8 minutes ago, Queanbeyan Demon said:

No religion too?

Definitely no religion

Edited May 28, 2025May 28 by Roost it far

26 minutes ago, Queanbeyan Demon said:

No religion too?

and no filth

McKay to full back, Weitering to centre half forward.

he's no better then what we have currently, plus we don't need our whole team kicking around the body when they are 20m out straight in front. we already have so many issues with accuracy which lost us a flag or two.

Haven’t read the OP or any posts, just the thread title. It’s a resounding no.

3 minutes ago, jaydenh10 said:

he's no better then what we have currently, plus we don't need our whole team kicking around the body when they are 20m out straight in front. we already have so many issues with accuracy which lost us a flag or two.

Last year he kicked 49.21 from 21 games, though granted there were probably a few out on the full.

If he was available for a decent price we would be crazy not to go for him, given we are crying out for a 200cm forward who can average over 2 goals a game. He would also help accelerate JVRs game I think, given he would be the main focal point of the forward line and JVR would play second tall.

Prob would consider him but not at any cost...

3 minutes ago, DistrACTION Jackson said:

Last year he kicked 49.21 from 21 games, though granted there were probably a few out on the full.

If he was available for a decent price we would be crazy not to go for him, given we are crying out for a 200cm forward who can average over 2 goals a game. He would also help accelerate JVRs game I think, given he would be the main focal point of the forward line and JVR would play second tall.

I would rather put that money into jacko and/or kosi.

plus we have a huge key position player problem, the only one on our list that has a permanent spot in the fwd or back line is turner which is down back. lever and may who in my view are nearly finished as well as tmac who has one more year left in him, petty is solid up fwd and down back but it depends on other players and how they are going. jvr just needs a legend of the club to work with him we have heaps why has this not been done??? mj is completely lost atm, Adams and kentfield we don't know about yet but look somewhat promising, fullerton is just as lost as mj, I also have no clue about Verrall but he has improved a lot this season. oh and we are hopefully bringing in Kalani at the end of the year there is another one. i think some of these lads absolutely have it in them but we have no idea where to play them and they just need a crack at it to see.

1 hour ago, Demon Dynasty said:

McKay is also the 2nd highest rated 2nd ruck only behind Blitzavs (Champion Data).

Harry turns 28 at the end of this year. LJ turns 24 in September.

If we're going to pay a second ruck $1mill, I'd rather it be LJ who is younger and a better ruck, who will one day be a permanent ruck.

That said, I think $1mill is too much to pay for a ruck.

1 hour ago, Adam The God said:

Harry turns 28 at the end of this year. LJ turns 24 in September.

If we're going to pay a second ruck $1mill, I'd rather it be LJ who is younger and a better ruck, who will one day be a permanent ruck.

That said, I think $1mill is too much to pay for a ruck.

He will not be a second ruck for long Adam

Thing is, are some suggesting we get him in as (almost) a like for like replacement for Max (in terms of impact / dominating the match)?

I doubt there is anyone that can do that at present including LJ. On his best days yes, he is probably very influential and effective. But for mine he still does a bit too much picking and choosing when he brings that.

If it's not so much about LJ then, do we just get the best available ruck around and spend the rest of our tickets on getting a brute KF that can add a few extra goals to the score alot of the time and help lock the ball i50 more often?

1 hour ago, Adam The God said:

Harry turns 28 at the end of this year. LJ turns 24 in September.

If we're going to pay a second ruck $1mill, I'd rather it be LJ who is younger and a better ruck, who will one day be a permanent ruck.

That said, I think $1mill is too much to pay for a ruck.

What’s Gawn worth?

12 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

What’s Gawn worth?

$1 mill, because he's more than a ruckman, but I think you'll find Max has taken unders to keep this group together.

2 hours ago, Dee Zephyr said:

McKay to full back, Weitering to centre half forward.

He could swap teams & positions with his identical twin. Could be a win / win and nobody would be any the wiser.

17 minutes ago, Adam The God said:

$1 mill, because he's more than a ruckman, but I think you'll find Max has taken unders to keep this group together.

Jackson will offer us more as well but I agree, let’s not overpay

2 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

Jackson will offer us more as well but I agree, let’s not overpay

What about afterpay?

7 hours ago, whatwhat say what said:

right, so baggers have no 1st rounder in 2025

ship mckay to the bloods for theirs?

Correct, no 1st rounder for this year's draft but the Blues could pick up Harry Dean (son of two time Premiership player, Peter Dean) and he is a possible late 1st rounder for the 2025 draft. He was selected yesterday in the Vic Country squad alongside fellow Carlton Father-Son prospect for 2026, Cody Walker.

Would rather we put work into getting a key back, such as Leek Aleer

4 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Haven’t read the OP or any posts, just the thread title. It’s a resounding no.

Five pages into the thread, Ethan 'Angel Eyes' Tremblay ignores shots fired, unrolls the saddle bag, calmly fixes the extended stock to his pistol, and puts a bullet right through the forehead at 30 paces.

'Bravo.'

7 hours ago, Roost it far said:

Hahaha, it’s a kind offer but in my world there’s no Presidents!

Thats too close to MFC reality really.

1 hour ago, dpositive said:

Thats too close to MFC reality really.

Look how well it’s working!

9 hours ago, Stiff Arm said:

Would rather we put work into getting a key back, such as Leek Aleer

Why ? It’s clear a KPF is still a greater game changer.

32 minutes ago, 58er said:

Why ? It’s clear a KPF is still a greater game changer.

Like when we put AJ into the side and kicked 19 goals? I think Im with @Stiff Arm

6 weeks ago l would’ve said get him in, now not so much

Reliance upon an inconclusive member, by Carltons bog standard results, is virtual suicide.

McKay is certainly not flawless

but he did kick 49.21 last year.

obviously the price needs to be right but to dismiss him out of hand is ridiculous