MFC injury list - 2015

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Jetta, Lumumba, Tyson

What a year these boys have all had

[bing181 9,240]

Interesting we have gone from 12 players injured around about round 4 through to round 16 or so when we dropped down to 6 injured for a short while, then it is now back to 9.

Biggest issue I feel is not just players out per se, but the lack of team stability. Even given the players available, the constant changes in personnel are not helping.

Doesn't help the players either. Fitzpatrick and Toumpas (OK, OK) have both been in and out of Casey - whatever they might become, neither we nor they are going to find out if they can't string a decent run of matches together.

[Jaded No More 68,920]

Jetta is the number one sufferer of the old "let's all compete for the same mark, fall over and get injured"

[Earl Hood 6,086]

Biggest issue I feel is not just players out per se, but the lack of team stability. Even given the players available, the constant changes in personnel are not helping.

Doesn't help the players either. Fitzpatrick and Toumpas (OK, OK) have both been in and out of Casey - whatever they might become, neither we nor they are going to find out if they can't string a decent run of matches together.

Bing I have said earlier we have played at around 60% of our potential man power all year as many of the injured this year would be rated top 25 on our list. But I am not sure basic man power available explains some of our lame performances this year.

However if we had an injury free year in 2016 things could look up very quickly assuming the entire list undergoes psychotherapy pre season.

[daisycutter 29,616]

Bing I have said earlier we have played at around 60% of our potential man power all year as many of the injured this year would be rated top 25 on our list. But I am not sure basic man power available explains some of our lame performances this year.

However if we had an injury free year in 2016 things could look up very quickly assuming the entire list undergoes psychotherapy pre season.

i believe lobotomies all round have been scheduled post season to avoid players over thinking. this should simplify their decision making by ensuring the first option is the only option

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,777]

i believe lobotomies all round have been scheduled post season to avoid players over thinking. this should simplify their decision making by ensuring the first option is the only option

I think your timing might be wrong. I have a sneaking suspicion the lobotomies might have already occurred.

[TGR 1,367]

Just been to the club and spoke to Webber and the Medicos and another Cert III personal trainer, and have come up with an updated injury list...

Jeremy Howe (hamstring) test
Jayden Hunt (back) 2 weeks
Dean Kent (heel) test
Alex Neal-Bullen (knee) 3-4 weeks
Christian Petracca (knee) season
Jack Trengove (foot) indefinite
Bernie Vince (hamstring) test

Paul Roos (ego) 3 weeks

Paul Gardner (relevance deprivation syndrome) 8 years

MFC staff (depression) 4 years

Nathan Jones (introversion) 2 years

Paleo (joke) life

Supporters (heart transplant) 2 years

Culture (premature) 3 years

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Why put a player on an injury list if they are "available"?

I've never understood this.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,777]

Why put a player on an injury list if they are "available"?

I've never understood this.

To leave open the Mystery Injury of the Week option for every player not listed?

[old dee 23,792]

Does anyone have the faintest idea what the problem is with Frost's toe?

He has been 2 -3 weeks now for 4 months.

Do we have another Clark / Trengove problem here?

[daisycutter 29,616]

Does anyone have the faintest idea what the problem is with Frost's toe?

He has been 2 -3 weeks now for 4 months.

Do we have another Clark / Trengove problem here?

hard not to think otherwise, od

but then i'm just a veil of negativity

[old dee 23,792]

hard not to think otherwise, od

but then i'm just a veil of negativity

Well it is good dc that we are now realising it.

Perhaps we should review all our comments over the last two weeks that we think could possibly have de motivated the players and deleted them.

Would that help do you think?

Nah bull s-it.

[ManDee 7,150]

If you are feeling negative take a look at Geelongs injury list, that will make you feel better.

GEELONG Player Injury Estimated Return

Sam Blease Concussion 1 week

Josh Caddy Knee Test

Mitch Clark Calf TBC

Cameron Delaney Knee TBC

Mitch Duncan Calf Test

James Kelly Ankle Test

Lincoln McCarthy* Foot Indefinite

Jared Rivers Knee Season

Rhys Stanley Foot Season

Sorry to see Rivers on list but at least it is at Geelong

[deanox 9,924]

Why put a player on an injury list if they are "available"?

I've never understood this.

Because he was out injured this week but is now available.

I think it is so that payers don't just drop off the list and then everyone asks questions.

[old dee 23,792]

Because he was out injured this week but is now available.

I think it is so that payers don't just drop off the list and then everyone asks questions.

Then how come that has not been done with Frost.

He has disappeared from view. 2-3 weeks on one report then nothing.

Missing without a trace

[TGR 1,367]

If you are feeling negative take a look at Geelongs injury list, that will make you feel better.

GEELONG Player Injury Estimated Return

Sam Blease Concussion 1 week

Josh Caddy Knee Test

Mitch Clark Calf TBC

Cameron Delaney Knee TBC

Mitch Duncan Calf Test

James Kelly Ankle Test

Lincoln McCarthy* Foot Indefinite

Jared Rivers Knee Season

Rhys Stanley Foot Season

Sorry to see Rivers on list but at least it is at Geelong

I have thought Josh Caddy and Mitch Duncan are grossly overrated, especially Caddy. He looks like Tarzan and his impact and decision-making in big games is average.

Kelly is over the hill.

Lincoln who?

Rivers has been playing on one knee since his Melbourne days.

The only player that would genuinely impact them is Stanley, who with Blicavs, has become part of the new age unpredictable quick ruck set up of the AFL.

Our injury list is chalk and cheese. Petracca, Frost, Kent would give us so much of what we need.

[deanox 9,924]

Then how come that has not been done with Frost.

He has disappeared from view. 2-3 weeks on one report then nothing.

Missing without a trace

Hey i didn't say the system was perfect!

But that extra information does allow us to differentiate between a player who leaves the list and is now available and a player like frost.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Because he was out injured this week but is now available.

I think it is so that payers don't just drop off the list and then everyone asks questions.

I just would have thought not being on the injury list means a player is not injured.

[ManDee 7,150]

I have thought Josh Caddy and Mitch Duncan are grossly overrated, especially Caddy. He looks like Tarzan and his impact and decision-making in big games is average.

Kelly is over the hill.

Lincoln who?

Rivers has been playing on one knee since his Melbourne days.

The only player that would genuinely impact them is Stanley, who with Blicavs, has become part of the new age unpredictable quick ruck set up of the AFL.

Our injury list is chalk and cheese. Petracca, Frost, Kent would give us so much of what we need.

TGR I highlighted the MFC players on the list, that was my point. (3 exMFC all injured)

I agree with your analysis though.

[ManDee 7,150]

Does anyone have the faintest idea what the problem is with Frost's toe?

He has been 2 -3 weeks now for 4 months.

Do we have another Clark / Trengove problem here?

From GRRM Training report -Absent: Trengove, Lumumba, Vanders, Bail, Frost, Kent, Fitzpatrick, Howe, Hunt

What is the story with Frost? Not injured & not training?

Edited August 27, 2015 by ManDee

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,777]

From GRRM Training report -Absent: Trengove, Lumumba, Vanders, Bail, Frost, Kent, Fitzpatrick, Howe, Hunt

What is the story with Frost? Not injured & not training?

Picked on the bench for Casey seconds this week.

[Chelly 810]

Melbourne injury list: final round

Angus Brayshaw (rested) – available

Chris Dawes (ankle) – test

Jack Fitzpatrick (concussion) – available

James Harmes (rested) – available

Jayden Hunt (back) – test

Nathan Jones (ankle) – test

Heritier Lumumba (ankle) – season

Jordie McKenzie (concussion) – available

Cameron Pedersen (knee) – season

Christian Petracca (knee) – season

Aidan Riley (knee) – test

Jack Trengove (foot) – season

Dom Tyson (hamstring) – season

Aaron vandenBerg (ankle) – season

[Yossarian 1,820]

What's wrong with your knee, Pedders?

[Earl Hood 6,086]

Frost? Not injured, not playing, not eligible for VFL finals? I was looking forward to see how he would go this year, big and fast but injured for all but the first few games.