The calumny of the AFL's priority pick policy

[Demon Dynasty 17,149]

1 hour ago, Moonshadow said:

For sure Jones is tradable, if managed well (though far from a certainty at MFC) 

Would I like to see him stay and get to 300 games and be a one club player? The romantic in me says yes. But romance won't get us closer to a flag. He won't play in a flag at MFC. Do you think Jones would want to stay because of loyalty or because he thinks he's weekly best 22? In 2020 he's not.

He has a couple of years to add to a club like Gold Coast who struggle to keep experienced stars. He'd get one year with us, some of it at Casey. Fresh start at a young club, surf next door. I'd say it's tempting.

3 + Jones to GCS for 2 (Anderson). 

As much as you might want that to happen Jones is staying Moon.

Hopefully he'll improve a little also assuming he gets a full pre-season in.

[Wrecker45 3,381]

5 hours ago, Moonshadow said:

For sure Jones is tradable, if managed well (though far from a certainty at MFC) 

Would I like to see him stay and get to 300 games and be a one club player? The romantic in me says yes. But romance won't get us closer to a flag. He won't play in a flag at MFC. Do you think Jones would want to stay because of loyalty or because he thinks he's weekly best 22? In 2020 he's not.

He has a couple of years to add to a club like Gold Coast who struggle to keep experienced stars. He'd get one year with us, some of it at Casey. Fresh start at a young club, surf next door. I'd say it's tempting.

3 + Jones to GCS for 2 (Anderson). 

Jones is not in it for the money and has no affection for the Gold Coast. Why would he make himself some tradeable commodity?

He has never been a leader by tongue it is all on field. Lead by example and his best footy is behind him. His leadership doesn’t work with an aging body.

The idea he would go to another club is ridiculous.

 

[Wrecker45 3,381]

6 hours ago, GetJonnoPatton said:

You create a winning culture by winning games of footy. Period. 

All else is smoke and mirrors.

You create a toxic culture by doing the wrong thing by your staff. Perception is important.

We on demoland are all passionate supporters and expect the players to play for the jumper. They need a reason to.

Winning is important but it can be short sighted. Carlton sold the farm to get Judd to win a few games. How did that work out for them?

[Moonshadow 17,678]

10 hours ago, Rusty Nails said:

As much as you might want that to happen Jones is staying Moon.

Hopefully he'll improve a little also assuming he gets a full pre-season in.

I don't doubt he will. We don't have the balls to do the deal 

[whatwhat say what 23,738]

1 hour ago, Moonshadow said:

I don't doubt he will. We don't have the balls to do the deal 

you seem to miss the point where he needs to agree to a trade too, and he might not WANT to go north to finish his career, seeing as his wife is based in melbourne, her job is in melbourne, his kids are forming friendship circles here, his brother is about to return to the state, the rest of his family is based here?

it's not just down to the team in the afl - the players have a LOT of control over their own destiny, much more so than in the majority of international sports

also, there's NO WAY if gc17 are gifted a priority end point pick - which seems a fait accompli - that they won't be taking rowell and anderson as best mates to play together

[Demon Dynasty 17,149]

25 minutes ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

you seem to miss the point where he needs to agree to a trade too, and he might not WANT to go north to finish his career, seeing as his wife is based in melbourne, her job is in melbourne, his kids are forming friendship circles here, his brother is about to return to the state, the rest of his family is based here?

it's not just down to the team in the afl - the players have a LOT of control over their own destiny, much more so than in the majority of international sports

also, there's NO WAY if gc17 are gifted a priority end point pick - which seems a fait accompli - that they won't be taking rowell and anderson as best mates to play together

He doesn't WWSW.   Wants to finish as a one club player which is why he'll be staying.  He may not have continued on otherwise.

Regardless of whether you may want him to stay or go, as a Demon supporter you have to admire his love of and loyalty to the club.

[DemonOX 8,841]

6 minutes ago, Rusty Nails said:

He doesn't WWSW.   Wants to finish as a one club player which is why he'll be staying.  He may not have continued on otherwise.

Regardless of whether you may want him to stay or go, as a Demon supporter you have to admire his love of and loyalty to the club.

I am happy he is staying but if his form is down like this season I expect him to be dropped to Casey, no exceptions. 

Edited September 1, 2019 by DemonOX

[Redleg 42,087]

16 hours ago, buck_nekkid said:

We lose about 500 points if we are forced to move down from 2-3.  That is a second rounder.  If they get 2, we should get 21 behind our 20! (Won’t happen....)

Only won't happen because every other club would then try the same thing.

Also, if GC do get pick 2 and we say nothing about it, I expect that could be because we have done a deal for something with the AFL and have been told to publicly cop it on the chin. We will see.

It is far more productive to work with City Hall, than against it.

Edited September 1, 2019 by Redleg

[Adam The God 30,668]

9 hours ago, Wrecker45 said:

Jones is not in it for the money and has no affection for the Gold Coast. Why would he make himself some tradeable commodity?

He has never been a leader by tongue it is all on field. Lead by example and his best footy is behind him. His leadership doesn’t work with an aging body.

The idea he would go to another club is ridiculous.

 

I think his leadership must work off field, because I've very rarely seen it on field as you describe. Being on the bottom of every pack is not leadership.

[Demon Disciple 12,520]

54 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Also, if GC do get pick 2 and we say nothing about it, I expect that could be because we have done a deal for something with the AFL and have been told to publicly cop it on the chin. We will see.

As in a fully funded new home base! One can only hope!!!

[Redleg 42,087]

54 minutes ago, Demon Disciple said:

As in a fully funded new home base! One can only hope!!!

That would be a sensational  deal, but maybe a large AFL contribution, together with help in getting it through the approval stage would be a pretty good deal too.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

2 hours ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

you seem to miss the point where he needs to agree to a trade too, and he might not WANT to go north to finish his career, seeing as his wife is based in melbourne, her job is in melbourne, his kids are forming friendship circles here, his brother is about to return to the state, the rest of his family is based here?

it's not just down to the team in the afl - the players have a LOT of control over their own destiny, much more so than in the majority of international sports

also, there's NO WAY if gc17 are gifted a priority end point pick - which seems a fait accompli - that they won't be taking rowell and anderson as best mates to play together

Not so. What i did say was "if it was managed well" which implies that we would put it to him in a way which might work for both parties. Doesn't mean he will. Of course he'd more than likely turn it down, likewise we might might not meet his expectations for another MFC contract. People change jobs and move interstate away from family.... stranger things have happened at trade time.

I also have posted that I don't doubt he will stay. Not sure any other clubs would be interested apart from GCS. We'll nurse him through to 300 like the polite club we are. 

A few on 'Land have suggested any PP to GCS might come with the condition it is traded, to bring in experienced player/s. Who knows. My suggestion gives them Jones and pick 2 only moves one spot to 3.

It's healthy to explore options, and on here to propose a few leftfield suggestions, whether they happen or not.

 

[Demon Disciple 12,520]

45 minutes ago, Redleg said:

That would be a sensational  deal, but maybe a large AFL contribution, together with help in getting it through the approval stage would be a pretty good deal too.

[censored] that. Fully funded.

[Ethan Tremblay 31,347]

18 hours ago, buck_nekkid said:

We lose about 500 points if we are forced to move down from 2-3.  That is a second rounder.  If they get 2, we should get 21 behind our 20! (Won’t happen....)

Every other team is pushed right one as well, would that mean they all get another pick directly after their second round pick? 

Don’t get me wrong, GC getting a PP annoys me  but too many posters (and I’m not saying yourself bn) are taking it too personally, every other team suffers as well. 

[buck_nekkid 6,092]

3 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Every other team is pushed right one as well, would that mean they all get another pick directly after their second round pick? 

Don’t get me wrong, GC getting a PP annoys me  but too many posters (and I’m not saying yourself bn) are taking it too personally, every other team suffers as well. 

Yeah.  I’m looking at the ridiculous nature of the whole thing.  I am resigned to us having zero input into what happens, so we have to roll with it.  The fact is that shifting from 2-3 has a bigger impact than any other move, and the size of that move is that of a second rounder.  I am not taking it personally, just looking at the AFL-ness of the whole thing....

[Bring-Back-Powell 15,449]

Rowell and Anderson won’t be the best 2 players in the draft. Lock it in, take it to the bank.

How many picks 1 and 2’s in the draft were in the All Australian team this year? Hint = less than 1.

Getting pick 3 instead of 2 is so irrelevant it’s not even funny.

 

Edited September 1, 2019 by Bring-Back-Powell

[old dee 24,072]

4 hours ago, Redleg said:

Only won't happen because every other club would then try the same thing.

Also, if GC do get pick 2 and we say nothing about it, I expect that could be because we have done a deal for something with the AFL and have been told to publicly cop it on the chin. We will see.

It is far more productive to work with City Hall, than against it.

As LBJ said it is better to have your enemies on the inside of the tent pissing out than have them outside pissing in.

[old dee 24,072]

23 hours ago, GetJonnoPatton said:

Winning games of footy takes precedence over sentimentality and loyalty. All options and possibilities should be on the table, including moving on Jones. 

We have tried that with a couple of recent captains in McDonald and Green and that worked well.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

4 hours ago, old dee said:

We have tried that with a couple of recent captains in McDonald and Green and that worked well.

Mr Old, I'd say more because of the way the club handled it rather than the reality of their time being up.

Interesting to note that Junior is no longer involved in footy - Old McDonald has a farm.

Edited September 1, 2019 by Moonshadow

[old dee 24,072]

12 hours ago, Moonshadow said:

Mr Old, I'd say more because of the way the club handled it rather than the reality of their time being up.

Interesting to note that Junior is no longer involved in footy - Old McDonald has a farm.

Ee I ee i o

[Cheesy D. Pun 1,765]

On 8/27/2019 at 1:20 PM, sisso said:

I hear what you’re saying but we never quite seem to get our act together. I keep hearing about what a great side we have but on the field it’s generally more shattered dreams. Who knows if 2018 was just a lucky season can anyone say with certainly it wasn’t? We’ve endured another season from hell and if pick 2 nets a significantly better player than pick 3 we have every right to be furious that the AFLs pet basketcase gets it over us...

But we were once it's 'pet basketcase' and received the same treatment. Isn't this just sour grapes?

[John Demonic 5,987]

Judd on Classified mentioning that we should trade pick 2 for Ben King and helping them draft Rowell + Anderson, followed by Caro saying we think GCS will get pick 2"

Judd: "Well "we" don't. My professional opinion is that I think they'll get pick 10" - It was his response to Lloyd after he asked if Judd knew anything.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

2 hours ago, John Demonic said:

Judd on Classified mentioning that we should trade pick 2 for Ben King and helping them draft Rowell + Anderson, followed by Caro saying we think GCS will get pick 2"

Judd: "Well "we" don't. My professional opinion is that I think they'll get pick 10" - It was his response to Lloyd after he asked if Judd knew anything.

Maybe that's part of the deal. They get 1, 2 and 10. We get King. 

Edited September 2, 2019 by Moonshadow

[Bates Mate 4,520]

 

10 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

Maybe that's part of the deal. They get 1, 2 and 10. We get King. 

That makes zero sense. So do Judd's comments about gc getting pick 10 .

[Moonshadow 17,678]

Just now, Bates Mate said:

 

That makes zero sense. So do Judd's comments about gc getting pick 10 .

Thanks Gil