Brock makes Sheahan's List

[alpha33 277]

Brock McLean is our third most rated player by Hun listmaker Mike Sheahan. He comes in behind Cameron Bruce and Aaron Davey in Catch Judd if you can

SHEAHAN'S TOP 50

1. Chris Judd (West Coast)

2. Barry Hall (Sydney)

3. Jonathan Brown (Brisbane Lions)

4. Dean Cox (West Coast)

5. Matthew Pavlich (Fremantle)

6. Adam Goodes (Sydney)

7. Brad Johnson (Western Bulldogs)

8. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda)

9. Shaun Burgoyne (Port Adelaide)

10. Chad Cornes (Port Adelaide)

11. Brendan Fevola (Carlton)

12. Simon Goodwin (Adelaide)

13. Scott West (Western Bulldogs)

14. Aaron Sandilands (Fremantle)

15. Daniel Kerr (West Coast)

16. Brendon Lade (Port Adelaide)

17. Ryan O'Keefe (Sydney)

18. Luke Hodge (Hawthorn)

19. Matthew Lloyd (Essendon)

20. Brett Kirk (Sydney)

21. Lenny Hayes (St Kilda)

22. James Clement (Collingwood)

23. Simon Black (Brisbane Lions)

24. Adam Hunter (West Coast)

25. Luke Power (Brisbane Lions)

26. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda)

27. Matthew Scarlett (Geelong)

28. Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn)

29. Scott Lucas (Essendon)

30. Nick Stevens (Carlton)

31. Cameron Bruce (Melbourne)

32. Paul Chapman (Geelong)

33. Luke Ball (St KIlda)

34. Dustin Fletcher (Essendon)

35. Andrew Embley (West Coast)

36. Lindsay Gilbee (Western Bulldogs)

37. Craig Bolton (Sydney)

38. Joel Bowden (Richmond)

39. Darren Glass (West Coast)

40. Brett Burton (Adelaide)

41. Luke McPharlin (Fremantle)

42. Andrew McLeod (Adelaide)

43. Kane Cornes (Port Adelaide)

44. Aaron Davey (Melbourne)

45. Daniel Cross (Western Bulldogs)

46. Tyson Edwards (Adelaide)

47. Daniel Wells (Kangaroos)

48. Ryan Griffen (Western Bulldogs)

49. Graham Johncock (Adelaide)

50. Brock McLean (Melbourne)

With Bruce our main man at # 31 you can understand why many in the media don't rate our flag chances. And why is it that we don't seem to be able to produce any top 10 players?

[Pepe Dee Pew 0]

We have only 3 players in the top 50. All in the bottom half. The Grandfinalists of the last two years have 2 players each in the top 10.

The pleasing thing about that is that with our young group of players if we can get a few to really emerge we could get there. I would suggest that White and Neita will not improve but Brock, Col, Bate, CJ, Bartram, Jones etc may the the top 10 of the future. They all have heaps of potential.

Has Dunn got what it takes to be a top forward? Will Newton step up in the next couple of years.

Given that we have made the finals 3 years in a row and are tipped to do it again we have done so with an even list without the top 10 types who tend to break open finals. Not a bad effort.

Perhaps Bruce, TJ and Green can step up. Or have they peaked at 26 or so??

One thing is FOR SURE to win a premiership we need a couple of players to emerge from the group and dominate.

Col has heaps of potential but cannot get his body right. Brock is maade of the top 10 stuff. Can some of the others step up??

Who is most likely to emerge?

What players can make the difference?

Will it be next year, this year?

No coach can win a premiership without those real top guns in the side.

CAC has spent several years building this list. Now lets see how far they can be developed by the club.

[Gorgoroth 12,330]

I think Trapper and McLean should be higher than Davey on last year's performances.

[demon_josh_au 0]

Tell me who rates Fish Face's lists?

[Jaded No More 58,113]

Sheahan's list means nothing, for one, the guy is infatuated with Joel Bowden. Enough said really.

McLean will be in the top 20 by the end of the year (given no injuries), I bet my entire shoe collection on it. :D

[demon_josh_au 0]

HA HA HA bowden at 38!!!! what a joke. I could almost do the role that bowden does.

[Demon Disciple 11,020]

Sandilands and Lade in the top 50????

another classic Sheahan 50.

[Slartibartfast 15,800]

It's one man's opinion. Put up your own list and see some of the comments that role in. And it's a great talking point.

If Melbourne win the flag this year we'll have 4 players in the top 25.

IMO Travis's year last year was very underrated. He averaged over 20 possessions a game and as we know, he uses them. Davey is overrated IMO. Little output, flashy contributions and far to much weight given to his "near run downs".

[Rivers Run Red 182]

Here's what Sheehan wrote about us in the AFL 2007 magazine...

"The Demons look top-four material and could be the best of the Victorian teams. They will regain Moloney (seven games last year) and have an emerging midfield gun in McLean. Neitz must stay fit and productive, and big years from Bruce, Davey and Johnstone would be handy."

Sounds about right.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

SHEAHAN'S TOP 50

24. Adam Hunter (West Coast)

That's ridiculous.

[kryton 0]

That's ridiculous.

And where is Ben Cousins huh???

[classy dees 42]

That's ridiculous.

my first thoughts exactly.

good player and would like him at the dees, but not the 24th best in the league.

[rumpole 480]

And where is Ben Cousins huh???

Ben Cousins was excluded because of the doubt over his playing career. Had he been sprung one week later, Brock would've missed out on making the top 50.

[demonfanjezza 1]

List absolute garbage

The media hates us <_<

[Yze_Magic 3]

Griffen and Cross ahead of Brock

What a joke

[Cactus 2]

fletcher and lucas.... sums up the quality of the list.

bowden is great for your dream team and thats about it, as far as him as a backman.

i think they were the only bleedingly stupid ones, some are too high, some too low but they always will be.

[Jarka 767]

Sandilands at 14 is, well, entertaining to say the least.

[ickey_11 145]

Chad Cornes at 10!

Rivers is a better CHB than Cornes.

Although Cornes is very versatile he is not a top 30 player in any position.

[Damo 2,997]

Sandilands at 14 is, well, entertaining to say the least.

I've put $10 on Sandilands to win the Brownlow at $81. Apart from Brock, ($61) my only bet.

I think Burgoyne is value too at $31(I think).

I reckon it is the best list Sheahan has put together for a few years.

I'm sure there are plenty who would have Colin Sylvia and Daniel Bell in, going by the exuberant urging going on here.

[CHAMP 347]

How can you take this list seriously when only half-a-dozen backmen are deemed good enough to make it. For a supposed senior journalist he's taken a very blinkered and puerile view of the relative worth of players. He should know that games are won just as much by defenders as mid-fielders and goalkickers.

[The Backyard Charizard 1,178]

The media hates us.... We all know this already, but I can now see why blokes like Sheehan and the likes rate the Bulldogs so highly when they have 5 blokes in the top 50 and Cooney doesn't even get a mention!

Similar to Brock, but not good enough to get in over Griffin??

That list is crap!

[Gouga 508]

Sandilands at 14 is, well, entertaining to say the least.

I'm not saying he is as talented as others on the list but he is probably the one player besides Brown and Judd that every coach wants on their list.

[tess 19]

I've put $10 on Sandilands to win the Brownlow at $81. Apart from Brock, ($61) my only bet.

I think Burgoyne is value too at $31(I think).

I reckon it is the best list Sheahan has put together for a few years.

I'm sure there are plenty who would have Colin Sylvia and Daniel Bell in, going by the exuberant urging going on here.

Where are you getting $61 for Brock?

[loges 6,094]

It's one man's opinion. Put up your own list and see some of the comments that role in. And it's a great talking point.

If Melbourne win the flag this year we'll have 4 players in the top 25.

IMO Travis's year last year was very underrated. He averaged over 20 possessions a game and as we know, he uses them. Davey is overrated IMO. Little output, flashy contributions and far to much weight given to his "near run downs".

agree with fan davey's done nowhere near enough to be in top 50

[Ash35 425]

The fact that Davey is ahead of McLean shows the list is flawed.

In fact, as a few have said, Davey is not top 50 material.