I believe Lyon was at the same reunion in Kyabram that Reid's parents attended.  I don't believe there's anything other than a happenstance meeting.  Lyon confirmed he attended a Kyabram reunion on radio during the week and Reid's parents were also there.

Edited August 26, 20231 yr by Gator

  On 26/08/2023 at 06:39, Gawndy the Great said:

Eagles need multiple 1st round picks. I wonder if we also offer them Grundy as well.

Brodie won’t want to go west when he has so many suitors on this side of the continent.

And before we talk about ‘we hold the whip hand’ - no we don’t. Players can refuse to go and while we can just keep him. Do we want to? Don’t we want to invest in a forward? Maybe JVR can avoid rucking?

With North Melbourne winning...against a soft as butter Gold Coast....we may still be a "slight chance" to get Harley Reid after all? 🤔

 

You would think North would threaten to take Curtin at 2/3, so our Pick 5/6 would be pretty useless to West Coast

  On 26/08/2023 at 06:28, Gator said:

Unfortunately, North are still best placed to trade for pick one.

2 + 16 for 1? WC get Curtin and a bonus 1st rounder (Port's)

Edited August 26, 20231 yr by old55

  On 26/08/2023 at 06:51, 2021 said:

You would think North would threaten to take Curtin at 2/3, so our Pick 5/6 would be pretty useless to West Coast

Unless they are happy to overlook Curtain and take pick 5/6, and what else we can get. 

  On 26/08/2023 at 06:54, old55 said:

2 + 16 for 1? WC get Curtin and a bonus 1st rounder (Port's)

We could come in and top that. If we can get GC pick. We’d have to pay massive overs, and get something back.

  On 26/08/2023 at 06:58, KingDingAling said:

We could come in and top that. If we can get GC pick. We’d have to pay massive overs, and get something back.

No guarantee WC gets Curtin with 4 or 5 though

  On 26/08/2023 at 06:59, old55 said:

No guarantee WC gets Curtin with 4 or 5 though

But they can trade them for 2 and other picks.

  On 26/08/2023 at 06:39, Gawndy the Great said:

I wonder if we also offer them Grundy as well

We won't be offering them Grundy if he doesn't wish to go there and I doubt he would.

  On 26/08/2023 at 07:12, Clintosaurus said:

But they can trade them for 2 and other picks.

Simpler just to trade with North direct

  On 26/08/2023 at 07:14, old55 said:

Simpler just to trade with North direct

Deal 1

Dees: Out - 4 and 18

           In - pick 2

Roos: Out - pick 2

           In - pick 4 and 18

Deal 2

Dees: Out - pick 2, 24 + F1 (15-18)

           In - Pick 1

WC:   Out - Pick 1

          In - Pick 2, 24 and melb F1

 

Essentially a 3-way trade. Not the worst possibility, and importantly a potential option if we can't get pick 4 from the suns.

 

Edited August 26, 20231 yr by Nascent

I've read on another forum that the Suns have plenty of picks to cover bids for their 3 (likely top 10) academy players.  The thought being that they're more likely to try and trade pick 4 for another team's future first.  Ideally a team they project to finish near the bottom in 2024.  But who knows what Taylor has up his sleeve.

  On 26/08/2023 at 07:30, Gator said:

I've read on another forum that the Suns have plenty of picks to cover bids for their 3 (likely top 10) academy players.  The thought being that they're more likely to try and trade pick 4 for another team's future first.  Ideally a team they project to finish near the bottom in 2024.  But who knows what Taylor has up his sleeve.

Pick 4 still equates to roughly 2,000 points. So they'll need to recuperate that in addition to a future 1st if that's their intention. Not many clubs will be able to facilitate that.

Welcome Harley Reid 

  On 26/08/2023 at 07:35, Nascent said:

Pick 4 still equates to roughly 2,000 points. So they'll need to recuperate that in addition to a future 1st if that's their intention. Not many clubs will be able to facilitate that.

Yes, they'd want a future first plus extra.

Might be wise to deal with North. Let WC take Reid should they wish. We need pick 2. That gives us leverage. Take either. 

Edited August 26, 20231 yr by KingDingAling

Is Reid back in play? That is the question. And a question well worth examining.

Our experts in the war room will show us exactly how this can happen after the break.

As much as I really want Reid, West Coast won't do any deal that risks losing Curtin and North will only deal if it means they get Reid. 

Hopefully we get pick 4 from GC and pick up up 2 very good kids. 

Edited August 26, 20231 yr by Palace Dees

I wonder if WC and North have done a deal already allowing them to strive for wins 

Today's results are certainly great news for MFC.  Opens up our options.  WC need multiple first rounds picks as we did in 2013........  splitting our number 1 pick went along way to rebuilding our list....... a super important step to building our premiership list.  No doubt WC are very aware of this.

Reid becomes a real and live option again.  Whether it can be done and whether this is the direction the MFC wants to go, only time will tell.  But what we do know is that we have been interested enough to pursue Reid as a possible payday for our 2023 draft bonanza.  It is a fact that we have put in enormous time and effort to make this a possibility of happening.

The MFC has options on how to spend its bonanza everywhere. 

This is the honey train draft/trade period for us.  Whatever direction we end up taking.......... if we nail it, we set our football club up for a decade.  We give ourselves the opportunity to create a genuine dynasty.  

I am just so excited.

Edited August 26, 20231 yr by Grand New Flag

  On 26/08/2023 at 10:38, Grand New Flag said:

Today's results are certainly great news for MFC.  Opens up our options.  WC need multiple first rounds picks as we did in 2013........  splitting our number 1 pick went along way to rebuilding our list....... a super important set to building our premiership list. 

Reid becomes a real and live option again.  Whether it can be done and whether this is the direction the MFC wants to go, only time will tell.  But what we do know is that we have been interested enough to pursue Reid as a possible payday for our 2023 draft bonanza.  It is a fact that we have put in enormous time to make this a possibility of happening.

The MFC has options on how to spend its bonanza everywhere. 

This is the honey train draft/trade period for us.  Whatever direction we end up taking.......... if we nail it, we set our football club up for a decade.  We give ourselves the opportunity to create a genuine dynasty.  

I am just so excited.

Yep it is exciting, Reid or multiple good young players, what a wonderful problem.

We also have a real chance at another flag.

  On 26/08/2023 at 06:54, old55 said:

2 + 16 for 1? WC get Curtin and a bonus 1st rounder (Port's)

That is way unders. 4 and 5 is a much better offer. So they miss Curtain - they’ll get two gun midfielders for the price of one. 
 

 

  On 26/08/2023 at 10:44, Gawndy the Great said:

That is way unders. 4 and 5 is a much better offer. So they miss Curtain - they’ll get two gun midfielders for the price of one. 
 

 

I wouldn't be trading 4 + 5 for pick 1

  On 26/08/2023 at 10:44, Gawndy the Great said:

That is way unders. 4 and 5 is a much better offer. So they miss Curtain - they’ll get two gun midfielders for the price of one. 
 

 

But they want Curtin, he is their Reid.

Any deal needs to ensure them of Curtin.

2 plus 16 would do it.