Who is our best defensive forward?

[DeeZee 6,853]

With people picking best 22 teams and choosing forwards mainly as goal kicking options, I think it's important to note in today's game that there needs to be a player or players who can play on those damaging half backs such as Malcevski in round one,Gibbs and Goddard and the like.

So having said that who would you pick round one to play on Malcevski?

[hardtack 10,149]

With people picking best 22 teams and choosing forwards mainly as goal kicking options, I think it's important to note in today's game that there needs to be a player or players who can play on those damaging half backs such as Malcevski in round one,Gibbs and Goddard and the like.

So having said that who would you pick round one to play on Malcevski?

If he is picked, possibly Pedersen... purely because of his experience playing in the back line.

[s-t-i-n-g-a 439]

I would like to see Garland tried in the role.

[Beats 190]

Who's our best defensive forward? Probably Dawes. Not much competition though...

Who would play on Malceski. JKH?

[DeeZee 6,853]

Pederson and Dawes are good defensively but do the have the run, perhaps a leaner Pedrson could do the job .

Edited February 12, 2015 by DeeZee

[The Chazz 4,077]

Watts if fit.

[Bombay Airconditioning 5,987]

Watts if fit.

Could you please explain your reasoning behind Watts.

Cheers.

[Ted Lasso 17,125]

Rohan bail.

[Bingo 241]

Rohan bail.

x2

[nutbean 8,837]

It shouldn't be but it is Dawes.

[John Dee 439]

Jeremy Howe

[Demon Jack 6,388]

Probably Bail. Good endurance, can lay a tackle and is known to kick the odd goal.

Edited February 12, 2015 by Demon Jack

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

Watts if fit.

Could you please explain your reasoning behind Watts.

Cheers.

One would say that Billy is just trying to take the P155 out of anyone that responded.

He won.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

Lumumba

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

JKH for me. He can chase and tackle plus his disposal of the ball is pretty good. If bail gets it he turns it over.

[Josh 1,420]

Is this a role for Bernie Vince?

[DeeZee 6,853]

I'm thinking Bail, Kent ,Salem as they have to be able to run well cover ground quickly and snaffle goals when the opportunity arises.

Pedersons preseason has been interesting as he has lost weight and toned down, he has good endurance,so being lighter might give him a bit more closing speed. JKH could be a little short for the role.

[The Chazz 4,077]

Could you please explain your reasoning behind Watts.

Cheers.

I was responding to the question in the OP, as opposed to the thread title.

I think Watts is capable of playing on a Malceski type. He has the engine to go with Goddard (although let's not forget mckenzie's job on Goddard a couple of seasons back.

If the question is about our best defensive forward, that would be Garlett.

I don't think my Watts response is taking anywhere near the quantity of urine as those who have said Dawes. Regardless of which question they chose to answer, Dawes is far from the answer to either of them.

[The Chazz 4,077]

Could you please explain your reasoning behind Watts.

Cheers.

I also love your method of posting. Question someone's answer/opinion without expressing your own. Interesting behaviour-some would say troll-like.

[The Chazz 4,077]

Could you please explain your reasoning behind Watts.

Cheers.

And one more "Al" - the OP asked who would play on Malceski. In your current starting 22 on another thread, you have Watts and Kent on HFF. Given Malceski is a HBF, who would he go to in your team, Kent or Watts? Edited February 12, 2015 by billy2803

[Ted Lasso 17,125]

Colin sylvia?

[CBDees 3,162]

And one more "Al" - the OP asked who would play on Malceski. In your current starting 22 on another thread, you have Watts and Kent on HFF. Given Malceski is a HBF, who would he go to in your team, Kent or Watts?

It will be the defender who elects who he plays on, not the other way around!

[The Chazz 4,077]

It will be the defender who elects who he plays on, not the other way around!

Not always, and it's a changing landscape, especially with the increase in the importance of the HBF.

A couple of years ago Watts played a dedicated defensive HFF role on Sam Fisher against St Kilda. Watts got towelled up, but his role as a HFF was to go to their running HBF. Dunn used to be a great defensive HFF, as he would kick goals.

Can't remember who the player is, maybe at Adelaide, that Roos had one of our players tag off a HBF last season.

[The Chazz 4,077]

It will be the defender who elects who he plays on, not the other way around!

And one more "Al" - the OP asked who would play on Malceski. In your current starting 22 on another thread, you have Watts and Kent on HFF. Given Malceski is a HBF, who would he go to in your team, Kent or Watts?

Also, CBDees, I think I have clearly indicated in the post you quoted, that the defender is choosing who he plays on. I've highlighted the main bit for your benefit...

[Coup Cooper 610]

Probably Bail. Good endurance, can lay a tackle and is known to kick the odd goal.

Didn't rate this guy until the end of last year.. Forever held a grudge when he couldn't make the distance from 45 against Collingwood in 2010 rd2. But he has turned the corner.. Lets hope Roo's turns him into a kirk like figure!