Rock, Paper, Scissors

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Melbourne lost to Essendon
Essendon got smashed by St.Kilda
Melbourne threw away a win to StKilda by 2 points

Melbourne beat Richmond
Richmond beat Collingwood, Freo and Sydney

Melbourne beat Bulldogs
Bulldogs beat West Coast, Richmond and Sydney

My point? That it seems logical to despair and say 'OMG how did we lose to THEM?' but the fact is that footy, more than ever, is a game of one side matching up on another on a given day, and the past performances of side A vs side B has a limited bearing on side A vs C - because the injuries/selections/matchups, gameplans/strageies and heart/psychological state varies between opponents, and even between the same opponent on differing weeks of footy.

Might seem obvious, but it's just a thought I had that made me feel a tiny bit better, and I hope it does for you too.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Melbourne lost to Essendon

Essendon got smashed by St.Kilda

Melbourne threw away a win to StKilda by 2 points

Melbourne beat Richmond

Richmond beat Collingwood, Freo and Sydney

Melbourne beat Bulldogs

Bulldogs beat West Coast, Richmond and Sydney

My point? That it seems logical to despair and say 'OMG how did we lose to THEM?' but the fact is that footy, more than ever, is a game of one side matching up on another on a given day, and the past performances of side A vs side B has a limited bearing on side A vs C - because the injuries/selections/matchups, gameplans/strageies and heart/psychological state varies between opponents, and even between the same opponent on differing weeks of footy.

Might seem obvious, but it's just a thought I had that made me feel a tiny bit better, and I hope it does for you too.

[monoccular 17,642]

Nope - sorry. Nothing makes me feel even just a little bit better after losing to the drug cheats on Saturday.

I doubt that I will ever believe or trust our team again.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Nope - sorry. Nothing makes me feel even just a little bit better after losing to the drug cheats on Saturday.

I doubt that I will ever believe or trust our team again.

agreed. i find i can't even read or listen to the post-match stuff properly. I just post smart ass gifs/things every now and then so people know i'm still here.

Edited July 14, 2015 by The Song Formerly Known As

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

What the past two posters have conveniently forgotten is that our mood(s) were considerably different two weeks ago when we pulled off what was thrown around as the 'win of the decade' at the Cattery. We sucked this week, and it hurt - but what it says about our long term future is not in any way conclusive.

[Nasher 33,617]

What the past two posters have conveniently forgotten is that our mood(s) were considerably different two weeks ago when we pulled off what was thrown around as the 'win of the decade' at the Cattery. We sucked this week, and it hurt - but what it says about our long term future is not in any way conclusive.

This should come as no surprise, really, it's well documented that footy supporters can only remember the last thing that happened. You see it within games ("if we win, I'll never post here again" oh look, we won), within years ("can't see us winning another game this year" oh look, we won the next week, make that "pencil us in to win every other game except Freo"), and across seasons ("this is even worse than the Neeld era.". No guys, nothing will ever be worse than the Neeld era).

[old dee 24,003]

This should come as no surprise, really, it's well documented that footy supporters can only remember the last thing that happened. You see it within games ("if we win, I'll never post here again" oh look, we won), within years ("can't see us winning another game this year" oh look, we won the next week, make that "pencil us in to win every other game except Freo"), and across seasons ("this is even worse than the Neeld era.". No guys, nothing will ever be worse than the Neeld era).

186?

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

Would Dean Bailey have done any worse with our team than what Roos did?? I doubt it.

[Nasher 33,617]

186?

It was the worst score old dee, but it was isolated and somewhat exceptional circumstance due to the toxic goings-on off the field. For mine it was the catalyst for the wheels falling off, but not the actual worst moment of the whole saga with the reflection of hindsight.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Would Dean Bailey have done any worse with our team than what Roos did?? I doubt it.

Dean Bailey won us 8 games in a season once.

[old dee 24,003]

Dean Bailey won us 8 games in a season once.

and a draw.

Seems like heaven after the last five.

[SaberFang 7,151]

186 was the wheels falling off. Neeld was the car crusher. Roos signed on in 2013 and Jackson presented him with his team:

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

and a draw.

Seems like heaven after the last five.

i'd take it currently. But that says more about my dismay for my clubs onfield effort on the weekend than it does for common sense.

Although our off-field was in far, worse shape back then.

Edited July 14, 2015 by The Song Formerly Known As

[beelzebub 23,390]

Interesting

The premise of the op boils down to it all about the day( one team v whoever) I agree.

On most days we seem to play sub par.. thats the problem . Simple as that

Edited July 14, 2015 by beelzebub

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

interesting that you try to throw a positive bone out there, a bone that clearly has merit-rich meat on it, but some are so firlmly entrenched in their misery that they refuse to even nibble

I don't blame you

Just trying to help

[beelzebub 23,390]

C and B . You choose a perspective. I see another.

Btw..weve won how many ?...more the point really is how many games have we found a path to defeat when seemingly marching to victory.

Facts are most inconvenient often.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

C and B . You choose a perspective. I see another.

Btw..weve won how many ?...more the point really is how many games have we found a path to defeat when seemingly marching to victory.

Facts are most inconvenient often.

Did we, or did we not, beat Richmond, Bulldogs and Geelong (and lose to the Saint by 2 points in ridiculous circumstances)?

Seems to me that this is evidence for the defense in the case of 'do we stink or not'?

Others choose to discard it as information non-pertinent to the narrative they have going

[beelzebub 23,390]

Which is it...you either wish to curry your narrative with the nonsense of roundabout winability, which you rightly discard or reintroduce it if suits.

The correct analysis is we have won few games despite nearly winning more but finding a way to lose.

There is nothing of that stance to defend as such for its simply the truth.

We are currently as bad as the ladder describes.

The scoreboard is the one stat that cant lie nor can it really distort for it is what it is....the barometer of the particular contest.

You either win or you lose. We do more of the latter.

As is quipped; the more things change, the more they stay the same.

Must have been authored by a Melbourne supporter!

[dee-luded 2,959]

186 was the wheels falling off. Neeld was the car crusher. Roos signed on in 2013 and Jackson presented him with his team:

Like him or not,,, I would call Neeld the Chaff Cutter. he started the cull in earnest, that has helped Roosy continue the sorting, sifting, & the teaching.

prior to Neeld, our list consisted of :-

2012 season squad

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_Melbourne_Football_Club_season#2012_squad

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Like him or not,,, I would call Neeld the Chaff Cutter. he started the cull in earnest, that has helped Roosy continue the sorting, sifting, & the teaching.

prior to Neeld, our list consisted of :-

2012 season squad

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_Melbourne_Football_Club_season#2012_squad

as a side note, I count TWENTY SEVEN on that list who have either disappeared forever or gone to other clubs for modest-at-best returns

of those 27, I count a grand total of ONE who has actually done any damage

that would be stefan martin

26 out of 27 correct calls it would seem

remember that, whingers, next time Martin plays a good game

don't forget to mention the other 26 when you have your whinge

[dazzledavey36 55,886]

What i have notice this year is probably how even this comp is atm. Every game this year deep down i think to myself we can win any game just a matter of 4 qtr effort like Geelong.

Anywho carry on..

[dee-luded 2,959]

as a side note, I count TWENTY SEVEN on that list who have either disappeared forever or gone to other clubs for modest-at-best returns

of those 27, I count a grand total of ONE who has actually done any damage

that would be stefan martin

26 out of 27 correct calls it would seem

remember that, whingers, next time Martin plays a good game

don't forget to mention the other 26 when you have your whinge

even Steph, would be a correct decision, I'm sorry to say. he had his issues when with us, & he needed a change it seems to get himself back ontrack.

Our culture was so sick, nothing could brow well.

we are well thru a total cleanout; of players, that carried the bug... next we need a clean sweep & diss-infect of lockers, walls, ceilings, property room, medical room, board room (done, apparently), & our staff need inoculation, against that soft complacent Virus. that takes us down every 12 - 15 yearly cycle.

[John Dee 445]

Essendon did not beat us, we beat ourselves.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Essendon did not beat us, we beat ourselves.

can we...uh...please...stop...beating ourselves...then...? Why can't we stop beating ourselves...

[Moonshadow 17,678]

Whichever way i keep looking at it, the loss to Ess was awful. I paint it a different colour and it still looks shite. I dress it in different clothing and it remains weak. Try and treat it in an alternate context, yet we have not improved in years. Rock, paper, scissors? I see not much else but bitter defeat. Where's that kitchen knife.......