On good authority/ The "good" mail....

[Arrow 1,257]

Let's get it back on track. I have it on good authority that if we can satisfy the Giants Kristian Jaksch is keen to play for Melbourne. Both Tyson and Viney are key pieces in his decision. Carlton are super keen and the bidding will be against them.

Good authority that Mitch Grigg will be hunted. He was interested in our approach last year but Adelaide promised him game time. This year he's been completely burned by them. Hoping mid 50's, Viv Michie style pick.

Finally, I have it on great authority that Frawley won't be a Demon next year.

[the grint 71]

Let's get it back on track. I have it on good authority that if we can satisfy the Giants Kristian Jaksch is keen to play for Melbourne. Both Tyson and Viney are key pieces in his decision. Carlton are super keen and the bidding will be against them.

Good authority that Mitch Grigg will be hunted. He was interested in our approach last year but Adelaide promised him game time. This year he's been completely burned by them. Hoping mid 50's, Viv Michie style pick.

Finally, I have it on great authority that Frawley won't be a Demon next year.

Interesting, thanks Arrow.

Any idea where Frawley is off to?

And do you reckon his compo pick is enough to get Shiel and Jaksch?

[nutbean 8,838]

And do you reckon his compo pick is enough to get Shiel and Jaksch?

You do realise that the compo pick we will possibly get and whether it is enough to entice players from other clubs are two different issues ?

Edited July 29, 2014 by nutbean

[Satyriconhome 10,339]

Let's get it back on track. I have it on good authority that if we can satisfy the Giants Kristian Jaksch is keen to play for Melbourne. Both Tyson and Viney are key pieces in his decision. Carlton are super keen and the bidding will be against them.

Good authority that Mitch Grigg will be hunted. He was interested in our approach last year but Adelaide promised him game time. This year he's been completely burned by them. Hoping mid 50's, Viv Michie style pick.

Finally, I have it on great authority that Frawley won't be a Demon next year.

What authority, the Herald Sun?, the Age?, Damian Barrett, last time I spoke to him, he promised me he hadn't made a decision as yet

[the grint 71]

Yeah nutbean, I was just wondering in Arrows opinion if that would hypothetically satisfy GWS if say Jaksch and Shiel wanted to "go home".

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

What authority, the Herald Sun?, the Age?, Damian Barrett, last time I spoke to him, he promised me he hadn't made a decision as yet

promises, sadly mean nothing in modern day sport mate.

[sue 9,000]

If the good authority has told Arrow why hasn't the good authority told Roos? And then why is Frawley not playing at Casey?

Edited July 30, 2014 by sue

[nutbean 8,838]

What authority, the Herald Sun?, the Age?, Damian Barrett, last time I spoke to him, he promised me he hadn't made a decision as yet

Hey Saty - can I ask - how do you find Damien Barrett ? It is interesting that sometimes the public personae can be totally different to what you get when you have a quiet one on one conversation. It can be a much more positive experience than expected or conversely much worse ! ( Not to get political but I didn't have much time for Peter Reith or Peter Costello - I spent an afternoon at the football with both of them on separate occasions - one of them went up in my estimation and the other was even worse than I expected)

[dee-luded 2,959]

Let's get it back on track. I have it on good authority that if we can satisfy the Giants Kristian Jaksch is keen to play for Melbourne. Both Tyson and Viney are key pieces in his decision. Carlton are super keen and the bidding will be against them.

Good authority that Mitch Grigg will be hunted. He was interested in our approach last year but Adelaide promised him game time. This year he's been completely burned by them. Hoping mid 50's, Viv Michie style pick.

Finally, I have it on great authority that Frawley won't be a Demon next year.

thanks arrow, like you trajectory.

[nutbean 8,838]

If the good authority has told Arrow why hasn't the good authority told Roos? And then why is Frawley not playing at Casey?

Because as stated on many occasions - players don't inform their clubs of their intentions for that very reason - being dropped. Players have contractual obligations - they can be incentivised in their contract on number of games played, goals kicked, finish in the best and fairest etc. So it may cost them financially to be dropped. To what end does it help the club to know now that he won't be at the Demons next year. The argument of playing someone else in his place is more than countered with the argument that we want to win games. And the preplanning/list management argument is a nonsense. The list managers will have contingencies for him staying and leaving as they would for most uncontracted players.

To date two players have acknowledged prior to seasons end that they were going - Bock with one game to go ( who was promptly dropped) and Davis who was injured and wasnt going to play again anyway.

[Satyriconhome 10,339]

Hey Saty - can I ask - how do you find Damien Barrett ? It is interesting that sometimes the public personae can be totally different to what you get when you have a quiet one on one conversation. It can be a much more positive experience than expected or conversely much worse ! ( Not to get political but I didn't have much time for Peter Reith or Peter Costello - I spent an afternoon at the football with both of them on separate occasions - one of them went up in my estimation and the other was even worse than I expected)

I meant Frawley, not Barrett, although I have spoken to Barrett once, and he is a [censored]

[Satyriconhome 10,339]

Because as stated on many occasions - players don't inform their clubs of their intentions for that very reason - being dropped. Players have contractual obligations - they can be incentivised in their contract on number of games played, goals kicked, finish in the best and fairest etc. So it may cost them financially to be dropped. To what end does it help the club to know now that he won't be at the Demons next year. The argument of playing someone else in his place is more than countered with the argument that we want to win games. And the preplanning/list management argument is a nonsense. The list managers will have contingencies for him staying and leaving as they would for most uncontracted players.

To date two players have acknowledged prior to seasons end that they were going - Bock with one game to go ( who was promptly dropped) and Davis who was injured and wasnt going to play again anyway.

That's not the question, Arrow needs to state why he is so confident in his assertion about Frawley, would think that Roos wouldn't want to be messed with so if there was even the slightest suspicion that Frawley had made up his mind and was going, he wouldn't be in the team....just saying

[timD 994]

That's not the question, Arrow needs to state why he is so confident in his assertion about Frawley, would think that Roos wouldn't want to be messed with so if there was even the slightest suspicion that Frawley had made up his mind and was going, he wouldn't be in the team....just saying

He does not have to do anything of the sort. You determine how much confidence you have in him. He does not have to do a damn thing to inspire you. It is by his actions you shall know him...or that sort of thing.

Example a = GNF. If he said we'll have a flag by 2015, I'd be placing bets now. He has earnt that by being consistent and getting hard-to-predict things right from a long way out. That is how you know what to believe.

[SaberFang 7,151]

This thread desperately needs some GNF..

[Satyriconhome 10,339]

He does not have to do anything of the sort. You determine how much confidence you have in him. He does not have to do a damn thing to inspire you. It is by his actions you shall know him...or that sort of thing.

Example a = GNF. If he said we'll have a flag by 2015, I'd be placing bets now. He has earnt that by being consistent and getting hard-to-predict things right from a long way out. That is how you know what to believe.

Ok, I have no confidence it what he is saying about Frawley leaving

[Sir Why You Little 36,587]

Ok, I have no confidence it what he is saying about Frawley leaving

so you think he is staying do you?

[Yossarian 1,820]

Have heard that Shannon Byrnes might be retiring from AFL this year. Make of it what you will.

(Source: MFC website)

[Vipercrunch 2,820]

Frawley may have made up his mind already but unless he deliberately makes that decision public, I doubt any coach would drop him based on rumours, however strong they are. In other words, just because Frawley is still playing seniors isn't evidence either way that he has made up his mind, just that he hasn't made a decision public.

For what it's worth, I think he is leaving. He played the "I want to see the clubs direction" card. I think we have all seen the clubs direction and he still hasn't signed on. When it goes on this long, Cloke aside, it seems to end up with the player leaving.

I think the AFL is heading towards the NRL model of announcing player movement during the season. Hard to know how it will work out for the AFL, but I think everyone is getting sick of the rumours and questions that hang around for so long.

[rjay 24,577]

Frawley may have made up his mind already but unless he deliberately makes that decision public, I doubt any coach would drop him based on rumours, however strong they are. In other words, just because Frawley is still playing seniors isn't evidence either way that he has made up his mind, just that he hasn't made a decision public.

For what it's worth, I think he is leaving. He played the "I want to see the clubs direction" card. I think we have all seen the clubs direction and he still hasn't signed on. When it goes on this long, Cloke aside, it seems to end up with the player leaving.

I think the AFL is heading towards the NRL model of announcing player movement during the season. Hard to know how it will work out for the AFL, but I think everyone is getting sick of the rumours and questions that hang around for so long.

I don't think there is any reason to head towards the NRL model, it doesn't work for them at all and in effect diminishes their competition to a feeder comp for state of origin where the passion remains. I actually prefer the 'rpfc' model.

[Machsy 2,858]

Frawley hasn't made a decision until he has personally told satyricon that he has made a decision, ok?

Why is it so hard for people to understand..?

[dazzledavey36 52,709]

I played with chips best mate last year, he was traveling up to play etc.. anyways I remember last year he mentioned how disgruntled he was and number of clubs made contact to his manager one was including Gold Coast and Hawthorn. After the season finished he had brief meetings with them in regards to next year and what his plans for were and stuff..

Chip is as good as gone. He is also chasing cash aswell even though he has mentioned in the media it wasn't. Its a massive cop out.

[sue 9,000]

Because as stated on many occasions - players don't inform their clubs of their intentions for that very reason - being dropped. Players have contractual obligations - they can be incentivised in their contract on number of games played, goals kicked, finish in the best and fairest etc. So it may cost them financially to be dropped. To what end does it help the club to know now that he won't be at the Demons next year. The argument of playing someone else in his place is more than countered with the argument that we want to win games. And the preplanning/list management argument is a nonsense. The list managers will have contingencies for him staying and leaving as they would for most uncontracted players.

To date two players have acknowledged prior to seasons end that they were going - Bock with one game to go ( who was promptly dropped) and Davis who was injured and wasnt going to play again anyway.

That all makes sense, but it implies that Arrow's source is unreliable because no player manager or player wishing to play their cards close to their chest would tell anyone for it to leak to Arrow.

For what it is worth ($0) I'd put my money on Frawley leaving.

[nutbean 8,838]

Frawley may have made up his mind already but unless he deliberately makes that decision public, I doubt any coach would drop him based on rumours, however strong they are. In other words, just because Frawley is still playing seniors isn't evidence either way that he has made up his mind, just that he hasn't made a decision public.

For what it's worth, I think he is leaving. He played the "I want to see the clubs direction" card. I think we have all seen the clubs direction and he still hasn't signed on. When it goes on this long, Cloke aside, it seems to end up with the player leaving.

I think the AFL is heading towards the NRL model of announcing player movement during the season. Hard to know how it will work out for the AFL, but I think everyone is getting sick of the rumours and questions that hang around for so long.

I agree with this...except ...

I don't know if we are heading down the NRL line as we have a far more complex system than the NRL - NRL players have a contract and that's it - when its up you can re-sign or move on so it is much easier for players to move in the NRL than the AFL. We have a National draft and PSD - so how can a non free agent player announce that he is leaving to go to another club - a deal may not get done ?

It would only work for Free agents - they are the only player category who could announce prior to the end of the season that they are going and where they going to.

I despise all this speculation so I actually prefer the NRL transparency. It would hurt to see a player in your colours this weekend who you know will be at another club next but is it any worse than the current Scully/Ablett/Franklin/Frawley charade ?

[nutbean 8,838]

Frawley may have made up his mind already but unless he deliberately makes that decision public, I doubt any coach would drop him based on rumours, however strong they are. In other words, just because Frawley is still playing seniors isn't evidence either way that he has made up his mind, just that he hasn't made a decision public.

For what it's worth, I think he is leaving. He played the "I want to see the clubs direction" card. I think we have all seen the clubs direction and he still hasn't signed on. When it goes on this long, Cloke aside, it seems to end up with the player leaving.

I think the AFL is heading towards the NRL model of announcing player movement during the season. Hard to know how it will work out for the AFL, but I think everyone is getting sick of the rumours and questions that hang around for so long.

I agree with this...except ...

I don't know if we are heading down the NRL line as we have a far more complex system than the NRL - NRL players have a contract and that's it - when its up you can re-sign or move on so it is much easier for players to move in the NRL than the AFL. We have a National draft and PSD - so how can a non free agent player announce that he is leaving to go to another club - a deal may not get done ?

It would only work for Free agents - they are the only player category who could announce prior to the end of the season that they are going and where they going to.

I despise all this speculation so I actually prefer the NRL transparency. It would hurt to see a player in your colours this weekend who you know will be at another club next but is it any worse than the current Scully/Ablett/Franklin/Frawley charade ?

[rjay 24,577]

I agree with this...except ...

I don't know if we are heading down the NRL line as we have a far more complex system than the NRL - NRL players have a contract and that's it - when its up you can re-sign or move on so it is much easier for players to move in the NRL than the AFL. We have a National draft and PSD - so how can a non free agent player announce that he is leaving to go to another club - a deal may not get done ?

It would only work for Free agents - they are the only player category who could announce prior to the end of the season that they are going and where they going to.

I despise all this speculation so I actually prefer the NRL transparency. It would hurt to see a player in your colours this weekend who you know will be at another club next but is it any worse than the current Scully/Ablett/Franklin/Frawley charade ?

Ask Cam Smith what he thinks of it. He much prefers our system, I would much rather keep some degree of passion in the game despite the speculation. The only real passion in league is for State of Origin now because it can't be diluted, play around with our game and it would be a major mistake.