MATCH PREVIEW AND TEAM SELECTION - Round 13

[In Gawn we Trust 86]

37 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

I had high hopes for Kennedy.  But as you say, his tank is tiny and his disposal is questionable at best.  He's behind many players at the moment.

I agree but I'm not really sold on Neal-Bullen or Harmes either, I think Kennedy needs to get a game to prove his worth though as opposed to playing VFL every week. Although I understand he should be playing really well to get a call up, but reading about how he's going it doesn't really seem as though he can do much more

[Cards13 9,117]

 

10 hours ago, Wiseblood said:

This doesn't concern me too much this year, as I think we've proven that we have the capacity to run out games very well.  I think we are very fit and, if we come to play, then we can knock the Dogs off without too many worries.

The turning up to play from the opening minute is just the stumbling block at the minute.

 

9 hours ago, rjay said:

We came off the bye on Monday so I don't think it will be a factor this week.

The next 2 will be a bit tougher though...particularly flying to Perth and back.

Have said it in other threads but yea I don't get this mindset. Off a bye, played 1 game with a 6 day break. Fine we may have sore/injuries/better players available but should be no issue this week. Next 2 weeks it starts to wear a bit but again full time players, full time fitness staff. I don't recall Hawks, Swans, Cats resting star players, bottom 6 or mid tier players but otherwise best  players at coal face.

Haven't seen selection so may be proven wrong.

[binman 42,614]

Nice vote of confidence by the coaches naming omac in the starting 22. 

[Cards13 9,117]

1 hour ago, picket fence said:

Give me Ben Ken anyday over ANB and even Harmes

On 0 exposed form this season for BK, ridiculous statement as per usual. ANB has been a good solider after a slow start to season. Harmes has been in and out but until BK can get a run in the 1s no idea how you make a call like that.

[leave it to deever 17,511]

39 minutes ago, binman said:

Nice vote of confidence by the coaches naming omac in the starting 22. 

He deserved it. Best game ever from him on Monday. His disposal was perfect.

[leave it to deever 17,511]

Would be great to have Pedo up forward for at least half a game with Spencer in. A big solid forward was a glaring absence against pies.

ANB has improved dramatically so should remain.

Salem will get a game again.

If the spotlights on anyone.... its Jordan Lewis this weekend.

[Billy 2,521]

14 hours ago, The Stigga said:

Think this is a bridge too far, Dogs will be smarting, 6 day vs 10 day turnaround at Etihad...

 

 

We've just come off a 16 day break after the bye, won't be a factor

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Given the upcoming 6 day breaks and the breakneck speed of QB game... Must have been tempting to roll some changes through. Wagner and JKH particularly.

Watts got his hip jab and pre game ankle. 

[MudDogs Gawn Win.. someday 499]

3 hours ago, In Gawn we Trust said:

I agree but I'm not really sold on Neal-Bullen or Harmes either, I think Kennedy needs to get a game to prove his worth though as opposed to playing VFL every week. Although I understand he should be playing really well to get a call up, but reading about how he's going it doesn't really seem as though he can do much more

Not sold on Harmes? Did you watch the last two games with a blindfold?

[titan_uranus 24,970]

I'm tipping either no change or Spencer to come in for Harmes or ANB.

Changes will need to be made, win or lose, before the Perth trip next week though, given the 6 day breaks.

[Devil is in the Detail 883]

10 hours ago, leave it to deever said:

Would be great to have Pedo up forward for at least half a game with Spencer in. A big solid forward was a glaring absence against pies.

ANB has improved dramatically so should remain.

Salem will get a game again.

If the spotlights on anyone.... its Jordan Lewis this weekend.

Thought Vince was worse. He cost us at least two goals.

[In Gawn we Trust 86]

8 hours ago, Mud Dogs Gonna Win said:

Not sold on Harmes? Did you watch the last two games with a blindfold?

Two games out of how many? I think he's okay sometimes and don't get me wrong he has his good moments, I'm just not a fan of his decision making and disposal a lot of the time

[beelzebub 23,313]

10 hours ago, Billy said:

We've just come off a 16 day break after the bye, won't be a factor

There is no doubt they will be fresher. We won't be stuffed, i dont think anyone is suggesting that but they'll be fresh as a daisy.....fresher.

There's an uncomplicated reality here.

[old dee 23,770]

12 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

There is no doubt they will be fresher. We won't be stuffed, i dont think anyone is suggesting that but they'll be fresh as a daisy.....fresher.

There's an uncomplicated reality here.

We had come off a long break last week bb. Swings and round abouts for me. Good teams win in spite of these disadvantages. With Spenser in we have a 50/50 chance IMO.

[beelzebub 23,313]

Just now, old dee said:

We had come off a long break last week bb. Swings and round abouts for me. Good teams win in spite of these disadvantages. With Spenser in we have a 50/50 chance IMO.

Old im not noting it as a precursor to an excuse.

Im just stating what is.

Given we've yet to play 4 qtrs of footy i think it is relevant however.

[picket fence 17,034]

12 hours ago, Cards13 said:

On 0 exposed form this season for BK, ridiculous statement as per usual. ANB has been a good solider after a slow start to season. Harmes has been in and out but until BK can get a run in the 1s no idea how you make a call like that.

I reckon he will play! 

[old55 23,357]

I expect "No Change" because if Spencer comes in OMac goes out and he's named in the 18.

I expect Spencer to play in Perth next week and Max to resume against Sydney back here.

[poita 3,889]

Very underwhelming inclusions, so I expect to keep the same 22. Weideman is not ready, Kennedy is C-grade and Spencer's lack of athleticism would be exposed by the Bulldogs.

Having seen him at training last week, I would have preferred Max to play this week, have next week off if necessary, and play against Sydney the following week.

This will be a tough game, but I will be bitterly disappointed if we give up yet another big lead in the first half. I'm pretty sure we have been well behind in six consecutive games - that is not sustainable.

[FarNorthernD 5,861]

4 minutes ago, Fifty-5 said:

I expect "No Change" because if Spencer comes in OMac goes out and he's named in the 18.

I expect Spencer to play in Perth next week and Max to resume against Sydney back here.

Agree 55

If they didn't play Spence against the Pies with Grundy they are unlikely to play him on the fastest track in the league against a running side like the Bulldogs. 

[DemonWheels 1,055]

After watching the replay I'm thinking Melksham will drop back to Casey – noticed he turned it over a few times with very poor disposal. Checked the stats and they don't lie:
Disposals: 10
Disposal Efficiency: 40%

[DemonLad5 1,642]

5 minutes ago, DemonWheels said:

After watching the replay I'm thinking Melksham will drop back to Casey – noticed he turned it over a few times with very poor disposal. Checked the stats and they don't lie:
Disposals: 10
Disposal Efficiency: 40%

He did the job on Pendlebury and did very well, but if there's no role for him then I suspect he'll be the first one out

[Red and Bluebeard 2,083]

1 hour ago, beelzebub said:

There is no doubt they will be fresher. We won't be stuffed, i dont think anyone is suggesting that but they'll be fresh as a daisy.....fresher.

There's an uncomplicated reality here.

So they'll be as fresh as a daisy fresher --- does that make them fresher than a daisy cutter?

[DubDee 25,533]

I'd say no change. if spencer was in form he would come in but we would be weighing up whether an out of touch Spencer would add more than the current set up.  unfortunately for Speno I dont think he does.

For the trip to Perth next week id expect 3-4 changes to freshen up some runners

[beelzebub 23,313]

suspecting no change also

just put names on sheet to keep the pups honest I suspect

[Lucifers Hero 39,507]

Thanks to WCE win Bulldogs are now out of the 8.  Lose vs Demons and they will stay out of the 8 with only 6 wins and a % of =/< 100.

To make the 8 they will then need to win 6/7 of the last 10.  They play North, WCE, Adel, Carl, GCS, Ess, BL, GWS, PA, Hawth. Only a couple of gimmes there.  It helps that 6 of those are at Etihad.

Expect two very desperate teams.  Huge game for both: We win and we are a game and % ahead of 8th and 9th.  Bulldogs win and they get a game clear.

The classic 8 point game!

Edited June 16, 2017 by Lucifer's Hero