Jump to content


Recommended Posts

Posted

We've lauded the work of Jason Taylor & the recruiting team and love the regeneration of the club under PJ & Roos but what about our list management.

Last year we recruited an EFC player with possible sanctions hanging over him, unfortunately that decision left us one down on the list. Luckily we had a good run with injury & it didn't really hurt us.

We got rid of one problem child & took on another (the prince) who then retired leaving us again one down on the list...this one has hurt us.

We have a list deficiency & this is not a hindsight call.

It was obvious to many of us that we were light on in the ruck division.

Max was carrying the load but had been injury prone. Big Jake gives his all but was/is a battler and has also struggled with injury...we then had King who was recovering from a knee and had only played minutes at VFL level and recruited a kid who is not ready for VFL footy let alone AFL.

Our current ruck predicament was predictable and we didn't take out insurance. Someone like Minson would be very handy about now.

Being one list position short hasn't helped but also not using a rookie spot for insurance has hurt.

What also hasn't helped us is we don't have any tall key position players who could go into the ruck and give a contest.

Watts has battled manfully and many have called for Pedders to come and or Frost to take over. Watts 196cm, Pedders 193cm, Frost 194cm, Weid 195cm, Hogan 195cm, Tommy Mc 194cm....

The Dogs didn't need to use Minson as they had key position players in Boyd and Roughead at 200cm and another in Campbell.

A lot will point to a lack of outside run & class but I think we can cover that. To me we lack good adaptable talls...and insurance.

The luck is not running with us this year but we also haven't done ourselves any favours with list decisions.

 

 

 

 

  • Like 7

Posted

Agree with you. We punted on Max staying fit and having Jake as a backup if he didn't. Losing both in 3 weeks for long periods is just plain bad luck.

We are now in a very difficult position.

  • Like 1

Posted
20 minutes ago, rjay said:

We've lauded the work of Jason Taylor & the recruiting team and love the regeneration of the club under PJ & Roos but what about our list management.

Last year we recruited an EFC player with possible sanctions hanging over him, unfortunately that decision left us one down on the list. Luckily we had a good run with injury & it didn't really hurt us.

We got rid of one problem child & took on another (the prince) who then retired leaving us again one down on the list...this one has hurt us.

We have a list deficiency & this is not a hindsight call.

 

Of course it's a hindsight call, rjay.  If Gawn and Spencer stay healthy then we don't have this discussion.  They go down and suddenly we have 'gee, in hindsight, we're light on in the ruck division...'.

We have two established ruckmen on the list and two developing.  You can't plan for both established ruckmen to go down as they have.  We don't know if Minson would provide us anything more in this situation than, say, Sam Frost.  Minson couldn't get a run in a Dogs side that used key position players in the ruck instead.  That's pretty telling.

We just have to grin and bear it.  Our mids are going to need to work extra hard around the stoppages as we won't be getting first use often.

  • Like 4
Posted

We recruited Smith and Keilty as KPF insurance along with Pedersen.  We have four ruck men on our list.  I'm not sure a fifth would have provided the right list balance given that most sides only play one ruck man in the team.  The issue with our list is it's age/game profile.  We just need to get more games into our developing talls like Weideman, Oscar, Frost, McKenna, and Joel Smith (who I think could play CHB), You can throw Hogan in there too for a KPF that's only played two seasons of AFL.  

I agree re Lumumba and Melksham though... very odd recruitment decisions.  Most supporters (including from their original clubs) didn't rate them - why did we?  I think we win with Bernie and Hibberd.  I am ambivalent about Tyson though, does he wear contact lenses?

  • Like 2
Posted

To balance out your points you do need to look also at the impact of adding a player such as Minson to the list.   If Gawn and Spencer both don't get injured the player languishes at VFL level and potentially stymies the development of King and Filipovic.  I really think this is a case of extreme bad luck - including King getting injured.  Also think that while it is a bad situation there are plenty of options - Tom McDonald as a running ruckman and other ideas.

  • Like 3

Posted

The list management is fine. It would have been kind of the AFL to allow us an additional rookie when the prince retired, but we aren't Collingwood or Hawthorn so the AFL wasn't going to do us any favours.

Gawn, Spencer and King should be enough to compete. We are just unlucky King has been out for 12 months and has just come back, and to lose your first and second ruck in 3 weeks is just cruel. You just can't plan for that. No club can.

Posted (edited)
12 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Of course it's a hindsight call, rjay.  If Gawn and Spencer stay healthy then we don't have this discussion.  They go down and suddenly we have 'gee, in hindsight, we're light on in the ruck division...'.

We have two established ruckmen on the list and two developing.  You can't plan for both established ruckmen to go down as they have.  We don't know if Minson would provide us anything more in this situation than, say, Sam Frost.  Minson couldn't get a run in a Dogs side that used key position players in the ruck instead.  That's pretty telling.

We just have to grin and bear it.  Our mids are going to need to work extra hard around the stoppages as we won't be getting first use often.

Disagree, there were a few on here that were concerned about a ruck deficiency before the start of the season.

That's not hindsight, it's foresight and what our list management people are paid for.

...and as I pointed out, our lack of height around the ground means we don't have the luxury of using KPP in the ruck. Watts at 196cm is our tallest KPP.

As 'Red' says, we took a punt and it came unstuck.

 

 

Edited by rjay
  • Like 9
Posted

Managing the ruck component of a list is a constant tightrope nowadays with high mid rotations and no spare spot on the bench for a #2. If your back-up is good enough as a back-up he'll want games and be lured elsewhere - an issue compounded by the time it takes to develop a ruck in-house. You need a second ruck with a second discipline and then an insurance ruck in the waiting.

  • Like 1

Posted (edited)

The rookie draft was the perfect opportunity to grab a mature age ruckman which i was crossing my fingers for.

I was pretty disappointed that we went down the pathway of grabbing another skinny project ruckman who had only played 12 months of footy. This is nothing against young Filipovic who i think is a fine young man, but he is 5 years away from at least making any sort of contribution at AFL level. Right now he is playing development league football.

Even young Oscar Mcinerney would have been an ideal selection (currently playing well in the NEAFL for Brissy) as that mature age ruckman.

I few on here last year voiced this exact concern as some didn't see Spencer as an ideal back up. 

 

 

Edited by dazzledavey36
  • Like 3
Posted
3 minutes ago, Adzman said:

The list management is fine. It would have been kind of the AFL to allow us an additional rookie when the prince retired, but we aren't Collingwood or Hawthorn so the AFL wasn't going to do us any favours.

Gawn, Spencer and King should be enough to compete.We are just unlucky King has been out for 12 months and has just come back, and to lose your first and second ruck in 3 weeks is just cruel. You just can't plan for that. No club can.

It was a known fact that King was injured so of course you can plan for that.

  • Like 1

Posted
2 minutes ago, rjay said:

Disagree, there were a few on here that were concerned about a ruck deficiency before the start of the season.

That's not hindsight, it's foresight and what our list management people are paid for.

...and as I pointed out, our lack of height around the ground means we don't have the luxury of using KPP in the ruck. Watts at 196cm is our tallest KPP.

As 'Red' says, we took a punt and it came unstuck.

 

It's only foresight as both have gone down injured.  I can understand a few being slightly worried before the season, but it isn't something I'd call foresight.  Again, if it doesn't happen then it isn't an issue.  

And for the record, I still don't see it as an issue.  We could have a third ruckman thrust into the game next week who does down injured in the first 5 minutes.  What then?  Same scenario.

  • Like 1
Posted

We don't have a player who can play the forward/ruck role effectively. This was spoken about last year & it's why we are still talking about Watts & Pederson to fill in. If we had addressed it at least we'd have some back up now.

The ruck/forward role is a little bit of a wasted position as it's rare to find a quality player for that role. The example being Hawthorn recruiting Hale & then Vickery to replace him. Who would we have traded in?

We've got other issues at the moment still, not enough good kicks but a lot of inside ball winners. We need to find a balance.

  • Like 1
Posted
15 minutes ago, Jaded said:

How many teams have 3 mature experienced rucks on their list?

We are unlucky but we are not dumb. 

Depends what you define as 'mature'.

I would say we would have one of the thinnest ruck stocks within the AFL. 

 

  • Like 2
Posted
32 minutes ago, Jaded said:

How many teams have 3 mature experienced rucks on their list?

We are unlucky but we are not dumb. 

Meth Coast have Nic Nat, Lycett & Petrie out injured. They are now going with Vardy and Giles

  • Like 5

Posted

Part of the reason why I just don't think we're ready for finals. We have gaps around the place and find ourselves plugging holes and then creating new ones elsewhere. We need Weeds

Posted
41 minutes ago, Bonkers said:

We don't have a player who can play the forward/ruck role effectively. This was spoken about last year & it's why we are still talking about Watts & Pederson to fill in. If we had addressed it at least we'd have some back up now.

The ruck/forward role is a little bit of a wasted position as it's rare to find a quality player for that role. The example being Hawthorn recruiting Hale & then Vickery to replace him. Who would we have traded in?

We've got other issues at the moment still, not enough good kicks but a lot of inside ball winners. We need to find a balance.

Agree.  Fwd-Ruck was the option.  Vardy and Darcy Cameron were available to us at the Hannan and Johnstone picks.

Posted
17 minutes ago, Pennant St Dee said:

Meth Coast have Nic Nat, Lycett & Petrie out injured. They are now going with Vardy and Giles

Nic Nat was injured before the season started. We'd have drafted more ruckman if Gawn was too.


Posted
19 minutes ago, praha said:

Part of the reason why I just don't think we're ready for finals. We have gaps around the place and find ourselves plugging holes and then creating new ones elsewhere. We need Weeds

I thought I saw some TAC video of Weideman rucking in the forward 50?

Posted
26 minutes ago, Pennant St Dee said:

Meth Coast have Nic Nat, Lycett & Petrie out injured. They are now going with Vardy and Giles

Nic Nat and Lycett were already injured and projected to be out most of the season.  Our two ruckmen were super fit.  Big difference.

Posted

I have posted on several occasions over the last 6 years for the "Spencer experiment" to be finalised.  Minson isn't the answer but even he was best on against Spud Spencer in VFL GF 7 months ago. 

 

Posted
4 minutes ago, M_9 said:

I thought I saw some TAC video of Weideman rucking in the forward 50?

Ultimately Weed needs to ruck relief but he's a couple of years off it.

Posted (edited)

Have to agree with rjay.  It is not hindsight by posters.  It was discussed at length during the trade/draft period on DL. 

There are several parts to our list management dilemma re ruckmen:  

1) It is known that the more successful clubs have at least 3 ruckman eg Hawks, Syd, WCE. ready to play at AFL level and usually 1 developing ruckman.

2) It is known that those that don't have 3 do have (and each week select) a starting 22 player who is a backup ruckman.  Think Boyd, Lobb. Jenkins. Blicvat. 

We don't have either so we are not protected during a game nor if our 2 main ruckman are out medium term with injuries. 

3) We know that Spencer is an FA on a one year contract, expiring this year.  So no guarantee of his tenure.  So next year we may be down to 1 ruckman if Spencer exercises his FA rights.  Probable, I don't know but certainly possible. 

4) We know that King (21yo) and Filipovic (18yo) are babies in ruckman terms and some way from any AFL football let alone holding down a regular AFL ruck role - probably, 3 to 4 years away.

Clearly the strategy was to make Watts the game day backup ruckman.  Already we can see the folly of that.  Firstly, he is not built for the role like Boyd, Lobb etc.  Secondly, Jack rucking leaves a gaping whole in our forward line as we are left with one tall forward (ala Geelong, Richmond) and it has cost us two games.

Yes injuries cannot be foreseen but blind freddy could see our ruck stocks for the next 3/4 years were/are thread bare.  

So no, it is not hindsight.  And yes, it is a huge problem. 

Our list management re ruckman was a roll of the dice, we lost.  But it needn't have been this way.  It was very foreseeable. 

I have heard it said that while list management decisions are a team effort, trading of players is largely the coaches call to fill a short/medium term need.  The drafting of players (especially at the pointy end) is primarily the domain of recruiting to build a balanced long-term list. 

Somewhere along the line in 2016 we misjudged our ruck stocks for the short/medium term.

Edited by Lucifer's Hero
  • Like 8
Posted
22 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

 

So no, it is not hindsight.  And yes, it is a huge problem. 

 

Yes, it is hindsight, but I've said that enough.  I won't change anybodies mind.

And it's only a problem now as we've had injuries.  If Gawn goes through the year as is AA ruckman again, which he would have done, then nobody cares about the ruck situation.  

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Demonland Forums  

  • Match Previews, Reports & Articles  

    TRAINING: Friday 22nd November 2024

    Demonland Trackwatchers were out in force on a scorching morning out at Gosch's Paddock for the final session before the whole squad reunites for the Preseason Training Camp. DEMONLAND'S PRESEASON TRAINING OBSERVATIONS It’s going to be a scorcher today but I’m in the shade at Gosch’s Paddock ready to bring you some observations from the final session before the Preseason Training Camp next week.  Salem, Fritsch & Campbell are already on the track. Still no number on Campbell’s

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Training Reports 2

    UP IN LIGHTS by Whispering Jack

    Those who watched the 2024 Marsh AFL National Championships closely this year would not be particularly surprised that Melbourne selected Victoria Country pair Harvey Langford and Xavier Lindsay on the first night of the AFL National Draft. The two left-footed midfielders are as different as chalk and cheese but they had similar impacts in their Coates Talent League teams and in the National Championships in 2024. Their interstate side was edged out at the very end of the tournament for tea

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Special Features

    TRAINING: Wednesday 20th November 2024

    It’s a beautiful cool morning down at Gosch’s Paddock and I’ve arrived early to bring you my observations from today’s session. DEMONLAND'S PRESEASON TRAINING OBSERVATIONS Reigning Keith Bluey Truscott champion Jack Viney is the first one out on the track.  Jack’s wearing the red version of the new training guernsey which is the only version available for sale at the Demon Shop. TRAINING: Viney, Clarry, Lever, TMac, Rivers, Petty, McVee, Bowey, JVR, Hore, Tom Campbell (in tr

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Training Reports

    TRAINING: Monday 18th November 2024

    Demonland Trackwatchers ventured down to Gosch's Paddock for the final week of training for the 1st to 4th Years until they are joined by the rest of the senior squad for Preseason Training Camp in Mansfield next week. WAYNE RUSSELL'S PRESEASON TRAINING OBSERVATIONS No Ollie, Chin, Riv today, but Rick & Spargs turned up and McDonald was there in casual attire. Seston, and Howes did a lot of boundary running, and Tom Campbell continued his work with individual trainer in non-MFC

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Training Reports

    2024 Player Reviews: #11 Max Gawn

    Champion ruckman and brilliant leader, Max Gawn earned his seventh All-Australian team blazer and constantly held the team up on his shoulders in what was truly a difficult season for the Demons. Date of Birth: 30 December 1991 Height: 209cm Games MFC 2024: 21 Career Total: 224 Goals MFC 2024: 11 Career Total: 109 Brownlow Medal Votes: 13 Melbourne Football Club: 2nd Best & Fairest: 405 votes

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 12

    2024 Player Reviews: #36 Kysaiah Pickett

    The Demons’ aggressive small forward who kicks goals and defends the Demons’ ball in the forward arc. When he’s on song, he’s unstoppable but he did blot his copybook with a three week suspension in the final round. Date of Birth: 2 June 2001 Height: 171cm Games MFC 2024: 21 Career Total: 106 Goals MFC 2024: 36 Career Total: 161 Brownlow Medal Votes: 3 Melbourne Football Club: 4th Best & Fairest: 369 votes

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 5

    TRAINING: Friday 15th November 2024

    Demonland Trackwatchers took advantage of the beautiful sunshine to head down to Gosch's Paddock and witness the return of Clayton Oliver to club for his first session in the lead up to the 2025 season. DEMONLAND'S PRESEASON TRAINING OBSERVATIONS Clarry in the house!! Training: JVR, McVee, Windsor, Tholstrup, Woey, Brown, Petty, Adams, Chandler, Turner, Bowey, Seston, Kentfield, Laurie, Sparrow, Viney, Rivers, Jefferson, Hore, Howes, Verrall, AMW, Clarry Tom Campbell is here

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Training Reports

    2024 Player Reviews: #7 Jack Viney

    The tough on baller won his second Keith 'Bluey' Truscott Trophy in a narrow battle with skipper Max Gawn and Alex Neal-Bullen and battled on manfully in the face of a number of injury niggles. Date of Birth: 13 April 1994 Height: 178cm Games MFC 2024: 23 Career Total: 219 Goals MFC 2024: 10 Career Total: 66 Brownlow Medal Votes: 8

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 3

    TRAINING: Wednesday 13th November 2024

    A couple of Demonland Trackwatchers braved the rain and headed down to Gosch's paddock to bring you their observations from the second day of Preseason training for the 1st to 4th Year players. DITCHA'S PRESEASON TRAINING OBSERVATIONS I attended some of the training today. Richo spoke to me and said not to believe what is in the media, as we will good this year. Jefferson and Kentfield looked big and strong.  Petty was doing all the training. Adams looked like he was in rehab.  KE

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Training Reports
  • Tell a friend

    Love Demonland? Tell a friend!

×
×
  • Create New...