Changes vs Sydney

[Demon17 5,203]

1 hour ago, pineapple dee said:

I think Spargo provided precisely the sort of input the FD required yesterday. For a player as vulnerable to big hits as him, he doesn't appear that scared by it and he puts everything in the line in every contest. He'll keep playing believe me.

Couldn't agree more. Big fan.

He doesn't panic or drop chest marks and can reliably hit targets. Clutch goals in close are also a speciality when compared to others. Not as quick as JKH but I'll take the above.

I actually think they both need to be in the 22.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

9 minutes ago, Petraccattack said:

 

LOL...  ok but, who gets dropped?

Frost has been playing well, and I doubt O Mac gets dropped. Was only 8 days ago he took Jenkins to the cleaners.

 

I do like Frost (except for that kick) and O. McDonald has been solid this year but I just worry who he will match up on if there isn't a Jenkins-style forward in the opposition.

[rjay 25,093]

4 hours ago, MSFebey said:

AFL website.

They have Hannebery as Test and Rohan 2 weeks, which was before this weekends game v Pies.

I think our best can win, but I've seen too many letdowns over the years to not get ahead of myself.

I feel like getting ahead of myself...

I reckon the Swans are like an old prize fighter at the moment and they got up off the deck for one last punch against the Pies.

I will be very disappointed if we don't bury them on the weekend.

Edited August 6, 2018 by rjay

[Demon_JB 1,385]

Would considering Hunt be too early for a senior recall? I just think with the wide open G' and Sydney lacking some pace, having Hunt off half back to replace Smith would be our most ideal scenario. 

For me:

OUT: Smith, JKH
IN: Hunt, Melksham

[Deespicable 2,886]

I think people are underestimating the influence Joel Smith has had on our backline - he provides pace, an ability to play on smalls and talls, he loves snagging a tackle and he intercepts really well. I accept that he's still learning the game (he's only played about eight) and his kicking choices at times are a little off, but I reckon he's been a sensational Mr FixIt since replacing Lever and he's one of the chief reasons why we are not all bemoaning the lack of pace that others possess down back.

I know Wiseblood disagrees, but I reckon outside of Salem, he's the one player from our back seven who we cannot cover because of his flexibility.

We can bring in Hunt to provide the dash and tackle pressure - but he is not capable of outmuscling a big. We can bring in Wags who can provide the leap and is more precise with his kicking, but he's just not as quick when teams break through our press and he's a left-footer - we've got plenty of those. We can bring in Pedo and we'll get an honest worker with a thumping kick, but if we do we are back to being the slowest side in the league that was exposed by the Pies and Tigers.

I actually have three changes to fix our issues down back  - that's how crucial Smith is.

Firstly, we need some marking confidence down back and unfortunately for the past six weeks Oscar has lost his mojo in that area. This is not a crime, he is a kid after all. But he needs to go back and spend two weeks in the twos as  the dominant man so that he can return eager to play his role in the finals. At the moment he looks worried the minute he is isolated down back near the goal square, so Frosty is now preferred for that role. Further to that Pedo has been playing even better than his normal reliable self and provided there is a slowish match up, then he is our best bet as our second tall defender until O-Mac's mojo returns. McCartin is a slowish match-up and he's a kid and Pedo should be able to exploit him and peel off for a few intercept marks. And as with Oscar, Pedo's the smoothest, cleanest kick in the side.

The second change is that Hunt has to come in this week, otherwise we will just be too slow down back against the Swans who have been forced to go small because of injuries. More than likely Jetta will have to play on Ronke and Hunt is quick enough to play on Papley or Rohan if he is rushed back.

The third change is that we may need to bring in Wags to counter Parker or Heeney's aerial ability when they play forward - effectively play Smith's role on the third tall. It's a tricky call because it means Bernie is pushed out of our backline. The question is whether Bernie is then sent forward where he can provide nuisance value and utilise his smarts and his kicking skills or just dropped again. But the forward line is where I'd like to see him play out this season and finish his terrific career because Lewis is too slow to play anywhere else than down back and our former Hawk is a lovely reader of the game and clever outlet - nine times out of 10 anyway.

If that means JKH or Spargo misses, then so be it. Both are young, both are working their butt off and developing, but with so much at stake, they aren't quite strong enough yet to regularly make an impact. Vanders is strong enough, he just isn't game-fit yet, but he'll get there and he's the ideal type for the Swans. Obviously if Melky is fit, then one of them has to make room anyway.

In: Pedo, Hunt, Wagner (Melky if fit)

Out: O.Mac, J.Smith, JKH/Spargo

B: Jetta (Ronke) Frost (Buddy) Lewis

HB: Hunt Pedo (McCartin) Salem

C Jones Brayshaw Tyson

HF: ANB T.Mac Vince

F: Garlett Hoges Petracca

Ru: Gawn Harmes Oliver

Int: Vanders, Wags, Fritsch, JKH/Spargo 

 

 

[jnrmac 20,189]

1 hour ago, Petraccattack said:

 

LOL...  ok but, who gets dropped?

Frost has been playing well, and I doubt O Mac gets dropped. Was only 8 days ago he took Jenkins to the cleaners.

 

I wouldn't say that...

Frost to buddy. The Swans don't really have any other tall forwards...

[shorty 233]

We must stop McVeigh

[Hardatit 13]

Need someone to play the intercept role...Wagner best suited for that.

[binman 43,821]

17 hours ago, radar said:

Who was on that Sun today - bobbed up and bagged five. 

Cover Buddy then there’s Ronke 

Whoever it was there are two likely dl responses.

1. Omac was on him

2. Small defenders get a free pass. It is only kpds that are heldcaccoubtable for forwards kicking bags.

[Vagg 2,439]

19 hours ago, DubDee said:

Milkshake for Smith

Salem and Fritsch to play more HB

I was wondering this, too.  If Syd aren't all that tall up fwd, Goody may prefer to keep changes to a minimum.  If so, we may already have sufficient cattle to cover the back half...

[jumbo returns 6,741]

1 hour ago, juzzk1d said:

Would considering Hunt be too early for a senior recall? I just think with the wide open G' and Sydney lacking some pace, having Hunt off half back to replace Smith would be our most ideal scenario. 

For me:

OUT: Smith, JKH
IN: Hunt, Melksham

Doesn't work anymore - coaches have woken up to him and block his path and zone up on his kick

If he plays, I'd play him forward....find a new string to his bow

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

5 hours ago, Petraccattack said:

Why are people wanting Pedders to come in when we have O Mac and Frost as key defenders?

Because without Joel we'll be lacking a 3rd tall intercept player.  And Pedders is the only logical alternative with AFL cred (albeit he has dropped away a fair amount from his form in prior years ?

[Diamond_Jim 12,628]

12 minutes ago, jumbo returns said:

Doesn't work anymore - coaches have woken up to him and block his path and zone up on his kick

If he plays, I'd play him forward....find a new string to his bow

agree Jumbo

as I posted a few weeks back the modern line breaker runs about 10 metres ...just enough to stretch the zone.

Hunt really has to reinvent himself.Watched him at Casey several times and even at that level he rarely got any run going.

[DeeSpencer 26,083]

17 minutes ago, jumbo returns said:

Doesn't work anymore - coaches have woken up to him and block his path and zone up on his kick

If he plays, I'd play him forward....find a new string to his bow

Hunt at his best used his speed to defend and to run in to space to receive as much as he did to have those big breaking runs through the middle. Coaches have caught up to the big run and the game has got faster with less plodders to run by but speed from half back is still a valuable weapon. Just don't think Hunt was fit and healthy at the start of the year. Was hands on hips after every effort instead of making the defensive play and then flicking straight in to attack. I don't think 1 VFL game will be enough to have him at his peak fitness. A couple more games at Casey and he could be an option either down back or up forward if they lose all faith in Garlett.

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

16 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Agree. 

Lever, Stretch, Maynard, J smith out for season

Viney indefinite 

Hibberd - 1 week

Melksham - 1 week

ins. j Wagner,  Hannan 

Outs j Smith, Jkh 

Melksham available for the Swans

[Deemania since 56 6,719]

1 hour ago, jnrmac said:

I wouldn't say that...

Frost to buddy. The Swans don't really have any other tall forwards...

From the HBflank, this may be a chance to give OMAC an opportunity to shine due to the lack of talls at the Swans. I would give him a try from the bench during the game. If Melk plays, Jones could HBFlank it well, I'd reckon, and Hunt or Kent could come in for some grunt and footspeed.

[bing181 9,330]

Talk about revisionism. Hunt was OUT of the side because he wasn't getting near it. Now, he's had a huge slab of the season out, but after one very average game back in the VFL, he's a "must in"?

[KysaiahMessiah 725]

Any news personnel wise around Sydney? Any injuries? Dees are into $1.37 and I can't fathom that, have been heavily backed today.  

[Dee Zephyr 19,269]

3 minutes ago, Travis16 said:

Any news personnel wise around Sydney? Any injuries? Dees are into $1.37 and I can't fathom that, have been heavily backed today.  

Wow, there’s talk of Hannebery and Rohan returning and the plunge is on us?

[Bitter but optimistic 22,249]

21 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

UNLEASH.  THE.   PED.

Indeed. I read somewhere post game that Goody said something like Pedo had been playing good footy down back at Casey. Could be on the money Ethan.

If Milkshake is right he'll come back. Vanders did ok first game back so JKH is on thin ice.

Edited August 6, 2018 by Bitter but optimistic

[KysaiahMessiah 725]

2 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:

Wow, there’s talk of Hannebery and Rohan returning and the plunge is on us?

Something we don't know about?  Seems very odd

[Dee Zephyr 19,269]

1 minute ago, Travis16 said:

Something we don't know about?  Seems very odd

Agreed, it is odd. $1.33 on TAB and they moved the line out from -17.5 to -21.5.

Edited August 6, 2018 by Dee Zephyr

[old dee 23,872]

13 minutes ago, bing181 said:

Talk about revisionism. Hunt was OUT of the side because he wasn't getting near it. Now, he's had a huge slab of the season out, but after one very average game back in the VFL, he's a "must in"?

Beggars belief doesn't it.

[jnrmac 20,189]

20 minutes ago, Deemania since 56 said:

From the HBflank, this may be a chance to give OMAC an opportunity to shine due to the lack of talls at the Swans. I would give him a try from the bench during the game. If Melk plays, Jones could HBFlank it well, I'd reckon, and Hunt or Kent could come in for some grunt and footspeed.

Please. My views on OMac are well known so I won't rehash them but even his most ardent supporters wouldn't countenance OMAc playing anywhere else but FB.

[Willmoy1947 4,140]

I reckon on Peddo or maybe Weideman and Macdonald goes down back with bro. We have the scoring power with Hogan and Weideman.........