VOTES: Rd 06 vs Richmond

[IvanBartul13 2,564]

6. Jack Viney

5. Max Gawn

4. Christian Petracca

3. Clayton Oliver

2. Kade Chandler

1. Jacob Van Rooyen 

[John Dee 438]

6. Viney

5.Gawn

4. Oliver

3. Petracca 

2. Lever

1. Chandler 

 

[Deeoldfart 7,802]

6.  Viney

5.  Oliver

4.  Gawn  *

3.  Petracca

2.  Lever  *

1.  Hibberd  *

Special mention to Nibbler.  I couldn’t quite squeeze him into my votes, but I thought he was an important contributor all game ………. and wow, haven’t his field and goal kicking have improved enormously this year?

*  how important it is to have these three back!

 

 

[Dee Dee 1,048]

6: Viney

5: Gawn

4: Petracca 

3: Chandler

2: Oliver

1: Van Rooyen

 

[Deeminion 348]

6. Jack Viney 

5. Clayton Oliver 

4. Christian Petracca 

3. Max Gawn 

2. Kade Chandler

1. Ed Langdon

[Swooper1987 2,777]

Was at the game last night and haven't seen a replay yet.  In terms of overall influence on the result, Gawn and Viney were the difference all the game and JVR was the match winner.  Chandler is coming along very nicely, ANB played the sort of game that really suits his strengths, Hibberd did well controlling what looked like our biggest danger in the first quarter and Lever was poised. I'll agree with the ANZAC medal judges and go:

6. Viney

5. Gawn

4. Chandler

3.Lever

2. Hibberd

1. Petracca

[waynewussell 4,092]

6 Viney

5 Gawn

4 Oliver

3 Langdon

2 Petracca

1 Chandler

[Fanatique Demon 2,409]

1 hour ago, Swooper1987 said:

6. Viney

5. Gawn

4. Chandler

3.Lever

2. Hibberd

1. Petracca

I agree with Swooper.

Much as I loved JVR’s final quarter and especially his goals, he was all at sea the other dozen times the ball came his way. 

[DeeZone 7,868]

6 - Jack Viney

5 - Max Gawn

4- Christian Petracca 

3 - Clayton Oliver

2 - Kade Chandler 

1 - Jacob van Rooyen 

I gave votes to the two kids that kept us in the game and eventually won it for us. Lever, Brayshaw and Langdon all deserved a vote, a great team effort in the end it was an exhilarating and tense game to watch at the G and boy did we get behind them it was so loud in the second half.!!!

[Tarax Club 3,064]

6 Jack Viney

5  Max Gawn

4 Christian Petracca

3 Angus Brayshaw

2 Thomas Sparrow

1 Edward Langdon

Honourable mentions;

Alex Neal-Bullen

Kade Chandler

Brody Grundy

Clarence Olivier

Jake Lever

Jacob van Rooyen

From the Director's chair;

Happenstance, JVR took flight in the last quarter just before being subbed off. His three goal burst was a match winning contribution. In a tense closely fought battle for supremacy of the hallowed MCG turf. The Demons overcame fierce resistance from the Tigers, to send them back to their Punt Road lair, to lick their wounds.

Adjudication;

According the DL post-game thread the condemnation of the umpiring performance was almost at universal pariah status. Surprisingly, the difference was only four more frees in favour of the Tigers. The total number of free kicks given was fifty-one. Is the fourth umpire necessary? Supposedly the extra gives greater scrutiny, but fairness goes both ways. The amount of infringements going 'unnoticed' particularly in packs is a blight on the game.

Broadcasters;

Preferred setting now during the game is a low rumble of crowd noise. Tiring of the oft partisan inanities and vacuousness of many the 'ex'pert commentators.

[Rob Mac...... 605]

Viney

Langdon

Chandler

Gawn

ANB.  

Oliver

 

also Trac. Grundy. Hibbo. Lever

[Monbon 1,524]

6: Viney

5: Oliver.

4: Gawn

3: Langdon

2: Lever

1: Petracca

 

 

[Demonland 65,981]

Clarrie extends his lead to 24:-

78. Clayton Oliver 
54. Christian Petracca
32. Brodie Grundy 
29. Jake Lever Jack Viney 
26. Max Gawn 
18. Lachie Hunter
16. Ed Langdon  
13. Kysaiah Pickett  
11. Trent Rivers
9. Ben Brown 
7. Charlie Spargo 
7. Judd McVee
5. Jake Bowey Tom McDonald 
4. Angus Brayshaw Bayley Fritsch Tom Sparrow
3. James Jordon Alex Neal-Bullen
2. Jacob van Rooyen 
1. Kade Chandler Michael Hibberd Harry Petty Steven May 

[dee-tox 4,829]

6. Petracca

5. Viney.

4. Lever

3. Oliver.

2. Gawn

1. Langdon.

[At the break of Gawn 3,592]

Staggering the lack of love for Grundy’s game. His second half was huge and if you listened to Hardwick’s press conference you’d learn that he was becoming the difference for us and that they were forced to move Balta into the ruck which led to JVR clunking some. 

[picket fence 15,419]

6 Gawn

5 Viney

4 Chatanooga Choo Choo

3 Langdon

2 Chandler

1 ANB

Hon mention Traac, Grundy

[DubDee 21,077]

6 minutes ago, picket fence said:

 

4 Chatanooga Choo Choo

Pardon me boy?

[spirit of norm smith 13,210]

6. Jack Viney

daylight

5. Max Gawn

4. Christian Petracca

3. Clayton Oliver

2. Kade Chandler

1. Ed Langdon

special mentions to JVR and Grundy

[deanox 8,733]

4 hours ago, Tarax Club said:

...

Adjudication;

According the DL post-game thread the condemnation of the umpiring performance was almost at universal pariah status. Surprisingly, the difference was only four more frees in favour of the Tigers. The total number of free kicks given was fifty-one. Is the fourth umpire necessary? Supposedly the extra gives greater scrutiny, but fairness goes both ways. The amount of infringements going 'unnoticed' particularly in packs is a blight on the game.

...

It was 10-17 Tigers way at half time, meaning we got 13-10 after that point.

Its a correlation/causation question in that sometimes you lead the free kicks because you are first to the ball and win the frees for holding the man, too high, etc. and other times you lead the game because the umpires are giving you all the momentum.

In that kind of case, momentum from free kicks is often about ground position and who had the ball at the time.

I thought in the first half they definitely helped Richmond's momentum.

[deanox 8,733]

1 hour ago, At the break of Gawn said:

Staggering the lack of love for Grundy’s game. His second half was huge and if you listened to Hardwick’s press conference you’d learn that he was becoming the difference for us and that they were forced to move Balta into the ruck which led to JVR clunking some. 

I do agree with this. I wanted to fit him in my 6 but couldn't. But Grundy into the ruck, freeing up Max to go forward had a big influence on the game.

[Tolstoys Nudge 1,256]

20 hours ago, Demonland said:

Clayton Oliver leads the Demonland Player of the Year after 5 rounds from Christian Petracca & Brody Grundy. Who gets your 6, 5, 4, 3, 2 & 2 votes please?

6) Gawn

5) Viney 

4) Grundy 

3) Chandler 

2) JVR

1) Lever

 

Edited April 25, 2023 by Nudge

[Tolstoys Nudge 1,256]

3 hours ago, dee-tox said:

6. Petracca

5. Viney.

4. Lever

3. Oliver.

2. Gawn

1. Langdon.

Thought Petracca was fumbly, one paced & altogether off-boil LN

Edited April 25, 2023 by Nudge

[robbiefrom13 877]

6 hours ago, Tarax Club said:

 

Adjudication;

According the DL post-game thread the condemnation of the umpiring performance was almost at universal pariah status. Surprisingly, the difference was only four more frees in favour of the Tigers. The total number of free kicks given was fifty-one. Is the fourth umpire necessary? Supposedly the extra gives greater scrutiny, but fairness goes both ways. The amount of infringements going 'unnoticed' particularly in packs is a blight on the game.

 

The free kicks awarded/denied in the early part of the game contribute to momentum.  Taking Fritsch's kick off him is a cruel blow, worth more than just one kick.  The umpires do appear to have a script to assist, as they can - and they often tidy that up statistically late in the game when the damage has been done.  Last night was too one-sided to be just the run of the green or whatever.  It was loaded in favour of the Tigers until later, when credibility dictated evening up the frees as far as could be harmlessly done.  Crying shame this happens, and without regulation.  Why, for example, has there never been an inquiry into how West Coast does so much better at home compared to interstate, etc etc?  Last night was a tough game, fought hard, except for the one-sided interventions of the part-timers.

[dee-tox 4,829]

2 hours ago, Nudge said:

Thought Petracca was fumbly, one paced & altogether off-boil LN

Not sure there were any absolute standouts to be fair. We tend to mark Oliver, Petracca and Gawn too critically. 30, a goal at 80 percent ain't bad going.

[waynewussell 4,092]

I was ferocious about several umpiring decisions at the ground on Anzac Eve. After watching the replay, I have to concede that the blocking for Fritta's high mark was there. The free against May for rough contact on the members wing was there. However, the non 50 to ANB for being bear-hugged to the ground seconds after marking was an umpiring screamer, as was the non-free for a push-out in a marking contest to Grundy at the Punt Road end. I could go on to mention at least three blatant incorrect Richmond disposals that the umps turned a blind eye to etc. etc. The lesson for me is that my own red & blue glasses cause some irrationality where umpiring is concerned, however, we are correct to suggest the standard of umpiring in our game sucked!