatwhat say what said:

witts is criminally underrated imo

Is that a typo @whatwhat say what?

[marieisademon 45]

2 hours ago, Demonland said:

3. Max Gawn (Melbourne)

“Gawn plays a different position to Greene but is able to impact in the same way, his endurance allows him to position himself exactly where the team needs him at any given time.

“Behind the play, a big mark down the line, inside 50 or influencing at the centre bounce. Has a calm, level head and is an excellent media performer.”

Without Greene GWS, don't get out of the bottom four, I think the Dee's would adjust without max, but maybe we would only be about 5 th on the ladder

[marieisademon 45]

1 hour ago, Little Goffy said:

Having just watched Petracca's interview this mention of Bontempelli brings to mind a couple of Trac's comments about the need for leaders to let the rest of the team play their role instead of the leader trying to do everything in crucial moments.

Having also just re-watched the 2021 3rd qtr highlights posted here the other day, my mind also goes to that moment of total shellshock in the Bulldogs clearance group. Bontempelli is a tremendous player and was probably their best player on that day, too, but his captaincy fell short when it came to steadying the team and the crucial few players at those clearances who desperately need to have their focus brought back.

I also think Toby Greene is overrated as a leader, mostly because I still think he is a *head just well covered by media love.

So... hmm, aside from that I guess I agree on at least the top three.

Without Greene GWS don't get out of bottom 4, would love to have him at the Dee's, we would be unstoppable, how much hovac would he and kossie cause?

[BDA 22,866]

Toby Greene is my favourite non dee. Super player. 

[Jibroni 5,008]

Gees once you get past Darcy Moore its a pretty average lot.

Neale a champion player but not sure on him as a leader.

[Dee Boys 698]

1 hour ago, whatwhat say what said:

witts is criminally underrated imo

Why? Decent player. Uninspiring leader, hasn’t been able to even lead his team into finals or raise the club’s basketcase reputation. Zero media profile for a club that’s crying out for relevance. Middle of the road is about spot on.

[whatwhat say what 22,896]

1 minute ago, Dee Boys said:

Why? Decent player. Uninspiring leader, hasn’t been able to even lead his team into finals or raise the club’s basketcase reputation. Zero media profile for a club that’s crying out for relevance. Middle of the road is about spot on.

nah

he's an excellent player and communicator on field, has lead the way in developing a strong attitude towards professionalism around the franchise, and is one of the reasons why they are developing strongly

[Sir Why You Little 37,119]

2 hours ago, Little Goffy said:

Having just watched Petracca's interview this mention of Bontempelli brings to mind a couple of Trac's comments about the need for leaders to let the rest of the team play their role instead of the leader trying to do everything in crucial moments.

Having also just re-watched the 2021 3rd qtr highlights posted here the other day, my mind also goes to that moment of total shellshock in the Bulldogs clearance group. Bontempelli is a tremendous player and was probably their best player on that day, too, but his captaincy fell short when it came to steadying the team and the crucial few players at those clearances who desperately need to have their focus brought back.

I also think Toby Greene is overrated as a leader, mostly because I still think he is a *head just well covered by media love.

So... hmm, aside from that I guess I agree on at least the top three.

Pretty much agree there, although i think Greene is becoming a very important Captain. 
The Dogs lost to West Coast at home last year with a Finals Berth up for grabs 

Totally unforgivable in my opinion. 
Bont is a great player, but not the Number 1 Captain 

Did he get another touch in The GF after Harmesy intercepted? I cannot recall him having any influence at all

 

[dl4e 5,851]

16 hours ago, DubDee said:

 

Surprised Danger is so high and think Sicily should be higher

correct.

[gs77 4,441]

12 hours ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Pretty much agree there, although i think Greene is becoming a very important Captain. 
The Dogs lost to West Coast at home last year with a Finals Berth up for grabs 

Totally unforgivable in my opinion. 
Bont is a great player, but not the Number 1 Captain 

Did he get another touch in The GF after Harmesy intercepted? I cannot recall him having any influence at all

 

The only thing he did after that was curtail Trac's attempted centre clearance to stop a 4th goal in the final minute of the 3rd.

[Sir Why You Little 37,119]

1 hour ago, gs77 said:

The only thing he did after that was curtail Trac's attempted centre clearance to stop a 4th goal in the final minute of the 3rd.

Ahh yes. The last play. After the Damage was well and truly entrenched!!

[dazzledavey36 55,311]

I rate Darcy Moore as one of the best captain in the league.

Marcus Bontempelli is overrated as a leader imo. Champion player but..

[drdrake 3,185]

14 hours ago, Sir Why You Little said:

The Dogs lost to West Coast at home last year with a Finals Berth up for grabs 

Totally unforgivable in my opinion. 
Bont is a great player, but not the Number 1 Captain 

 

Went to that game, saw a half fit Elliot Yeo towell him up im the first half.  Agree good player but not sure about no1 captain, I reckon dogs on field leadership is why they are the great underachievers over recent years

[Whispering_Jack 30,573]

I think Sicily at Hawthorn is a little underrated in Cornes’ list and while the Bont is great, he’s not a premiership skipper like Max.

Now, if only the men/women/them who once were in white would give him the proper protection in ruck and marking duels, he would be way far ahead of the rest. 

[Demon17 5,191]

On 15/02/2024 at 19:45, Little Goffy said:

Having just watched Petracca's interview this mention of Bontempelli brings to mind a couple of Trac's comments about the need for leaders to let the rest of the team play their role instead of the leader trying to do everything in crucial moments.

Having also just re-watched the 2021 3rd qtr highlights posted here the other day, my mind also goes to that moment of total shellshock in the Bulldogs clearance group. Bontempelli is a tremendous player and was probably their best player on that day, too, but his captaincy fell short when it came to steadying the team and the crucial few players at those clearances who desperately need to have their focus brought back.

I also think Toby Greene is overrated as a leader, mostly because I still think he is a *head just well covered by media love.

So... hmm, aside from that I guess I agree on at least the top three.

I try to avoid Clickbait Cornes so thanks for nothing Demonland.

However I think top 3 are spot on albeit Goffys Bont comments above are on the money. There's Bont then daylight in leadership at the Dogs.

Max is a more well-rounded leader than bont or Toby. Should be top for this reason. And he's not advertising alcoholic drinks like Moore. 

[Little Goffy 14,635]

20 minutes ago, Demon17 said:

I try to avoid Clickbait Cornes so thanks for nothing Demonland.

However I think top 3 are spot on albeit Goffys Bont comments above are on the money. There's Bont then daylight in leadership at the Dogs.

Max is a more well-rounded leader than bont or Toby. Should be top for this reason. And he's not advertising alcoholic drinks like Moore. 

I'm Little Goffy. 'Goffy' is my brother. Although he'd probably agree.

It is an interesting contrast between the Bulldogs' leadership and ours.

I'd say that while Gawn is clearly the outstanding captain, we have a wealth of leaders whether they are top-level players like May, Brayshaw, Lever, Viney and Petracca or just as importantly in the less renowned like Neal-Bullen, Melksham, Brown and McDonald who set standards and get around teammates regardless of their own personal form at the time.

The mood I get from the Bulldogs is of individuals who each play football and are on the same team rather than much active shaping of the team. Maybe there are just too many 'stars'? Maybe a little too much individual bathwater drinking compared to Melbourne's alleged collective bathwater problem?

On that analogy, I'm going to see myself out.