Farewell Mitch Hannan

[58er 6,353]

1 hour ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

I wasn't suggesting we don't trade him, commenting more on folks saying his form has been poor and inconsistent.  There was good reason for that which is easy for folks to overlook.

In his favour (imv) he is far better than ANB, AvB plays injured and one wonders how long he can keep that up and on par with or slightly more valuable than Hunt. 

But if he has market value, we let him go.  Altho would much rather let ANB go but I suspect there are no takers. 

No problems LH but if every player whose form was not great in 2020 is excused because of 2019 fitness and 2020non VFL footy we won't improve our list. 
Mitch is 26 ANB 24 I think AVB is 28 but under contract and I am in favour of retaining Toby Bedford and happy with Spargo's 2020 progress with 2 of his very best games vs Pies and Giants. We need that EACH week of course.

But Mitch  is older and that IMO weighs against potential fir improvement.

Hrnce my negotiation suggestion re player rather than a draft pick trade.

[cantstandyasam 700]

1 hour ago, poita said:

I'd be happy to delist Hannan, so if anybody wants to take him for a pick under 100, good luck to them.

Clearly has ability, but doesn't work hard enough and goes missing way too often.

He's Mr 20%, he plays really well once every 5 weeks.

[Pates 9,649]

I wonder whether part of Hannan’s frustration would stem from seeing the likes of Melksham and AvB consistently avoid the chop (Melks in particular) despite being equally ineffective in the games. 

Personally I’m a fan and could see a trial on the wing for him. I’d still be offering him a 2 year with that said with an option for a third should he break through a certain amount of games. 

[Turner 1,505]

14 hours ago, 58er said:

I am a fan of Mitch but if we Think  he can't Offer more ie improve in 2021 then let him go.

Maybe look at a trade of a player from the Dogs like Trengove or Schacke or even AhChee. All have greater potential ( and Could be are a level above Mitch's best ) therefore a 3 Rd or 4 th rounder might be necessary to get a deal done .

Just think that our Player bottom no's 15/30  this year were so disappointing ( and of course they did it tough With no real games ie VFL) but we have no tome to waste with players that aren't going to improve us.

Mitch's fitness is a bit of a query ( as would Ah Chee's be also) But let's look at next opportunity to switch a couple of deck chairs Ie nothing ventured nothing gained!

who is this AhChee of the bulldogs you speak of?

[spirit of norm smith 16,193]

If the Bulldogs really want Hannan , I am not interested in a pick. I’d force their hand and ask for Louis Butler.  Sure he’s only 19 and played no senior footy, but I rate this kid and was surprised that he was left in the draft until pick 53 last year.  I had him around a pick in the low 30s and would not have been disappointed if the Dees picked him. 
Had a very good under 18s year at Sandringham and Vic metro and captained Brighton Grammar.  He is like Trent Rivers in his run, skills, intensity and size.  A very good kick which is a must. Suits a half back or wing role. Let’s see if they are interested.  

[dazzledavey36 54,098]

6 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

If the Bulldogs really want Hannan , I am not interested in a pick. I’d force their hand and ask for Louis Butler.  Sure he’s only 19 and played no senior footy, but I rate this kid and was surprised that he was left in the draft until pick 53 last year.  I had him around a pick in the low 30s and would not have been disappointed if the Dees picked him. 
Had a very good under 18s year at Sandringham and Vic metro and captained Brighton Grammar.  He is like Trent Rivers in his run, skills, intensity and size.  A very good kick which is a must. Suits a half back or wing role. Let’s see if they are interested.  

Mate, he was drafted last year and is contracted until 2021. Bulldogs will not give up a kid that I'm sure they rate highly for a bloke who drifts in and out of games and someone they can get for a 4th round pick or delisted free agent.

Have to be realistic here. We'll be getting a late pick at best.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

4 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Mate, he was drafted last year and is contracted until 2021. Bulldogs will not give up a kid that I'm sure they rate highly for a bloke who drifts in and out of games and someone they can get for a 4th round pick or delisted free agent.

Have to be realistic here. We'll be getting a late pick at best.

It's not like us to overrate our own players...

[dazzledavey36 54,098]

44 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

It's not like us to overrate our own players...

Tell me about it Wise..

Red and blue glasses need to be taken off when it comes to this time of the year.

[spirit of norm smith 16,193]

Bulldogs see Hannan as an upgrade on Sam Lloyd and Tory Dickson has come to an end. They seemed to have Vandermeer and the inconsistent Bailey Dale as half forwards.  I think they are still p&$d-off by us grabbing Hannan ahead of them after he had a very good year in the Dogs VFL team in 2017.  My point was that you ask the question and see what is the response.  Hannan is worth at least a 3rd round pick imo.  50 games. Consistent goal kicker.  

[Turner 1,505]

On 10/18/2020 at 1:31 PM, spirit of norm smith said:

Bulldogs see Hannan as an upgrade on Sam Lloyd and Tory Dickson has come to an end. They seemed to have Vandermeer and the inconsistent Bailey Dale as half forwards.  I think they are still p&$d-off by us grabbing Hannan ahead of them after he had a very good year in the Dogs VFL team in 2017.  My point was that you ask the question and see what is the response.  Hannan is worth at least a 3rd round pick imo.  50 games. Consistent goal kicker.  

they're surprisingly yet to announce delistings but OOC are ALOT of those mid type nothing players hannan barely an upgrade but like us theyre trying to try something different so fair play to them and i wont be surprised when he's off their list in 2years. hopefully we can weasil their first pick out of the deal once we make our other moves and get the late points up

[spirit of norm smith 16,193]

16 minutes ago, Turner said:

they're surprisingly yet to announce delistings but OOC are ALOT of those mid type nothing players hannan barely an upgrade but like us theyre trying to try something different so fair play to them and i wont be surprised when he's off their list in 2years. hopefully we can weasil their first pick out of the deal once we make our other moves and get the late points up

Yes the Dogs will try to engineer points so we might be a willing partner in pick swaps. It’s a crazy time 

[old dee 23,695]

On 10/18/2020 at 12:27 PM, Wiseblood said:

It's not like us to overrate our own players...

Why on earth would you say that !

[old dee 23,695]

As a number of people have said is about a number 30 on our list. Too inconsistent. He is one of those players that is good at VFL level but not good enough senior level. He has had his chance, go or stay I don't really care either way. If we ever make a GF he won't be in the 22.

Edited October 20, 2020 by old dee

[Redleg 40,776]

1 hour ago, old dee said:

Why on earth would you say that !

Sarcasm OD, have you forgotten what it looks like?

[Demon3 2,541]

Officially requested a trade to Bulldogs. i feel a bit sad about this, liked him. But this is life, if Goodwin didnt play him, then fair enough and we have a few of his types.

[Dirts 429]

Had potentially but never really shined. Was a handy inclusion at the time but not really there if we are to progress to the next level.

Hopefully we can engineer a decent trade that may be on traded to secure Brown. or someone else that we may require.

 

 

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

This is a bit disappointing. Will always remember the sealer in the semi final against the Cats in 2018.

Come to think of it, I miss that winning feeling - it's good for the soul.

 

[Lucifers Hero 39,320]

9 minutes ago, Ron Burgundy said:

This is a bit disappointing. Will always remember the sealer in the semi final against the Cats in 2018.

Come to think of it, I miss that winning feeling - it's good for the soul.

 

This one:

Spine tingling!  Still brings happy tears.

Up there  with the Watts QB goal for unbridled joy and emotion.

Sad to see him go.

[Lord Travis 10,676]

Late 3rd - early 4th round pick would be about right. 

Bulldogs have pick 48, but no 4th rounder. So it's pick 48 or pick 84 unless there's swaps or players involved.

Getting 48 for Hannan would be a win IMO. 

[Bang Bang Bang 5,799]

Similar to Kent in my opinion. Both decent fringe players with a penchant for memorable goals. We'll swap him for a can of coke and he'll do well for the Dogs, but we won't lose much sleep at the same time.

His goal in 2018 is easily the best MFC goal of the modern era IMO. Best wishes Mitch. 

[Red and Blue realist 2,051]

6 minutes ago, Lord Travis said:

Late 3rd - early 4th round pick would be about right. 

Bulldogs have pick 48, but no 4th rounder. So it's pick 48 or pick 84 unless there's swaps or players involved.

Getting 48 for Hannan would be a win IMO. 

Don't think the dogs will offer up anything this year, they need all the points they can get, might even end up being a 2nd round next year and we give them Hannan and 62 & 63 this year, so ends up being around a 3rd rounder but they get extra points this year and we get the better pick next year.

[Demonland 71,123]

 

[Turner 1,505]

good deal, take what we can get and target a genuine small crumber instead

[Demonland 71,123]

 

[58er 6,353]

56 minutes ago, Ron Burgundy said:

This is a bit disappointing. Will always remember the sealer in the semi final against the Cats in 2018.

Come to think of it, I miss that winning feeling - it's good for the soul.

 

Think it's about time we put 2018 to bed really to just great memoriesUp until Prelim Final.

The Support fabric of that team are not up to it NOW viz Oscar Jets Hannan Melksham ANB snd AVB sadly plus Smith And Hunt who both really havn't improved much. Maybe one or two others I can't think of.

Also our plan is nit the same and not able to be practiced 2 years on.

This  is why we We're so inconsistent In 2020 because our Top 10/12 played pretty well right down to Fritta and Weid ( still much room fir improvement though) plus Hibbo BUT our lowest 10 on any given day most from my list above did not  contribute other than cameos.

Hunt Spargo and Baker showed some good girl in odd games but went missing for 2/3 games when needed as support to our stars.

Thats why we need to stop looking at some on our list and move on ie move than on as we will not improve.

Really Baker Jordan Sparrow Bedford and Chandler should all have been given time and matches to test them out this year. We are none the wiser re them to hold or release some! 

FWIW Sparrow looks the goods Baker showed some great skill and needs at least one more year free from injury and I think Jordan has always looked promising his pace being questioned mainly and Bedford improved but his next level is needed consistently and who knows? Plus Chandler who May be lucky to survive.

This year we had May and Trac improve markedly to A graders and who knows if our 12/ 30 on the list Many of those improved we could be like the Cats who have found that this year with a slightly more altered and more aggressive game plan and consistency from most on their list.

Lets get it together Dees in 2021.