On 5/15/2021 at 6:15 PM, Turner said:

sorta wanted a place we can all dump some potential names of interest across the competition to strengthen the side. just been spitballing in my head came up with a couple:

a small forward who tackles AND kicks goals, got McDonald-Tippungwuti front of the queue with 1 yr to go on his current deal, could be gettable given the two sides trajectories

wingman: either of whitfield or jkelly not sure about the getability tho especially with the money jelly is tied on and whitfields length of deal but maybe one might fall out to accomodate the other

half back: recently learnt jordon dawson was OOC and it caught my attention. might keep an eye on how he plays next couple weeks just see what he's like as a mature HB option we could look at. also eddy rich at the dogs has had some clubs ask the question and would suit a need but maybe less proven at the level to date

half forward: lipinski, too good to play vfl but at full strength seems to be on the fringes at the doggies so they can fit 12 mids in, certainly an improvement on melky in terms of touches and delivery but mayve less scoreboard impact, could also see harmes move to this role when all our side is availabvle.

I wrote in one another thread a few weeks back to watch this space. Very good chance Lipinski will be at the Dees in 2021.

Having a talented list and performing strongly should make us an appealing destination for both young players wanting to return to Victoria and older players seeking a flag before retirement. On the latter, I wonder if we could convince Ziebell to come across at below market rates. He's a free agent I would suspect North might be happy to accept a 2nd round compensation pick (around pick 20) for a 30yr old that won't feature in their next finals team.

We should pick up Brodie Kemp from Carlton, he is 20 yr old. This kid will be another Cripps.

3 minutes ago, COOLX said:

We should pick up Brodie Kemp from Carlton, he is 20 yr old. This kid will be another Cripps.

i doubt very much that, having taken two years to rebuild him, carlton would be prepared to let him go

On 5/15/2021 at 11:03 PM, Jaded said:

Gees imagine getting The Bont. 
Dreaming I know.

We’d be unstoppable. Would remind me of when KD went to the Warriors.

Biggest issue be retaining who we’ve got. Spent plenty keeping pies away from Trac. 
Develop our own and astute drafting.  If someone falls into our lap for unders, so be it. 

8 hours ago, COOLX said:

We should pick up Brodie Kemp from Carlton, he is 20 yr old. This kid will be another Cripps.

I'm just bumping this comment so everyone can see it in all it's glory for a second time. A thing of beauty. It has everything, complete unknown quantity, has never played a game, history of long term leg troubles, coming from a mid ranged club, 20 years old, comparison to a club champ. It's a future browlow medalist prediction away from being hall of fame.

it's chefs kiss

1 hour ago, Rigatoni Rigoni said:

I'm just bumping this comment so everyone can see it in all it's glory for a second time. A thing of beauty. It has everything, complete unknown quantity, has never played a game, history of long term leg troubles, coming from a mid ranged club, 20 years old, comparison to a club champ. It's a future browlow medalist prediction away from being hall of fame.

it's chefs kiss

To be fair Rigatoni plenty of BS (big statements) are made on Demonland. You learn to let them pass...

On 5/18/2021 at 7:29 AM, JV7 said:

I wrote in one another thread a few weeks back to watch this space. Very good chance Lipinski will be at the Dees in 2021.

What makes you think that?

I like Kane Farrell from Port. Gettable. Good kick, classy user. Don’t know if he’d transition to a wingman, but he’d add something different to our side regardless. Would be a best 22 player.

Edited May 31, 20213 yr by KingDingAling

Would be nice to raid a few of the power clubs who've spent years raiding the MFC, anyone at the Pies or Hawks sick of losing?

Heard some rumours Brayden Maynard might be unhappy at the Pies. I hope we are into him. Would be a great lockdown defender, super competitive and excellent kick. No idea on contract status though.

A quick google says Maynard will be a free agent at the end of 2022. Would Collingwood consider trading him a year early?

Ed Richards and Lipinski are also worth a look IMO.

Know it's not exactly a player trade target, but could we be aggressive to move into the top 10 of the draft this year? Perhaps trade a 2nd rounder and a future 1st and target the best available outside midfielder?

Edited May 31, 20213 yr by adonski

6 minutes ago, godees said:

Heard some rumours Brayden Maynard might be unhappy at the Pies. I hope we are into him. Would be a great lockdown defender, super competitive and excellent kick. No idea on contract status though.

future first in 2022 out the door, maynard in? make it happen josh mahoney alan richardson gary pert choco jason taylor tim lamb

5 hours ago, drysdale demon said:

What makes you think that?

I know people say all the time "I have a close source" but I honestly know someone close to Pat & the last time I asked the question both parties were very keen... 

4 hours ago, godees said:

A quick google says Maynard will be a free agent at the end of 2022. Would Collingwood consider trading him a year early?

Ed Richards and Lipinski are also worth a look IMO.

Melbourne supporter, old man works for Casey Demons and is very close with Petracca.

He would be an awesome replacement for Hibberd. 

4 hours ago, godees said:

A quick google says Maynard will be a free agent at the end of 2022. Would Collingwood consider trading him a year early?

Ed Richards and Lipinski are also worth a look IMO.

Melbourne supporter, old man works for Casey Demons and is very close with Petracca.

He would be an awesome replacement for Hibberd. 

On 5/30/2021 at 5:11 PM, Nascent said:

Having a talented list and performing strongly should make us an appealing destination for both young players wanting to return to Victoria and older players seeking a flag before retirement. On the latter, I wonder if we could convince Ziebell to come across at below market rates. He's a free agent I would suspect North might be happy to accept a 2nd round compensation pick (around pick 20) for a 30yr old that won't feature in their next finals team.

Ziebell? Wtf would you want him for ? 

2 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Melbourne supporter, old man works for Casey Demons and is very close with Petracca.

He would be an awesome replacement for Hibberd. 

Did his father play for us?

Agree.  Brayden Maynard would be a great addition. Tough. Solid defender. Good kicking skills. 

33 minutes ago, Fat Tony said:

Did his father play for us?

Yes

7 hours ago, godees said:

Heard some rumours Brayden Maynard might be unhappy at the Pies. I hope we are into him. Would be a great lockdown defender, super competitive and excellent kick. No idea on contract status though.

And again, Maynard's inclusion would allow us to release Rivers to a wing or into a genuine mid role.

7 hours ago, adonski said:

Know it's not exactly a player trade target, but could we be aggressive to move into the top 10 of the draft this year? Perhaps trade a 2nd rounder and a future 1st and target the best available outside midfielder?

We should be doing this every year, so that if possible, we're bringing in top end talent and giving Jason Taylor a look in the first round every year.

Disagree it should be about necessarily targeting an outside mid. I think it should almost always be a case of picking best available.

10 hours ago, Fat Tony said:

Did his father play for us?

Not just his father Peter, but his brother Corey as well.  Would welcome Brayden to the fold.

17 hours ago, godees said:

Heard some rumours Brayden Maynard might be unhappy at the Pies. I hope we are into him. Would be a great lockdown defender, super competitive and excellent kick. No idea on contract status though.

 

13 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Melbourne supporter, old man works for Casey Demons and is very close with Petracca.

He would be an awesome replacement for Hibberd. 

I had no inside knowledge but have been pushing this for a while now.

Pies will need to get in a good draft position and Maynard is one of the few chips they have.

He would be perfect fit in our defence.