2022 All Australian Team

[58er 6,565]

4 hours ago, The Lobster Effect said:

I'm actually surprised he made it. Had a good year but not as good as last year. Was injured in the first quarter against the Dockers, missed the next two games and then took a few games to get back in the groove after his dust-up.

Most "new" champion choices often make the team in their second breakout year as Selectors trust the new champs on the block. 

Players like Sinclair and Saad are one hit wonders generally. 

[Radar Detector 1,347]

6 hours ago, Garbo said:

Felt like Brayshaw stiff not to at least make the bench, not sure rozee had that good of a year. One again no wings, with the way the transition game is played these days they are one of the most important roles in any serious team, no coincidence that all the best sides have at least one good winger.

Rozee finished 5th in the coaches votes 1 behind Tracc and 10 behind Clarry and Miller. He deserves his spot.

how Tom Lynch doesn’t get in ahead of Hawkins is beyond me though. Clearly wanted a cats captain.

Edited August 24, 2022 by Radar Detector

[Edm 104]

Don’t get the Tom lynch or tex argument

you can’t have more than 3 kpf

i actually think it should only be 2

curnow most goals 

cameron probably best overall player this year 

and Tom Hawkins goals and goal assists probably gives him nod as well as geelongs record 

tom lynch only kicked 19 goals against top 8 teams with bags at the end of the year against hawks who didn’t even play sicily on him and Essendon who were cooked 

Edited August 24, 2022 by Edm

[BenBeams 33]

Clarry for Chaz this year 🤞🏻

[Radar Detector 1,347]

19 minutes ago, Edm said:

Don’t get the Tom lynch or tex argument

you can’t have more than 3 kpf

i actually think it should only be 2

curnow most goals 

cameron probably best overall player this year 

and Tom Hawkins goals and goal assists probably gives him nod as well as geelongs record 

tom lynch only kicked 19 goals against top 8 teams with bags at the end of the year against hawks who didn’t even play sicily on him and Essendon who were cooked 

For starters, Hawkins only kicked 16 goals against top 8 teams (8 games, 2 goals/game) and Lynch kicked 19 goals against top 8 teams from 5 games (3.8 goals/game) and kicked more goals overall despite playing 5 less games. It was an objectively superior body of work.

[Edm 104]

9 minutes ago, Radar Detector said:

For starters, Hawkins only kicked 16 goals against top 8 teams (8 games, 2 goals/game) and Lynch kicked 19 goals against top 8 teams from 5 games (3.8 goals/game) and kicked more goals overall despite playing 5 less games. It was an objectively superior body of work.

Tom lynch goal assists 6 

tom Hawkins goal assists 26 

[layzie 34,011]

5 hours ago, Wrecker46 said:

I used to live next door to Clarko. I had an argument with him about who was better out of Oliver and Cripps.

1 to Wrecker 0 for Clarko.

When we payed Carlton I noticed Cripps tagging Oliver a few times at centre bounces. Oliver would get away from him and Cripps was following him.

You won't see Clarry tagging anyone. Cam.you.imagime if he got a free run.at the ball.

 

You had an argument with Clarko? Have you got a death wish? 😛

[jnrmac 20,188]

Disgrace that Hawkins is Captain.

Has never captained at any level. Borderline cheat with his 'flailing' arms and elbows

[layzie 34,011]

Hawkins captain is a bigger middle finger than Trump getting presidency.

[Clintosaurus 7,865]

17 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

Disgrace that Hawkins is Captain.

Has never captained at any level. Borderline cheat with his 'flailing' arms and elbows

Don't forget the litres of baby oil to make it harder to tackle him and some of his team mates.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Another job well done by the selectors, trying to squeeze in 19 inside mids into a 22 man squad.

Wingers do not exist. 

[Demonstone 22,820]

9 hours ago, Crystal Dees said:

Then don't read it. You saw the topic title.

The topic title wasn't "Let's have a whinge about all the Geelong players in the AA Team".

[BDA 22,889]

15 minutes ago, Demonstone said:

The topic title wasn't "Let's have a whinge about all the Geelong players in the AA Team".

Great idea for a thread DS. I love bagging Geelong

[titan_uranus 25,043]

4 hours ago, Clint Bizkit said:

No idea how Blicavs keeps getting AA, Brayshaw extremely unlucky.

Huh? Isn’t this Blicavs’ first AA?

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

2 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

Huh? Isn’t this Blicavs’ first AA?

Gut feel says his second and I can’t be bothered looking it up.

[titan_uranus 25,043]

9 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

Gut feel says his second and I can’t be bothered looking it up.

Definitely his first. 

[Bates Mate 4,510]

1 hour ago, layzie said:

Hawkins captain is a bigger middle finger than Trump getting presidency.

Maybe if the selectors let people know their criteria.

In my my if you are a club captain and good enough to make the starting 18 then You should be 1st choice . If their a more than one choose the captain they feel had the better year (Cripps this year)

If it's just a lifetime achievement award just let people know to avoid all the ambiguity

I think part of it is to generate discussion 

 

 

[reynolds46 1,273]

as long as Goodwin ends up the AA coach I don't care about the captaincy

[Gunna’s 2,104]

I’d like it if the players awarded AA were then asked on the spot to vote for their  captain (not the selectors captain). Secret ballot style to be read out at the end.
I think that would result in a captain everyone respects. 

[layzie 34,011]

23 minutes ago, Bates Mate said:

Maybe if the selectors let people know their criteria.

In my my if you are a club captain and good enough to make the starting 18 then You should be 1st choice . If their a more than one choose the captain they feel had the better year (Cripps this year)

If it's just a lifetime achievement award just let people know to avoid all the ambiguity

I think part of it is to generate discussion 

 

 

That's right. I personally thought Cripps should have been bench but he's in the team so captain makes sense. Or how about this novel concept: Touk Miller?

It's not supposed to be a popularity contest and something where bozos can chat afterwards with comments like "I'm glad they gave it to him"

[DeeZone 10,129]

Must admit I just expected it to be the Premiership Captain who just received his sixth All Australian Jacket but I suppose Hawkins has been such a great captain at glong. Grrrr bloody grrrr. Turned off at that point.!!!!

[joeboy 3,166]

Obviously the selectors got orgasmic after the vision appeared of Hawkins running downfield to admonish the poor ball movement of his team’s defenders. True captain’s worth🙄

[Mr Steve 3,820]

Has a player ever won the Brownlow and not made the AA team. 

[Jjrogan 1,439]

1 hour ago, Bates Mate said:

Maybe if the selectors let people know their criteria.

In my my if you are a club captain and good enough to make the starting 18 then You should be 1st choice . If their a more than one choose the captain they feel had the better year (Cripps this year)

If it's just a lifetime achievement award just let people know to avoid all the ambiguity

I think part of it is to generate discussion 

 

 

I think they let the people know when first Rance, and then Franklin was made AA captain in 2018. He wasnt part of the leadership group at the Swans and like Hawkins had never been captain. Since Selwood they spread it around now.   

They dont spell it out because they know the outrage and debate get the clicks! 

2 minutes ago, Mr Steve said:

Has a player ever won the Brownlow and not made the AA team. 

Woewodin immediately springs to mind

[Sideshow Bob 2,418]

5 minutes ago, Mr Steve said:

Has a player ever won the Brownlow and not made the AA team. 

Yeah Priddis for a start without thinking