Might be a reality check for Hogan ..he wanted to explore his options ..we ok’d it & explained how we would use the picks we got for him ..Freo didn’t value him enough ...I now feel whatever happens in the future ...he doesn’t hold all the cards !!

Wait, no, THIS one will bring on the 300.

I'm as sure as Peter Bell is stupid.

1 minute ago, EnterTheDragon said:

 

Today’s outcome was predicted by science, folks.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-5718081/amp/Scientists-confirm-short-man-syndrome-REAL.html

Very appropriate post to begin page 300

5 and 23 is a credit to our football department for their willingness to take unders in order to satisfy Hogan's desire to return home. It sounds like we did all we could on our end. We put Hogan's wishes ahead of the clubs needs. When contract time comes we can only hope Jesse factors that gesture in. 

5 minutes ago, KingDingAling said:

Passing up the opportunity to land Hogan, and overseeing the departure of Neale - pretty much puts paid to any chance Fyfe may of had of tasting success in his career. Sandilands will depart at the end of next year, and with no guarantee Darcy will make it as a ruckman, that could very well leave Lobb to carry the load. Freo will still need key backs and forwards. Hogan is probably the last home grown forward to fit their need, and they just passed up on him for a reasonable deal. It is just a disaster for Fremantle IMO. If I were Fyfe I would be asking for a trade this week.

Can we get Fyfe please...if only we had a young WA product to trade...

Nobody is going to want too deal with these [censored]! And players won’t want to go there... Someone in purple is trying to be a hard arse pumping his chest! 

If that’s you Peter Bell it ain’t working! You need to take your cape off and suffocate yourself immediately! 

Who is the fella who took over from Lloyd. He seems to be another [censored] in the gun who is going to ruin this club! 

I would love if Cerra and Brayshaw told them they want out and back to Victoria and won’t be signing on any further... 

10 minutes ago, monoccular said:

Try ate so bad that they achieve this without even trying 

A psychiatrist’s ??

 

11 minutes ago, MFC-11 said:

I'd like to help this get to 300. But how can I help?

You already have.

13 hours ago, Engorged Onion said:

Can we get Fyfe please...if only we had a young WA product to trade...

Now that you mentione Fyfe.  It was reported that he and Jesse are great mates. 

Suspect Bell has [censored] off his own captain and perhaps other teammates who were looking forward to playing with Jesse and winning a few more games. 

Bell doesn't realise what a pandora's box he has opened.  The guy is a football player and a radio jock - has no idea of managing people and organisations.

39 minutes ago, Pates said:

 

It's also on his teammates to make sure in no uncertain terms they are glad he's still with us, and try to make him more of a Demon.

True but more up to Hogan to become more of a Demon and jump in with both feet. If he doesn’t im not sure he will have a good season in 19. 

I think Jesse is a genuine CHF and can push into the centre square and onto a wing also...

Our forward line can definitely work with Hogan, Weid, TMac and Preuss. Why? Because both Hogan and TMac can push up the ground and create a rotation that would be difficult for opposition too match up on.

It will be a strength of ours that will be un rivalled. Just look at Hogan and TMac as extra midfield/flankers rather than Key Position.

 

19 minutes ago, faultydet said:

Seems Freo are positioning themselves to finish on the bottom next year.
Terribly poor management.

They can try, but the Suns have that one sewn up already. And equally badly run.

Freos supporters just scream “VIC BIAS” any time a journo is critical of Fremantle. 

2 hours ago, Gorgoroth said:

Came home to these three beauties and the news that Freo are bigger flogs than I thought... which was already a bloody lot!

Just remind me of your address again Gorgoroth. I will bring a worthy single malt and a small glass.?

1 minute ago, Matty said:

I wish someone would enlighten me on these Hogan issues. Bali incident?

i feel like a mushroom 

Please keep on topic - I gather it is biscuits.  (but me too)

Hogan will play off half back next year, a solid inside source told me about an hour ago. Also told me last week that Tyson was gone for Pruess. 

So i will watch closely. 

“The club is not unhappy” his words...

49 minutes ago, Aus in Engerland said:

Not supporting the Gibbs trade (they paid too much) but it wasn't simply picks 10 and 16 for Gibbs. Adelaide also go 2018 picks 21 and 40. And gave up 2018 pick 28, expected to be much later as Adelaide were expected to finish a lot higher.

So what ?

2 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Hogan will play off half back next year, a solid inside source told me about an hour ago. Also told me last week that Tyson was gone for Pruess. 

 So i will watch closely. 

“The club is not unhappy” his words...

I like it.  He's one of the best field kicks in the team with a big tank

I think it is clear that in the end Freo didn’t want him for whatever reason and their offer was a token effort, knowing it would be rejected. Hogan will need to work really hard to rehabilitate his value because I think it has plummeted 

Edited October 12, 20186 yr by chook fowler

1 minute ago, ucanchoose said:

I like it.  He's one of the best field kicks in the team with a big tank

Agreed. He doesn’t like the goal square. Will still get a chance to kick the odd goal running forward

7 minutes ago, ucanchoose said:

I like it.  He's one of the best field kicks in the team with a big tank

Makes complete sense and physically he is ideal for that position. He has strength, stamina and pace. Just needs to develop a defenders mindset.

3 minutes ago, Tram 74 said:

Makes complete sense and physically he is ideal for that position. He has strength, stamina and pace. Just needs to develop a defenders mindset.

Mmm...well he's not mad on that pack marking thingy....

Just now, Engorged Onion said:

Mmm...well he's not mad on that pack marking thingy....

Agreed, that’s part of the mindset bit.

Apologies if this has been mentioned before as I’ve not caught up however, this outcome aligns with ch7 Perth’s early call from Basil big nose last night that was apparently a ‘tele prompt’error. 

That and the time stamp in Mitch Cleary’s tweet all deduces to the fact that Freo had informed local stakeholders at least, yesterday afternoon. 

Was Mahoney aware of anything this morning and he played a straight bat, thereby allowing Freo to reconsider?

Who knows but if anything last nights ch7 Perth blunder was in fact anything but. 

Edited October 12, 20186 yr by McQueen

9 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

No idea what you are getting at, he said “Goodwin has earmarked him for Half Back for next year...”

and said the club wasn’t unhappy...”

I was commenting on another post.

I was ok with hogan leaving IF HE wanted too, only if we got compensated what he is worth.

It feels like everyone is trying to come up with reasons for him not being any good.No player is perfect and remember he is ONLY 23  What about Carey, fevola,Alistair Lynch, Barry hall etc Players like hogan are franchise players who put bums on seats, yes hogan is a risk but so is the draft. 

im not sure what Gibbs treloar lever Weller Neale etc are all getting paid at there clubs but I’m pretty sure it’s not near 1.2 -1.3m what Fremantle think hogan is worth. 

Now Fremantle want to play hardball and take there own risks what if Kennedy has a major injury next year and west coast might start thinking Hogan’s available or even with these new rules ie no hands in the back, one player starting in goal square hogan could kick 70+ for Dees and win a flag, pretty sure he won’t leave Dees after that.