14 minutes ago, Superunknown said:

Let us all hope dearly for a GWs Lions GF

oh my god it would be a joy. The AFL commercial corrupt cartel would lose their minds

please god make this happen

 

 

i’d personally prefer a Magpies v Lions GF. with Lions winning of course. 

Will traumatise the Pies more. flashback to the early 2000’s

ABC - Anyone but Collingwood

My preferred winners in order - GWS (for Jesse), Lions, Carlton, Pies. I don't like the expansion clubs but GWS look the business.

The Pies will be getting nervous.

 

1 minute ago, DubDee said:

Such a pity Hogan had all the issues he had 7-8 years ago

talent wise he should be a 700 goal fwd

How handy would he be at the Dees now!!

Off to the Port Bigfooty forum and specifically the sack Hinkley thread for a half time giggle.

How good are GWS to watch at the moment?

Fast, brutal, and most importantly, accurate footy

14 minutes ago, praha said:

We've lost Hogan, Jackson and Bedford on Goodwin's watch.

Hogan & Jackson requested a trade, hogan homesick & mentally gone and didnt last with behaviour issues so no one trusted him, Jackson por of gold, bedford yes didn’t play him often enough in 22,by the thickhead coach 

Carn the Orange 🍊 Tsunami 🌊 

Even though it sucks for us, I reckon this finals series is good for the game. Two elimination finalists playing prelims and at least one a huge chance of winning one. It’s not inconceivable that both GWS and Carlton make the GF.

It also will give teams who are going absolutely horribly at the Bye cause for optimism for a long time. 

1 minute ago, DubDee said:

i’d personally prefer a Magpies v Lions GF. with Lions winning of course. 

Will traumatise the Pies more. flashback to the early 2000’s

Yep.

Collingwood losing a GF > Collingwood losing a prelim.

Just now, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Off to the Port Bigfooty forum and specifically the sack Hinkley thread for a half time giggle.

Just stay on Demonland and read Hinkley wherever you see Goodwin

1 minute ago, DubDee said:

Such a pity Hogan had all the issues he had 7-8 years ago

talent wise he should be a 700 goal fwd

I was just telling my partner about all he went through with his dad and then his diagnosis. He went through a lot, and I wish him every success.

The only good outcome for 2023 now is for the Giants to win it all. 
 

2 minutes ago, DubDee said:

i’d personally prefer a Magpies v Lions GF. with Lions winning of course. 

Will traumatise the Pies more. flashback to the early 2000’s

An epic conundrum. Seeing them lose in the GF by lots and lots and lots of a kick after the siren would be the besybest

Just now, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Yep.

Collingwood losing a GF > Collingwood losing a prelim.

Prefer the 🍊 🌊 give them an early exit

3 minutes ago, Demonsone said:

Hogan & Jackson requested a trade, hogan homesick & mentally gone and didnt last with behaviour issues so no one trusted him, Jackson por of gold, bedford yes didn’t play him often enough in 22,by the thickhead coach 

Bedford asked to leave because he did not believe he could break into the team. The club offered him a three year contract.

The PAP look bog ordinary 

3 minutes ago, Bang Bang Bang said:

Even though it sucks for us, I reckon this finals series is good for the game. Two elimination finalists playing prelims and at least one a huge chance of winning one. It’s not inconceivable that both GWS and Carlton make the GF.

It also will give teams who are going absolutely horribly at the Bye cause for optimism for a long time. 

A really really good take on things! Chapeau!

Go GWS

4 minutes ago, —coach— said:

Just stay on Demonland and read Hinkley wherever you see Goodwin

There's a lot of criticism about Goodwin but I don't think anyone here is crazy enough to think he should be sacked.

Hinkley definitely shouldn't have lasted as soon as he has.

4 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

The only good outcome for 2023 now is for the Giants to win it all. 
 

A GWS V Brisbane GF would be an amazing outcome for humanity.

 

I’m happy to admit I’m on the Giants train and will be pleased if they snag this years flag. 
 

Their game is so good to watch - wish it was red and blue guernseys. 

Edited September 16, 20232 yr by McQueen

5 minutes ago, —coach— said:

Just stay on Demonland and read Hinkley wherever you see Goodwin

Both offered contract extension before the finals and out in straight sets 

The PAP can’t lay a tackle 

2 minutes ago, YearOfTheDees said:

Bedford asked to leave because he did not believe he could break into the team. The club offered him a three year contract.

Also, Hogan was "ill disciplined" but we're about to recruit McAdam and recruited Hunger lol

I know we got good value for all of them but gee whiz, you can't ignore the common denominator of forwards wanting to leave.

what an epic choke by Port

imagine if Goody put in one Hinkleys famous chokes?