My 3 word player analysis V StKilda

[joeboy 2,849]

Jones - age catching up

Viney - great when unburdened

Fritsch - was all class

Hogan - ten minute game

Harmes - played with heart

Brayshaw - prolific but wasteful 

Lewis - often a liability

Melksham - playing slow motion

T.McDonald - was probably injured

Neal-Bullen - an irrelevant player

Petracca - plenty of nothing

Tyson - a dumb player

Weideman - nothing to commend

Gawn - one man team

Hannan - devoid of ability

Hibberd - reduced to amateurish

Oliver - rarely found space

Petty - debut to forget

Salem - undisciplined and disappointing 

Smith - little to praise

Jetta - was still concussed

O.McDonald - was emphatically embarrassing 

 

[At the break of Gawn 3,590]

Agree on pretty much everything.

[Hardatit 13]

 Salem - Can kick Ball

[goodwindees 2,123]

Selection = Some pace please

I'm not saying we have much in this area but FCS time to roll the dice on anyone with a bit of toe.  Time for Baker, Stretch and last roll for Garlett.   

[Big Demon 197]

Hibberd - One man defence

Brayshaw - Abysmal by foot

 

[red&blue1982 252]

Disagree with a lot of

26 minutes ago, joeboy said:

Jones - age catching up

Viney - great when unburdened

Fritsch - was all class

Hogan - ten minute game

Harmes - played with heart

Brayshaw - prolific but wasteful 

Lewis - often a liability

Melksham - playing slow motion

T.McDonald - was probably injured

Neal-Bullen - an irrelevant player

Petracca - plenty of nothing

Tyson - a dumb player

Weideman - nothing to commend

Gawn - one man team

Hannan - devoid of ability

Hibberd - reduced to amateurish

Oliver - rarely found space

Petty - debut to forget

Salem - undisciplined and disappointing 

Smith - little to praise

Jetta - was still concussed

O.McDonald - was emphatically embarrassing 

 

Disagree with a lot of this.

Hibberd played well. Salem was good. Smith was good. Jones was good. Lewis made blunders, but his composure and skill was first class again.

 

[Dr.D 1,771]

i actually thought that nathan Jones was good. I thought him and gawn were standouts wih fritsch being serviceable. everyone else was disgusting. where was the defensive mindset? weak as p!$$

[billyblanks29 184]

Thought Petracca played better this week. Gawn was excellent. Clarity down on usual.

[Juicebox 628]

Nitpicking over individual performances is pointless after a game like todays.

 We got beat by a team that was better on the day.

That being said, Dom Tyson sucks.

[layzie 29,309]

Harsh on Hibbo. Never stopped working. The rest are probably right, maybe Salem and Smith were a little stiff as well. 

[Demon_spurs 1,690]

45 minutes ago, billyblanks29 said:

Thought Petracca played better this week. Gawn was excellent. Clarity down on usual.

BB29 I disagree about Petracca, disappears for loooong stretches of the game, then does something brilliant ( this is frustrating) This is the first time I reckon I think StK got it right by selecting McCartin

 

[Demon17 4,624]

58 minutes ago, billyblanks29 said:

Thought Petracca played better this week. Gawn was excellent. Clarity down on usual.

Re: Petracca.  You must be in a parallel universe, or I am. 

[Earl Hood 5,806]

1 hour ago, Demon17 said:

Re: Petracca.  You must be in a parallel universe, or I am. 

Interesting, is it about expectation based the Trac’s potential? I thought he battled on today and did some good things but yes he could not turn the game on it’s head. But I can’t remember him being responsible for an absolute howler whereas how many of our guys coughed up the ball with embarrassing errors? 

We all hope for more but today he put in, I thought. 

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 5,927]

Petracca is a Pretender. 

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 5,927]

Hold your heads up high Gawny, Fristchy and Hibbo.

3 out of 22 players says something doesnt it?

[jumbo returns 6,515]

53 minutes ago, Win4theAges said:

Hold your heads up high Gawny, Fristchy and Hibbo.

3 out of 22 players says something doesnt it?

Harmes ran his guts out - top four for mine

[rolling fog 1,146]

Joeboy - 95 percent agree

[davo 209]

6 hours ago, joeboy said:

Jones - age catching up

Viney - great when unburdened

Fritsch - was all class

Hogan - ten minute game

Harmes - played with heart

Brayshaw - prolific but wasteful 

Lewis - often a liability

Melksham - playing slow motion

T.McDonald - was probably injured

Neal-Bullen - an irrelevant player

Petracca - plenty of nothing

Tyson - a dumb player

Weideman - nothing to commend

Gawn - one man team

Hannan - devoid of ability

Hibberd - reduced to amateurish

Oliver - rarely found space

Petty - debut to forget

Salem - undisciplined and disappointing 

Smith - little to praise

Jetta - was still concussed

O.McDonald - was emphatically embarrassing 

 

disagree with Hibberd, thought he was best backman, agree about TMac and Nev, both shouldn't have played. And at the moment Hannan is a complete waste of space, Jeffy would have given a contest, this bloke is scared of contact!!!!

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 5,927]

48 minutes ago, jumbo returns said:

Harmes ran his guts out - top four for mine

Fair enough 4,?

[Dee tention 611]

Spreadless-Crumless-Paceless

Gawn-A-Star

Gawn-4-Captain

[Elegt 872]

tyson: first for delisting

[Demon3 2,541]

Pass Marks:

Gawn

Hibbo

Fritsch

Harmes

Viney

Brayshaw ** (was lazy with disposal - but tried)

That's it. Honestly, that is all i can find. i think Salem tried and others as well, but trying hard should be mandatory.

[beelzebub 22,269]

13 hours ago, jumbo returns said:

Harmes ran his guts out - top four for mine

And was a very effective spoiler ... unfortunately went better for StKilda than us !!

He might run lots....needs to think lots too

[jumbo returns 6,515]

1 hour ago, beelzebub said:

And was a very effective spoiler ... unfortunately went better for StKilda than us !!

He might run lots....needs to think lots too

He tried his guts out....better than 13 or 14 others

[Satyriconhome 9,993]

That comment on Jetta is your lowest amd most disgusting yet

He was not concussed, he had his lip split open