Goodwin 'confident' all four (May, Fritsch, Viney, Salem) will be available next week, as mentioned in his post game presser

Edited March 18, 20232 yr by adonski

 

11 hours ago, adonski said:

Goodwin 'confident' all four (May, Fritsch, Viney, Salem) will be available next week, as mentioned in his post game presser

That could just be coach speech. He was confident some would play this week too. 

Having been to training last week I reckon Viney will play. He didn’t train with the main group but was doing agility work with with a trainer before training without any strapping on the knee and looked to be moving very well. 

Salem trained with the 2nds. Theoretically he could play but they may bring him back through Casey. 

Fritsch didn’t train at all and was just having shots on goal. 

Given Kozzy will be out we need Frisch to fill that scoring void. Given he didn’t train last week I have no idea whether his foot is ready. Perhaps they were just keeping the load off for another week and that’s why he didn’t train. 

I can’t see May being ready this week based on his slight limp. Given his age I think they may be conservative with him. He was kicking the ball at training off one step and had no strapping on the calf but running at match level pace is a different story. Thomo played well enough not to rush him but there are massive match ups in the next 2 weeks. 

1 hour ago, rpfc said:

Sparrow too. It’s odd being judgemental for a team that started like that but that’s selection with 4 of our best 8 players out.

I left Sparrow out because right now I see his role coming off the bench and just giving guys like Oliver and Petracca a breather. I know what you mean but.....

I've accepted that reality Sparrow could turn out to be a Brad Sewell type player who'll be a good ordinary foot soldier that'll carve out a solid 150 game career.

No chance we rush all 4 guys back in. Tomlinson played well and deserves another crack while May gets 10000% fit. If May blows a calf you can kiss our season goodbye. 

Likewise I think Salem goes through the VFL to get some touch as he’s missed a lot of pre season. 

Lets assume at this time that Koz gets off and as per presser all of May, Fritter, Salem, Viney are available for selection. I would still only select Fritter and give May and Viney another training block ready for round 3. Salem I think needs to find touch in the VFL first. He is great when cherry ripe and in touch but Bowey, Rivers and McVee all deserve to maintain spots until he can show that. 

Assuming the above Fritsch in for Laurie only change. Melksham as sub again. 

I think if Koz out more likelihood we make two changes and try and replace his midfield minutes and hardness with Viney straight up.

 

 

Definitely wouldn’t risk May for the trip to QLD when Tommo did such a great job…get that calf/hammy 100% right

10 hours ago, dl4e said:

May won't play next week.

Agree, would rather delay his and others return by and have him / them 100% fit when he / they are back.

Upside we have plenty of depth, gives these guys exposure and experience on the big stage. Let’s utilise our squad’s strength.

 It’s going to be a long season…. we want all our key players cherry ripe come September. (exact opposite to last year)

Edited March 18, 20232 yr by Wodjathefirst

Daniher and Hipwood didn't look too flash yesterday so no need to rush May back. Give him all the time he needs. 

Brisbane were slow and ponderous yesterday. we'll carve them up. if Salem ready I'd give him some gametime. 

Viney should come if fit. Doubt Fritsch is ready. And given its a foot injury lets be cautious.

If the medical/conditioning/training staff say Viney, Fritsch and May are 100% fit  they must be selected.

Midfield bull and inspiration, best goal kicker, top defender - how do you not play them?

If Kozzie gets a holiday, there are 4 changes to a side that had a big win.

It's rather different to the dark old days!

Fritsch (if fit)for Laurie, he’s not up to it yet, couldn’t understand how he played in front of others 

Viney (if fit) for Kozzie (1-2 weeks)

May (if fit) for Thommo unlucky 

Salem (if fit) or JJ for Hunter (I’m with you ANG13) not convinced with Hunter yet

We just won’t make 4 unforced changes. We never have. 
Goodwin seems hell bent on not repeating the mistakes of last year and grinding our best players into the ground. We have to be fit come finals. No point finishing second and bombing out in straight sets again because half our squad can’t get out of bed, let alone play 120 minutes of finals intensity footy. 
It is early in the season and we have depth and plenty of kids desperate to play. None of the debutants disgraced themselves yesterday and both Chandler and Tomlinson had wonderful games. No point rushing 4 underdone players in for round 2. If it’s a final, sure, but it’s round 2. 

Out: Pickett, Laurie

In: Viney, Fritsch

We will smack Brisbane, They got us when it mattered last year but we are streets ahead of them playing fully fit.  It'll take about 3 minutes to get back in their heads and then it's all over. They've got a deep, dark chasm to cross to get to our side and that won't happen anytime soon. Personally I was worried about last night with our outs but jeepers, we're even better than I thought and that's saying something! I just want to beat the Pies, that and the Premiership, that's all I want. The rest is just fluff. 

 

9 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

We just won’t make 4 unforced changes. We never have. 
Goodwin seems hell bent on not repeating the mistakes of last year and grinding our best players into the ground. We have to be fit come finals. No point finishing second and bombing out in straight sets again because half our squad can’t get out of bed, let alone play 120 minutes of finals intensity footy. 
It is early in the season and we have depth and plenty of kids desperate to play. None of the debutants disgraced themselves yesterday and both Chandler and Tomlinson had wonderful games. No point rushing 4 underdone players in for round 2. If it’s a final, sure, but it’s round 2. 

I don't see them as "unforced" changes Jaded.

They are three of our best and would have played Saturday night if fitness allowed. As I said above though, 100% is the key.

Tomlinson was excellent. I hope he's given another week and potentially more if form permitting. Am I crazy in thinking Petty isn't an automatic lock, if he gets beaten next week and May is ready to return v Sydney? I know some,even me, have pencilled him in as a future AA Backman, but that doesn't exactly mean his spot is an absolute lock, if others 'below' are performing. It's easy to forget he's still 23* and isn't immune to a dip in form. 

Edited March 18, 20232 yr by John Demonic

1 hour ago, John Demonic said:

Am I crazy in thinking Petty isn't an automatic lock, if he gets beaten next week and May is ready to return v Sydney? 

I am pretty certain it will just be you. 

13 hours ago, titan_uranus said:

You’d imagine Brisbane will be fired up after their Round 1 shocker. Big game. 

Pickett will miss. He has to. Maybe Melksham takes his spot?

 

Well yes, but I’d also imagined they’d be fired up yesterday after last years preliminary embarrassment. Lions defenders have always been a liability over the past few years, their fwds have annihilated weaker teams but often struggled against top 4 sides, but their midfield has always been solid. Yesterday they were carved up the middle largely by a couple of kids.

4 hours ago, ANG13 said:

I have said it through the pre season I am out on my own on Demonland with my views on Hunter and he did nothing last night to convince me he should be playing in front of some of our young players or even Harmes on last nights form. And if Salem is fit I am definitely playing him in front of Hunter, just my thoughts. 
 

I don’t expect Hunter to be dropped but I would. 

Awful call. What are you basing his “nothing” game on? only having 12 disposals? Langdon had 14.. should we drop him also? .. Hunters 12 touches were damaging. 3 score involvements, 75% efficiency & i saw him on numerous occasions do the 1 percenters. And considering how dominant his preseason was, he’s only going to get better. Not sure why the anti hunter sentiment.. But you’ll eat your words in no time. 

49 minutes ago, Die Hard Demon said:

Awful call. What are you basing his “nothing” game on? only having 12 disposals? Langdon had 14.. should we drop him also? .. Hunters 12 touches were damaging. 3 score involvements, 75% efficiency & i saw him on numerous occasions do the 1 percenters. And considering how dominant his preseason was, he’s only going to get better. Not sure why the anti hunter sentiment.. But you’ll eat your words in no time. 

Just my opinion that we have others in front of him. 
 

More than happy to eat my words on Hunter. 

2 hours ago, John Demonic said:

 Am I crazy in thinking Petty isn't an automatic lock, if he gets beaten next week and May is ready to return v Sydney? 

Confirmed crazy 

Petty is a lock in the starting 18 and is May’s heir to the throne 

IN.....The Bull and The  Hun.

Out.... Pickett .( probably because he's not Geelong or Carlton)  and Laurie.

Done. No more.

4 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

I left Sparrow out because right now I see his role coming off the bench and just giving guys like Oliver and Petracca a breather. I know what you mean but.....

I've accepted that reality Sparrow could turn out to be a Brad Sewell type player who'll be a good ordinary foot soldier that'll carve out a solid 150 game career.

Some think he is a star-to-be, personally, I don’t see it. Sewell would be a good comparison.

6 minutes ago, rpfc said:

Some think he is a star-to-be, personally, I don’t see it. Sewell would be a good comparison.

I don't see it either. To be honest he's been underwhelming for me since the 2021 season.

15 hours ago, At the break of Gawn said:

Out: Tomlinson (stiff because he was good), Pickett

In: May, Fritsch

May won't be ready.

I love petty but if you were judging the game on form not name, he goes out for may. Not Tomlinson. He was exceptional last night.