Who is going onto the Banner?

[Willmoy1947 4,085]

What about one position vacant each match day for a mystery pick by all after the round (with a time limit ,of course)....

[Demonland 72,155]

25 minutes ago, willmoy said:

What about one position vacant each match day for a mystery pick by all after the round (with a time limit ,of course)....

That seems like more work for me.

[Moonshadow 17,676]

Remove Jack. Nine remain. We are Ninethbourne

[Gorgoroth 12,947]

7 hours ago, Moonshadow said:

Remove Jack. Nine remain. We are Ninethbourne

Put the number 9 up there

[640MD 3,375]

9 hours ago, willmoy said:

What about one position vacant each match day for a mystery pick by all after the round (with a time limit ,of course)....

Don't knoiw much about the amount of work time or effort that goes into editing the banner,   but this is a good idea worth thinking about.

As another thought    what about a random change with a past player being seen on the banner   Barrassi,  Robbie, Greg Parkes, Ray Biffen, Crackers,  Jacko,     what an assortment of goodies  !!

[Deemented Are Go! 3,677]

How about having Goody on the banner? You know, get behind the coach, a bit of solidarity?

Crazy idea, I know......

[640MD 3,375]

To the Demonland   not trying to increase your work load,  don't know anything at all about IT design,  but it would be an interesting project    Good Luck

[Pennant St Dee 13,171]

Tmac Lewis Jetta Hibberd Jones Daisy Viney Clarry Trac Hunt

In that order from left to right based on 2017 apologies to Nibbler

[John Crow Batty 8,863]

Rather than a player of the week how about a player of the month? Acknowledges consistency and output.

[DV8 2,271]

On 10/18/2017 at 4:04 PM, Demonland said:

I was actually thinking about this this morning.

I will be changing the banner soon.

I'm not sure whether Lever gets a guernsey so soon.

No.

Only put players up who are killing it for the Dees. Not before.

The banner does not have to be full.  But has to have integrity to the cause.

Watts never deserved to be there. One season in 9, is a disgrace, and should not earn a spot up in lights.

potential should not be highlighted, until after it bears fruit.

[DV8 2,271]

4 hours ago, Gorgoroth said:

Put the number 9 up there

A spur, I like it.

[DV8 2,271]

1 hour ago, Pennant St Dee said:

Tmac Lewis Jetta Hibberd Jones Daisy Viney Clarry Trac Hunt

In that order from left to right based on 2017 apologies to Nibbler

The leadership group & 9th, plus the player of the month.

[rpfc 28,383]

4 hours ago, Deemented Are Go! said:

How about having Goody on the banner? You know, get behind the coach, a bit of solidarity?

Crazy idea, I know......

No. He has to earn it.

[Dee Dee 1,108]

14 hours ago, ProDee said:

No.

He gets in on merit.

It's not often that I choose to argue the point with people on this forum (too many big egos), however in this case I shall.

i can't remember an aboriginal player being represented on the banner ( if I'm incorrect I apologise, I can't of the top of my head remember every banner)) so I believe their contribution should be recognised. Now in my opinion that recognition should take the form this coming season of one of the teams very best players I.e. Neville Jetta. Even if Jetta was one of the teams journeymen I think it would be appropriate to have him or another player from the aboriginal community represented. It is a symbolic gesture and one that I believe would be appreciated by many people in the aboriginal (and wider) community: It represents inclusiveness.

If your sole criterion is merit, then Neville Jetta gets in. If the banner represented a broader view then he gets in for the above reasons as well. But of course merit was not the only factor driving who did or didn't get chosen for last seasons banner was it!

 

[Gorgoroth 12,947]

Race should have zero to do with it.

Same as Gender.

[chookrat 4,247]

On 18/10/2017 at 3:47 PM, CBDees said:

A day has passed since Jack Watts left the Club yet he remains on the Demonland Banner. Surely Jake Lever or Michael Hibberd or Clayton Oliver loom as the replacement? Who is it to be (and when)?

(Not sure how to do a poll.) ?

Tom Bugg

[In Harmes Way 7,766]

2 hours ago, DV8 said:

The leadership group & 9th, plus the player of the month.

Plus a picture of the 1964 premiership cup

with rust on it

Edited October 21, 2017 by small but forward

[Dee Dee 1,108]

47 minutes ago, Gorgoroth said:

Race should have zero to do with it.

Same as Gender.

But it does, and it has through history. Ask an aboriginal player about race and you'll get a different answer. 

[Gator 17,332]

1 hour ago, Dee Dee said:

It's not often that I choose to argue the point with people on this forum (too many big egos), however in this case I shall.

i can't remember an aboriginal player being represented on the banner ( if I'm incorrect I apologise, I can't of the top of my head remember every banner)) so I believe their contribution should be recognised. Now in my opinion that recognition should take the form this coming season of one of the teams very best players I.e. Neville Jetta. Even if Jetta was one of the teams journeymen I think it would be appropriate to have him or another player from the aboriginal community represented. It is a symbolic gesture and one that I believe would be appreciated by many people in the aboriginal (and wider) community: It represents inclusiveness.

If your sole criterion is merit, then Neville Jetta gets in. If the banner represented a broader view then he gets in for the above reasons as well. But of course merit was not the only factor driving who did or didn't get chosen for last seasons banner was it!

 

No worries.  We differ.

[Gorgoroth 12,947]

39 minutes ago, Dee Dee said:

But it does, and it has through history. Ask an aboriginal player about race and you'll get a different answer. 

Yes history shows that it has mattered, if you want to promote a change in this then of the whole MFC you put up players who have had a good year or we sponsor etc etc.

Nev should be there not because he is Aboriginal, but because he had a cracking year. Same as Oliver, Hibberd, Daisy, all had great years for the MFC and prob deserve a spot on the banner.

If you add a player simply due to race then we need a much bigger banner as why have an Aboriginal over some one with Italian background and so on. 

 

I understand and what you are trying to say, but for us as a society to move on we need to see all players (people) as equal. 

If Jetta, Garlett and JKH have great seasons next year then all 3 would deserve a spot. I’m against tokenism.

 

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,388]

It would have to be all the elite trainers wouldn't it.....

[Moonshadow 17,676]

1 hour ago, Gorgoroth said:

 

If Jetta, Garlett and JKH have great seasons next year then all 3 would deserve a spot. I’m against tokenism.

 

Different reason, but weren't Wagner and Hunt originally put on the banner not because of merit? Could also be argued the Watts didn't deserve a spot. Or that Daisy isn't as good a player in her own right as the others. I don't think Nev should get on only because he's Aboriginal, I believe he should be there on playing merit (tick) and for his support of players coming from indigenous backgrounds (tick).

If it's only on merit over the previous season I'd argue about 5 currently on the banner should be removed. Surely there is room for more than playing merit as selection criteria.

Edited October 21, 2017 by Moonshadow

[Demonland 72,155]

I've said this before but I created this site and in turn the banner as a fan. Who am I to be the arbiter of who "deserves" a spot? I'm simply a fan who puts on players I like or are popular at the time. I may choose them because I think they had a good year or because I sponsor them or because I've got a good photo of them facing the right way in the right pose. I know there will be criticism no matter who I ultimately choose and I do take all suggestions into consideration. Understand that sometimes players are left out because of the silliest of reasons and is not necessarily because of form, being deserving and certainly not to fill quotas of gender or ethnicity. The last would be insulting to the players especially if they were included for those reasons. 

[Pennant St Dee 13,171]

21 minutes ago, Demonland said:

I've said this before but I created this site and in turn the banner as a fan. Who am I to be the arbiter of who "deserves" a spot? I'm simply a fan who puts on players I like or are popular at the time. I may choose them because I think they had a good year or because I sponsor them or because I've got a good photo of them facing the right way in the right pose. I know there will be criticism no matter who I ultimately choose and I do take all suggestions into consideration. Understand that sometimes players are left out because of the silliest of reasons and is not necessarily because of form, being deserving and certainly not to fill quotas of gender or ethnicity. The last would be insulting to the players especially if they were included for those reasons. 

Well said Daisy got my vote not because of gender but because ee are a club AFL, AFLA & VFL. Daisy is a great representative on field and off. Jetta is in the same boat and he is an absolute champion of the club

[McQueen 17,864]

Make 4 or 5 banners, capturing all players (I’ll admit to having no idea how difficult this is) and cycle them over the year rather than having a single dedicated banner.

If not, I vote for Pedersen to be given a guernsey.