On 14/09/2017 at 8:28 PM, Ethan Tremblay said:

Will Garland retire?

 

On 15/09/2017 at 4:41 AM, Ethan Tremblay said:

 I think he will. 

When he’s not #Breakingtrades, he’s knowing who’s going to retire. 

Edited October 16, 20177 yr by Ethan Tremblay

made sense then, makes sense now

With Col Garland retired and everybody else on contract, it looks as if we're set to recruit four more players to fill our main list. Our last pick will be 47 - around the same place where we drafted Mitch Hannan last year so it looks like there's going to be a little more interest on draft night than there was last year.

I can tell you who will be delisted come the years end. 

Billy stretch. 

He is as useful as [censored] on a bull.

Maynard

Wagner

Vince 

Lewis 

stretch 

Kennedy Harris

keilty 

king

Neal bullen 

Johnstone 

harmes 

bugg

Goodwin 

Lol.

I’m a pretty critical supporter.

But this thread is just farkin ridiculous.

There's a few posters on here tonight who could use a good delisting.

16 minutes ago, Elegt said:

Maynard

Wagner

Vince 

Lewis 

stretch 

Kennedy Harris

keilty 

king

Neal bullen 

Johnstone 

harmes 

bugg

Goodwin 

You are having a tough night tonight aren’t you? So sorry mate, we can give you a hug next week at the game. Sounds like you need it. 

Minimum three to come off the list 

If Vince or Lewis (who has a year to run) retire there’d be two, plus JKH and DJ would struggle to hold their spot 

Some judicious pruning will definitely be required

6 minutes ago, Dee-licious said:

You are having a tough night tonight aren’t you? So sorry mate, we can give you a hug next week at the game. Sounds like you need it. 

mate what do you disagree with? none of those players are up to scratch 

Game plan is the problem not players. Richmond have many average players but clearly it doesn't matter.

34 minutes ago, Elegt said:

Maynard

Wagner

Vince 

Lewis 

stretch 

Kennedy Harris

keilty 

king

Neal bullen 

Johnstone 

harmes 

bugg

Goodwin 

You forgot Frost, Vanderberg and Makenna.  Agree with the rest

Edited April 24, 20187 yr by olisik

3 minutes ago, billyblanks29 said:

Game plan is the problem not players. Richmond have many average players but clearly it doesn't matter.

it's a mix of both, tigers actually have a fantastic list with great depth , were missing 3 players from the past week yet covered them fine, on the other hand we only have one player in the vfl putting his hand up selection who is a key forward in their 30s on their last legs, all the tigers players are quick yet the only fast players I can think of are frost garlett and hunt, we really need to draft better ball users and speedy players as the players we have now are not up to it in the modern game- which is built on quick ball movement and intense pressure, it really makes me wonder why we draft such slow players 

Just now, olisik said:

You forgot Frost

oh and Tyson my bad

1 hour ago, Elegt said:

Maynard

Wagner

Vince 

Lewis 

stretch 

Kennedy Harris

keilty 

king

Neal bullen 

Johnstone 

harmes 

bugg

Goodwin 

Maynard and King are developing so they will stay for another year.

Wagner won't be delisted.

I would hold onto Neal-Bullen and Harmes for depth.

Add Frost and I agree with the rest. 8 sounds like a good number for delistings.

I'll bite.

JKH

Stretch

Johnstone

Vandenberg

McKenna

 

6 hours ago, olisik said:

You forgot Frost, Vanderberg and Makenna.  Agree with the rest

Agree with the lot

Retire: Vince Lewis

Trade: Salem, Tyson

Delist: Bugg, JKH, Stretch,

I need to get up and do some work

Why the hell did I click on this thread for?

It’s a shorter list of WHO TO KEEP

Bernie Vince. I love the old Vince but he left at the beginning of last season. 

King- project player that has not worked out. 

McKenna - injury prone. 

Kennedy Harris - no hunger to play AFL. 

That is about it but we are not playing the right players either. Spargo, Fitsch and Balic will get an extended run now, as will Pedersen. 

Edited April 24, 20187 yr by Thehardtackler

2 hours ago, Big Carl said:

Retire: Vince Lewis

Trade: Salem, Tyson

Delist: Bugg, JKH, Stretch,

lol do you really think clubs would trade for Salem and Tyson? they're not stupid 

Salem and Tyson are two of our better players and automatic best 22

Unless we get a like for like replacement they’re going nowhere

FMD, think about list make up people

Lewis has a year to go; he’s not going to forego a year’s (very good) salary

Vince May retire or he may play on - he’s automatic best 22 for us, so why not get another year and decent pay out of his body?

McKenna and vandenBerg (and potentially Kent) don’t have the bodies to play afl

Maynard, JKH and DJ sadly don’t look up to it

And then it’s a matter of judicious trading; but if Salem and Tyson were parts of that conversation I’d be mighty surprised

10 minutes ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

Salem and Tyson are two of our better players and automatic best 22

Unless we get a like for like replacement they’re going nowhere

FMD, think about list make up people

Lewis has a year to go; he’s not going to forego a year’s (very good) salary

Vince May retire or he may play on - he’s automatic best 22 for us, so why not get another year and decent pay out of his body?

McKenna and vandenBerg (and potentially Kent) don’t have the bodies to play afl

Maynard, JKH and DJ sadly don’t look up to it

And then it’s a matter of judicious trading; but if Salem and Tyson were parts of that conversation I’d be mighty surprised

tyson: absolute butcher of the ball, poor 2 way running and refuses to man up, slower than gawn, has no left foot, gets caught holding the ball too often

salem: small, lacks pace, poor 2 way runner and gets beaten by his opponent too often, kicks get smothered frequently, not fit enough to play midfield, can' take a mark

vince: so slow, handballs to the ground, poor defensive skills, butcher's the ball

 

I would hardly say they're best 22

23 minutes ago, Elegt said:

lol do you really think clubs would trade for Salem and Tyson? they're not stupid 

Well why are they on our list??