5 hours ago, thesleepinggiant said:

My belief is Adelaide won't get anywhere near a premiership with these two.

They actually did.

Edited July 30, 20187 yr by david_neitz_is_my_dad

3 minutes ago, WERRIDEE said:

Flat track bully like Hogan.

I don't mind some of your posts but to say that about Hogan is a non-supporter comment. He's regularly double teamed and been carrying a niggling injury for over a month. He played last Saturday still feeling the effects of illness. 

What's your excuse for being a [censored]?

14 minutes ago, ProperDee said:

I don't mind some of your posts but to say that about Hogan is a non-supporter comment. He's regularly double teamed and been carrying a niggling injury for over a month. He played last Saturday still feeling the effects of illness. 

What's your excuse for being a [censored]?

Hogan has been a flat track bully his stats say it all. If he can play a good game in the last 3 weeks then I will change my mind, in our loses he has been poor. Needs to start holding his marks.

4 hours ago, It's Time said:

Barry Hall was never the same player after his shocker in the '06 GF. 

 

Maybe if he had punched a St Kilda player in the prelim that year, he would have played better ( or just punched a St Kilda player for fun )

"Flat track bully" is a ridiculous term to apply to Hogan. To suggest that he doesn't perform against top level opponents is misleading. He may be inconsistent... but he certainly has performed against the best. As for the weekend... he had a very important hand in the goal that sealed the deal, in spite of his physical issues... never gave up... brought the ball to ground throughout the tough contests in the final qtr.

1 hour ago, Moonshadow said:

Worth remembering that Sat night was Walker's first game back from injury.

Would benefit from slimming down over summer. Less weight and bigger tank

I' m thinking it was Walker's first game back from a one week suspension for whacking some guy.

l could be wrong. I have been wrong once before.

Do we really need a thread like this ? I for one think it's insulting to call any AFL footballer who goes out their week in week out and gives there all soft, while us armchair riders set back & have pot shots. 

Secondly why should we at all care about the way 2 Adelaide players go about it... We're on the verge of our 1st finals series in 12 years & were talking about this ?

Thirdly I just think it's poor taste to start a topic on opposition players like this, we've probably had dozens of players who could have been criticised over  last decade, be a little humble...

As a Dees supporter, I could care less about a team we won’t be playing again this year, let alone 2 of their players. I also don’t see the need to be disrespectful of the abilities of 2 players who have given great service to the crows. But that’s me. I’d rather worry about our own forward line and try and improve our goal to forward entry ratio. 

May is out flat track bully time for Hoges.

Tex was the best goal assist player in the AFL by a mile last year, and the year following he was 2nd. He's not your standard KPF. He's a very crafty forward general that makes things happen. A player who's creativity i want to see Hogan emulate as a roaming CHF. Injury has cruelled Tex this year, pretty unfair to call an individual soft when the game plan breaks into pieces on the big dance.

 

Rank	Player	Team	Games	Total
1	Taylor Walker	Adelaide	23	33
2	Robbie Gray	Port Adelaide	23	30
3	Dustin Martin	Richmond	25	29
				23

Edited July 30, 20187 yr by johndemonic

1 hour ago, david_neitz_is_my_dad said:

They actually did.

I mean in the future and they have to win it.

 

17 minutes ago, WERRIDEE said:

May is out flat track bully time for Hoges.

We get it. Now get back under your bridge. 

Edited July 30, 20187 yr by Ethan Tremblay

2 hours ago, Moonshadow said:

Worth remembering that Sat night was Walker's first game back from injury.

Would benefit from slimming down over summer. Less weight and bigger tank

It ain' his form in talking about.

 

1 hour ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

We get it. Now get back under your bridge. 

What's wrong with being known as flat track bullies? We should be known as flat track bullies, if we beat St.Kilda we would be. Better than we are usually chokers against bottom teams.

They got destroyed by O Mac and Frosty,  who should both take a lot of confidence from the game.

7 hours ago, It's Time said:

I was sitting in the cheer squad 6 rows back and got to have a close look at Jenkins and more significantly Oscar on Jenkins. Jenkins was rag dolling him early. Oscar couldn't match him one on one and was just knocked off his feet. Sitting there looking close up at him and Walker and Lynch and McGovern and Betts and seeing Oscar getting monstered so easily I was thinking early on this is daunting this forward line looks scary intimidating. But Oscar held Jenkins goalless and did enough in enough contests to negate his influence. Stats can be funny things. He only had 4 disposals but there's no stats for the amount of times he beat Jenkins punching the ball away and stopping him marking. They need a stat for that for stats to have any relevance for a backman's role.  Jetts only had 4 stats but you wouldn't have thought that either with his influence. 

On the other hand Frosty had the physical strength to take Tex on one on one and beat him and once he took off Tex didn't even try to catch him. Frosty has a very rare X factor with height, strength and speed. His decisions, brain fades and skill can be scary but I'm surprised he hasn't been given more of a go. He played a significant role in the win. I have no doubt there's at least two games we would have won if he'd been selected. 

I've been astounded that Frosty hadn't been given a run even with Lever in the team, his pace is x factor big time, closing speed, tacking, spoiling and can take a mark.

Has a bit of Micky Martin about him when he just slaps it on his boot (get out of my area style) but i can live with that.

Did Jenkins sign a deal worth 800k a couple of years ago???

If he did, he's a veerryyy clever footballer

Pretty embarrassing thread. You'd think that after the period we've been through there would be some humility in supporters. But no let's lay into 60 and 40 goals per year forwards who have achieved more than any of our current forwards have. 

I am not sure any AFL player is soft but Tex is directing his enegy in the wrong direction.

Footage and commentary from "On the Couch" tonight, Tex showed trying to bully and get stuck into Max with in your face finger pointing, bumping and shaping up especially when they were 20 points up. As Roos said Max ignored it all and calmly went about his business getting 66 hit outs and another BOG while Walker was huffing and puffing and going nowhere. He didn't fire a shot in the grand final and has been below par this season

4 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

May is out flat track bully time for Hoges.

 

5 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

Hogan has been a flat track bully his stats say it all. If he can play a good game in the last 3 weeks then I will change my mind, in our loses he has been poor. Needs to start holding his marks.

I don't know how to interpret these posts unless they're put in a best 22. Mind knocking up one for us? Just don't put Jesse at CHF.

2 minutes ago, A F said:

 

I don't know how to interpret these posts unless they're put in a best 22. Mind knocking up one for us? Just don't put Jesse at CHF.

 

Id love to see @WERRIDEE do a best 22 of the AFL's flat track bullys

Tex Walker surely the captain.

Edited July 30, 20187 yr by Petraccattack

5 hours ago, Neil Crompton said:

As a Dees supporter, I could care less about a team we won’t be playing again this year, let alone 2 of their players. I also don’t see the need to be disrespectful of the abilities of 2 players who have given great service to the crows. But that’s me. I’d rather worry about our own forward line and try and improve our goal to forward entry ratio. 

Maybe there can be a forum for General AFL talk to keep this stuff out of the MFC forum. 

Why do we need a thread like this? Seriously, stupidest topic ever. Outlandish sensationalism at best. 

The video in this link proves what an absolute [censored] Tex Walker is..

https://coupler.foxsports.com.au/api/v1/article/amp/afl/youve-got-to-back-it-up-taylor-walker-slammed-for-false-bravado-in-adelaides-loss-to-melbourne/news-story/79d73c4b7051f6ffda778905dac163cc?__twitter_impression=true

19 hours ago, KingSlayer33 said:

Fortunately that pick is looking worse with every win

And Adelaide’s 2nd round pick back to us is looking better with every one of their losses