2 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Salem might miss a few games after his hit on a player in the VFL, so this may not happen.

Was I also led to believe that Hogan is a chance next weekend as well?

Was Salem actually reported ?  I dont believe so.

11 minutes ago, Watts the matter said:

Lets not kid ourselves, StKilda were as bad as a I can remember a team in the 1st quarter.

Didn't watch Port Adelaide get done by 85 points in the wet last week, or Freo flogged by 100 points yesterday?

Saints didn't handle the pressure, but thats because we brought it. 

I can't handle the negativity around here at the moment. It's pathetic (and boring).

Just now, SFebey said:

OK thanks WB. Didnt someone say Salem would be ok and wasnt even reported?

Unsure about Hogan, but would be nice to have all 3 of those back. Pedo stays in, put him on a wing if need be, team plays better with him in it for whatever reason but as Clint said, Gawn forward and Pedo in ruck looks much more dangerous

You could be right there, I haven't looked at it since the Casey thread from yesterday where some were saying he could get 3-4 weeks.  I'd love him not to miss though!

This game was the perfect example of our season, its the reason why we are  7 and not top 4, we dont finish off teams, we don't  have a killer instinct.

3 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Salem might miss a few games after his hit on a player in the VFL, so this may not happen.

Was I also led to believe that Hogan is a chance next weekend as well?

I think we look better without Hogan.

How bout the quick clearance in the 4th was it clarrie when Hannan took that pack mark and dobbed it from 50. amazing what a quick long kick into 50 from a center clearance can do instead of the over using the handball.

Just now, Clint Bizkit said:

I think we look better without Hogan.

At the moment I can't help but agree.  Having said that, I think that's more out of the fact that he has missed so much footy and we've had to adapt to playing without him.  I'd rather him in the side than out (he would offer more than Weideman).

31 minutes ago, ProperDee said:

Great, gutsy win but these fade outs are causing my blood pressure no favours.  I would love to see us play 4 quarters of football without dropping off. We would be just about unbeatable.  

Weideman can go back to Casey.  Laid a couple of good tackles but at other times looked slow. Petracca is brilliant but I just wonder if he needs to leave his ego at home and just play footy.

i agreed Weed struggled? I imagjne Watts will come straight back in. Overall we were great apart from the 3rd qtr. As for Razor he needs a red and blue cracker up his arse!!!!!!

1 minute ago, don't make me angry said:

This game was the perfect example of our season, its the reason why we are  7 and not top 4, we dont finish off teams, we don't  have a killer instinct.

agreed and our forward 50 awareness isn't quiet there we don't kick enough easy goals our dominance demands especially that 1st quarter should have been 50pts up.

What a late season recruit BRAYSHAW is!!! Good football story and well done to him and his family

5 minutes ago, jumbo returns said:

CP5 is not far off a blinder

Maybe saving it for Collingwood again.

2 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

I think we look better without Hogan.

Disagree Clint. There were a number of times when a strong marking forward was lacking.

He would have put the icing on the cake.

The Carlton doctors will make sure Salem gets weeks!

Garletts form has been woeful - very droppable IMO. I also reckon Vince is cooked.

As old Teddy said - we stuck it right up em and as well finished off their season.Feels so good to have been the one to 

finally stuff them up. 

Just now, Lucifer's Hero said:

The Carlton doctors will make sure Salem gets weeks! months!

They won't go that easy on us, LH! 

Harmes may be coming of age. Had my doubts but all his AFL attributes were on show today. Yet to turn 22.

Pedo tends to get the boot after one average game. He deserves greater leniency because the average games are few and far between. If we do make finals, I want him in the side. 

Gus was the story of the day. He's gonna be a star. Nothing surer.

Just now, Win4theAges said:

agreed and our forward 50 awareness isn't quiet there we don't kick enough easy goals our dominance demands especially that 1st quarter should have been 50pts up.

A lot of the time we seem to be shooting ourselves in the foot, stuffing up some good chances that we've created. I'm all for the team-first mantra, but when you have the ball and are inside 50, back yourself in (you're an AFL footballer after all, you're meant to be good enough).

1 minute ago, chook fowler said:

Garletts form has been woeful - very droppable IMO. I also reckon Vince is cooked.

[censored] me chook, I thought Bernie played well.

Would you drop Weid for Lions game? I wouldn't, another game of AFL experience for him. Watts comes in a week later.

Edited August 13, 20178 yr by Cards13
Ffs toe thumbs

26 minutes ago, Mr Steve said:

53,000 people there today. 

Where were they all in the lean times?????

Tom McDonald back in defence gives me more confidence and straightens us up, Oscar, I had been critical but his year has been a great story of persistence. Hogan up forward, Salem and Watts back would be handy. Wagner goes out as does Weed and possibly Petracca for a rest? Garlett has had a tough few weeks personally, but he's allowed to, his year has been great. We need to thump Lions next week.

Just now, Bitter but optimistic said:

[censored] me chook, I thought Bernie played well.

Some of his decision making and kick outs were terrible and resulted in goals

Does Frost come back? I think T-Mac was very good in defence but could have used him forward.. Wagners dispoal was pretty woeful and he turned it over about as much as Frost. For me Frost has a bit more upside.

1 minute ago, Skin D said:

Where were they all in the lean times?????

20,000 free ticket giveaway's help