On 16/04/2025 at 17:21, John Demonic said:

At this rate, he'll choose the Tigers

Imagine being stuck on the list at a football club that has just scapegoated and sacked your father for not magically transforming a full cliff-dive rebuild into an instant return to contenders?

That would be vintage Richmond, I must say.

Fun fact: between Tom Hafey and Damien Hardwick, a Richmond coach (not including caretakers) was more likely to coach less than 50 games than more than 50 games.

7 below 50 games, 5 over 50, and just two (Tony Jewell and Danny Frawley) cracked 100.

Discuss.

Deserves a rookie list spot. His year has been tremendous compared to last year.

Big final snd the kid boots 7 straight.

Seven goals so far for Casey today. He looks smart and is a fantastic set shot. We could do a lot worse than him.

Once you've nominated once already for father/son, not been selected, can you be eligible again the following year? 7 goals in a final would be worth a rookie or even a late pick selection just to see what happens. Couldn't do any worse than Woewodin or Brown.

Id rookie him

Yep. i'd take him as a rookie, if not as a late pick in the main draft.

Rookie spot is beckoning. Good game sense and he. can. kick. straight.

12 minutes ago, boydie said:

Once you've nominated once already for father/son, not been selected, can you be eligible again the following year? 7 goals in a final would be worth a rookie or even a late pick selection just to see what happens. Couldn't do any worse than Woewodin or Brown.

Anyone know the rule? It would be awesome to see white and yze at the dees.

Edited August 30Aug 30 by Gouga
Typo

On 15/04/2022 at 23:30, dazzledavey36 said:

Is currently with the under 16's Oakleigh Chargers team and played alongside another father son prospect in Kynan Brown last week against Sandy Dragons.

One to watch.

Hopefully better than Woewoedin, Kynan Brown… hope they’re delisted.

Just get him squirreled away Melbourne.. just do it.

Google AI says yes can renominate.

Only ineligible once placed on another AFL list.

ChatGPT

ChatGPT - AFL Father-Son Rule

Shared via ChatGPT

Chat gpt agrees

Edited August 30Aug 30 by Sideshow Bob

Kicking straight, he’ll never fit in.

Definitely worth a look. Get in the gym Noah

Tom Wallis

Jake long

Josh clayton

Tom Fields

All examples of F/S nominated a second time after not being taken. Tom Fields ended up at Carlton though after not being taken by sydney as the eligible club

5 minutes ago, Fritta and Turner said:

Definitely worth a look. Get in the gym Noah

If he's anything like his old man it won't matter.

14 minutes ago, Fritta and Turner said:

Definitely worth a look. Get in the gym Noah

He looked pretty strong already. I thought that was one of his pros. Just from watching this game my impression is he's powerfully built, plays smart and is a great kick. He took contested pack marks and got out on the lead. Kicked running goals as well as set shots.

My concern would be with his height. He played more like a KPF today, but he's too small for that role at AFL level. I don't see the athletic traits to play mid, although he is listed as a wing on his draft profile.

All that being said, he's clearly a very smart footballer, and Jake Melksham has reminded us how much value a smart mid-sized forward can be. Maybe he builds into that role?

Rookie him now!!

Get him!! Him and White coming in together makes me very excited

3 hours ago, beelzebub said:

If he's anything like his old man it won't matter.

I dont think he has the smarts/skill of his old man so compensate with a bigger, stronger body.

He can be pre listed as a Category A rookie, or taken as a father son rookie, if not taken in the main draft.

4 hours ago, GawnOfTheDead said:

Hopefully better than Woewoedin, Kynan Brown… hope they’re delisted.

What a dribble post. Woey is looking better by the week ant pup has given much needed desperation when he has come in.

I have been a massive Goodwin supporter but that is over now. He won us a premiership and maybe didn't give the kids a go he needed too.

Noah Yze was exciting today and you would have to think he will come to Melbourne but we have overlooked him twice.

He kicked 7 goals but the greatest moment was when he nailed Woey with a picture perfect pass. You can't script tha

He plays next year you can bet you house on it it.

10 minutes ago, Wrecker45 said:

What a dribble post. Woey is looking better by the week ant pup has given much needed desperation when he has come in.

I have been a massive Goodwin supporter but that is over now. He won us a premiership and maybe didn't give the kids a go he needed too.

Noah Yze was exciting today and you would have to think he will come to Melbourne but we have overlooked him twice.

He kicked 7 goals but the greatest moment was when he nailed Woey with a picture perfect pass. You can't script tha

He plays next year you can bet you house on it it.

I’ll happily be proven wrong, but until now, they both under perform, apply no pressure and lack polish and skill. They wouldn’t be getting game time at other clubs, and do because of their name.

I hope they come good, because how good would that be for them and us.

2 hours ago, Wrecker45 said:

What a dribble post. Woey is looking better by the week ant pup has given much needed desperation when he has come in.

I have been a massive Goodwin supporter but that is over now. He won us a premiership and maybe didn't give the kids a go he needed too.

Noah Yze was exciting today and you would have to think he will come to Melbourne but we have overlooked him twice.

He kicked 7 goals but the greatest moment was when he nailed Woey with a picture perfect pass. You can't script tha

He plays next year you can bet you house on it it.

Totally agree. Plays smart and team first. Very popular and hard at it.

9 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Discuss.

Deserves a rookie list spot. His year has been tremendous compared to last year.

Big final snd the kid boots 7 straight.

Got my vote Dazzman!